Who Was Your First Musical Crush?

24 really cute New Yorkers told BuzzFeed who they first swooned over in the music world. Their answers ranged from Chris Brown to Kim Gordon. So, tell us — who was YOUR first musical heartthrob?

1. Elijah, Joan Jett

Macey J. Foronda

2. Zelis, Dave Matthews

Macey J. Foronda

3. Alex, Kim Gordon of Sonic Youth

Macey J. Foronda

4. Antoine, Janet Jackson

Macey J. Foronda

5. Myron, Nona Hendryx of Labelle

Macey J. Foronda

6. Dylan, Kim Deal of The Pixies and The Breeders

Macey J. Foronda

7. Demi and friends, Chris Brown

Macey J. Foronda

8. Zachary, Mika

Macey J. Foronda

9. Melanie, Dave Gahan of Depeche Mode

Macey J. Foronda

10. Kevin, Mary J. Blige

Macey J. Foronda

11. Sorelle, Ray Davies of The Kinks

Macey J. Foronda

12. Isabella, Aaron Carter

Macey J. Foronda

13. David, Susanna Hoffs of The Bangles

Macey J. Foronda

14. Poundo, Michael Jackson

Macey J. Foronda

15. Matty, Axl Rose

Macey J. Foronda

16. Alain, Sylvie Vartan

Macey J. Foronda

17. Cheyenne, Usher

Macey J. Foronda

18. Chris, Miley Cyrus

Macey J. Foronda

19. ???, Alicia Keys

Macey J. Foronda

20. Gil, Peggy Lee

Macey J. Foronda

21. Steven, Danger Mouse

Macey J. Foronda

22. Gorgeous, Omarion of B2K

Macey J. Foronda

23. Ace, Jimmy Page

Macey J. Foronda

24. Roman, self-explanatory

Macey J. Foronda

All images by Macey J. Foronda for BuzzFeed.