10. Buck O'Neil
9. Andrew "Rube" Foster
8. James "Biz" Mackey
7. Walter "Buck" Leonard
6. Willie Wells
5. James "Cool Papa" Bell
4. Joe Williams
3. John Henry "Pop" Lloyd
2. Josh Gibson
1. Oscar Charleston
A note about statistics: These numbers we do have available to us regarding these players are primarily due to a great effort by the folks at Baseball Reference to collect Negro Leagues numbers in one place. That said, statistics in the leagues were incomplete and some are lost to history, so the career numbers for these players were likely actually much higher in most cases.