We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.
1. A sentimental song plaque that'll showcase their favourite tune. Reviewers say the process is super speedy and love that they can use their own photos as the album cover art to make it even more personal.
Get it from StaatsCustoms on Etsy for $78+. Available in three styles with three stand options.
2. A wooden watch you can get with a message of your choice etched on the back of its face. Reviewers say the engraving comes out super clean and that it's the perfect gift for anyone who has a reaction to metals (because it's mainly made of wood and leather).
3. A stunning coin necklace that'll adorn your significant other with luxury. Reviewers say the chain is dainty, but strong and that it isn't irritating to their skin whatsoever.
4. An iron-forged bottle opener that'll come in handy every time they crack a cold one. Reviewers love the solid, rugged feel of it and say that it's super durable.
Get it from BlackDogIronWorks on Etsy for $26.58+.
5. An impressive chess set that'll look beautiful on their coffee table. Reviewers love that each piece was carved by hand and say that its rustic aesthetic elevates their playing experience.
Get it from Deepearthsource on Etsy for $127.34+ (originally $141.49+). Available with or without a custom engraving.
6. A rose petal-infused massage oil, so you can give them the sensual rubdown they deserve. It's made with all-natural vegan ingredients that won't irritate their skin and has a delicate scent that won't overwhelm their senses.
Get it from LaMarcotterie on Etsy for $28.
7. A necklace with their birth flower hand stamped onto the pendant. Reviewers rave about the quality of the necklace and say the charming packaging it comes in is personal and clearly wrapped with care.
Get it from EmeryandOpal on Etsy for $31.91+. Available with birth flowers from January—December with 25 chain styles.
8. A leather belt you can customize by adding their initials onto one of the loops. It's subtle, thoughtful, and practical — which is the best kind of gift, if you ask me.
Get it from PolLeatherStudio on Etsy for $85.41+ (originally $172.83+). Available in three colours and two packaging options.
9. A minimalist ring they can stack with other bands or wear on its own. You can personalize it by getting the letter of their first name engraved onto it, and you can even specify if you'd like it in upper or lower case.
Get it from MisoaJewelry on Etsy for $276.75 (originally $369). Available in white, yellow, and rose gold and in sizes 4—10.5.
10. A map print of their favourite place in the world. Whether that's the town they were born in or the city where you met each other, it's customizable, so it's totally up to you.
You might want to pair it with a frame, too.
Get it from SunWallArt on Etsy for $35+. Available in three sizes.
11. An adorable custom spoon they'll appreciate if they just can't get enough of cheesy puns. You can get it as a teaspoon for their morning coffee or a tablespoon for their late-night ice cream binge.
Just enter the date you want stamped onto your spoon and they'll do the rest.
Get it from ImpressionsStamped on Etsy for $22+. Available in two sizes and in a customizable peanut butter spoon.
12. A fancy pocket knife they'll be happy to have on camping trips. You can get the rosewood handle engraved in one of four style options for an added personal touch.
Get it from JMlabonneimpression on Etsy for $54.90+. Available in four styles and with or without the wooden case.
14. Their pet's portrait in watercolour, because their fur baby deserves some love this Valentine's day, too. You can get up to four pets painted in one portrait, so if they have multiple pets, you won't have to pick favourites!
15. A super-cute Valentine's Day card that'll impress your beau who loves all things spooky (especially if you aren't exactly an artiste). It's blank inside, so you'll have the whole card to write all of your sentimental sweet nothings on.
It comes with a blank envelope, too.
Get it from WhichisWitch on Etsy for $8.
16. A leatherbound flask you can customize with their initials, a date, or even an inside joke. Reviewers love all of the colour options and that it comes with cleaning instructions to make sure it gets the care it requires.
Get it from CabinLeatherGoods for $42. Available in six base colours and 12 thread colours.
17. A unique line art portrait that'll showcase a sweet memory of the two of you, without being too showy. Just attach a reference photo and any text you'd like to add, and voilà! A handmade, sentimental Valentine's Day gift they'll swoon over.
It comes with the rustic wooden stand, too.
Get it from INKSCRPT on Etsy for $46.99. Also available in a rectangle cut.
18. A rose quartz ring dish that'll charge up their favourite bling with ~romantic~ energy. If your significant other uses crystals, they'll already know that rose quartz is the stone of universal love — and will appreciate the intimate gesture.
Get it from houseandhoneyco on Etsy for $50.
19. An engraved compass they'll appreciate if they work away from home or if you're in a long-distance relationship. It's especially great if they love to camp and occasionally need to know which way is north — otherwise, it's a lovely collector's item, too.
Get it from EliteCustomeDesignUSA on Etsy for $38.55+ (originally $77.11+). Available in eight engraving options and with or without a leather case.
20. A personalized cheese board that'll impress their inner chef. Reviewers love how sweet, simple, and functional these boards are, and that each one is made with exceptional craftsmanship.
Get it from SugarTreeGallery on Etsy for $53.23+ (originally $62.63+). Available in four wood species.
21. An organic self-care set that'll help them unwind and relax. Reviewers are obsessed with the smell of everything it comes with, but love that there are unscented options for anyone with a sensitivity to fragrance.
It comes with a lotion bar, two soaps, and two lip balms.
Get it from BotanyBarnCanada on Etsy for $45.
22. A sterling silver guitar pick that'll hands down be the boujiest (and cutest) pick they've ever jammed with. You can decide what message you'd like to include, or stick to the puntastic "I pick you."
Get it from BeachCoveJewelry on Etsy for $53.09.
23. A handmade docking station that'll save their desk or bedside table from clutter. Add an engraving to make it personal, or gift it as is if your OTL prefers to keep things simple.
Get it from JMlabonneimpression on Etsy for $57.99. Available in eight engravement styles.
24. A wood bound recipe book they can use to start their own personal food bible. You can customize it with an engraving of their name and choose the cover design, too.
You'll even have the option to choose what kind of paper goes inside.
Get it from WoodCardGifts on Etsy for $51.85+. Available in six sizes and in four wood species.
25. A constellation necklace that'll match their star sign. If your Valentine rocks a dainty or minimalist style, then they'll love this handmade gift.
It'll arrive in an embossed jewelry box, so you won't have to fuss over wrapping it.
Get it from Potionumber9 on Etsy for $43.80+. Available in all 12 star signs and 11 lengths.
26. A thoughtful keychain charm that'll remind them to stay safe on the road. It's perfect if your sweetheart drives for work or y'all are in a long-distance relationship that requires a lot of travelling to see one another.
Get it from StampOutLoudShop on Etsy for $17.99+. Available in sets of one or two.
27. And finally, a leather wallet that's both stylish and durable. You can request an engraving on the front, inside, or both to make it ultra personal.
Get it from CaglarCreations on Etsy for $60+ (originally $120+).
Have a happy Valentine's day, y'all!
