Skip To Content

    18 Food Combinations That Sound Weird As Heck, But People Absolutely Swear By

    "Put peanuts IN your Coca-Cola!"

    Hello, my name is Allie. I'm a 27-year-old grown woman and I will put honey mustard on absolutely anything. No, seriously. Anything. Don't try me. You should see the horrified look on the waiters' faces everywhere I go.

    NBC

    So this week when Reddit user llamashortcake asked, "What is your favorite 'I know it sounds weird, but just trust me' food combination?" I can say I honestly felt seen.

    ABC

    Here are just a FEW of the most "What the sweet heck? Okay, you got me, I'll try it once..." responses:

    1. "Quesadillas with marinara sauce.'"

    WorldBlackened

    2. "Black coffee with a tiny pad of butter, a little bit of sugar, and a pinch of garlic powder. Weird, yes, but it tastes like a meal and curbs my appetite, so it's perfect when I'm in a rush or can't handle food."

    XWitchyGirlX

    3. "I love putting maple syrup IN my scrambled eggs."

    Cylasbreakdown

    New Line Cinema

    4. "Macaroni and cheese with Worcestershire sauce."

    youdrivemecrazy13

    5. "Pizza rolls done? Dip them in some French onion dip for some next level enjoyment."

    BogeyBogeyBogey

    6. "Take a bite of a pretzel rod and then a sip of Sprite."

    ieatsilicagel

    20th Century Fox

    7. "Strawberry jam and mozzarella cheese on whole grain bread."

    finalsalvo

    8. "Peanut butter and bacon sandwiches."

    MartenBroadcloak1974

    9. "Put peanuts IN your Coca-Cola!"

    ScriabinFanatic

    Universal Pictures

    10. "Pickles, cream cheese, and salami in a roll-up."

    cooka22

    11. "Cake frosting on graham crackers."

    younopeme

    12. "Peanut butter and BBQ chips sandwiches!"

    kittycat716

    Screen Gems

    13. "Grilled cheese with pickles and sauteed onions."

    LunaticLooking4

    14. "Not me, but my grandma LOVED mayonnaise, peanut butter, tomato, and cucumber on her sandwiches."

    whodat773

    15. "Make any sandwich using waffles instead of sliced bread or a roll."

    cswimc

    Disney

    16. "Shredded cheddar cheese on French toast with syrup drizzled in top."

    novakanet

    17. "A family favorite is 'chopped olive sandwiches.' Chopped black olives mixed with mayo, then spread on to white bread. It HAS to be white bread, just trust me."

    DeuceOfWar

    18. ''Not one I personally consider rare or weird, but I love french fries dipped in ice cream/milk shakes."

    thisisausername5002

    So there ya have it! Would you be willing to try any of these? What's YOUR personal favorite "weird" food combination? Sound off in the comments below! I'll be here, drowning stuff in honey mustard.

    Universal Studios

    Some stories have been edited for length and/or clarity. H/T Reddit.