First, a few notes.
Who Qualifies: I ranked only superstars who were part of the active wrestling roster at some point between 2000 and 2009. This excludes other personnel such as valets, commentators, managers, general managers, and legends or celebrities making cameo appearances. Even though many of them saw ring time once in a while, if they weren't in a primarily-wrestling role at some point, they were not ranked.
Wrestlers also had to have been part of the main roster, resulting in at least one match on RAW, Smackdown, ECW or a pay-per-view. Talent that was in OVW or FCW was excluded, despite making occasional appearances on secondary shows like Heat and Velocity.
How They Were Ranked: Rankings were based on the quality of the wrestler's performance. Much of it came to in-ring ability, ring psychology, character, and storylines/feuds. This is somewhat unfair to the talented individuals who did not get much of a chance to shine, and for that their potential was somewhat considered, but ultimately it came down to what was actually proven.
Also, only the years 2000-2009 (and in WWE) were considered. This means that work in other decades (80's, 90's, 10's) and in other promotions (WCW, ECW, TNA) was not part of the equation.
238. The Heartthrobs
237. Amish Roadkill
235. Mideon
234. Ryan Braddock
233. Tony Mamaluke
232. The Gymini
231. Mean Street Posse
230. Kizarny
229. Alicia Fox
228. Kronik
227. Buff Bagwell
226. The Bellas
225. Stacy Keibler
224. Jesus
223. Kelly Kelly
222. CW Anderson
221. Shawn Stasiak
220. Braden Walker
219. Nidia
218. Torrie Wilson
217. Dawn Marie
216. Danny Doring
215. The Headbangers
214. Gangrel
212. Maria Kanellis
211. The Dudebusters
210. The Dicks
209. Christy Hemme
208. Johnny "The Bull" Stamboli
207. Nathan Jones
206. DJ Gabriel
205. The Blue Meanie
204. Eve Torres
203. Ashley Massaro
202. Layla El
201. Eric Escobar
200. The Boogeyman
199. The Godfather
198. Mike Awesome
197. Gunner Scott
196. Daniel Puder
195. Colin Delaney
194. Bam Neely
193. Scotty Goldman
192. Tyler Reks
191. "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan
190. Vance Archer
189. Ricky Ortiz
188. Big Daddy V
187. British Bulldog
186. The Basham Bros.
185. The Highlanders
184. Maven
183. Hornswoggle
182. Kenzo Suzuki
181. Sylvester Terkay
180. The Great Khali
179. Bill DeMott
178. Rodney Mack
177. Spirit Squad
176. Tyson Tomko
175. Heidenreich
174. Manu
173. Haku
172. Sakoda
171. Rosey
170. Curt Hawkins
169. Mark Jindrak
168. Ezekiel Jackson
167. Zack Ryder
166. Deuce & Domino
165. Matt Morgan
164. Jillian Hall
163. Marcus Cor Von
162. Luther Reigns
161. Mike Knox
160. Maryse
159. Sylvain Grenier
158. Rene Dupree
157. Grandmaster Sexay
156. Jacqueline
155. Road Warrior Animal
154. DH Smith
153. Big Vito
152. Orlando Jordan
151. Farooq
150. Candice Michelle
149. Balls Mahoney
148. Dave Taylor
147. Daivari
146. Big Bossman
145. Yoshi Tatsu
144. Bull Buchanan
143. D'Lo Brown
142. Christopher Nowinski
141. Matt Striker
140. Scotty 2 Hotty
139. Kenny Dykstra
138. Shannon Moore
137. Chuck Palumbo
136. Jesse
135. Justin Credible
134. Zach Gowen
133. Taka Michinoku
132. Jerry Lynn
131. Simon Dean
130. Katie Lea Burchill
129. Hardcore Holly
128. Rico Constantino
127. Rob Conway
126. Ultimo Dragon
125. Crash Holly
124. Perry Saturn
123. Psichosis
122. Juventud Guerrera
121. Super Crazy
120. Steve Blackman
119. Kevin Thorn
118. Joey Mercury
117. Essa Rios
116. Funaki
115. Nunzio
114. Vladimir Kozlov
113. Michelle McCool
112. Gene Snitsky
111. Festus
110. R-Truth
109. Dean Malenko
108. Elijah Burke
107. Tyson Kidd
106. Drew McIntyre
105. Kid Kash
104. Trevor Murdoch
103. Lance Cade
102. Primo Colon
101. Tatanka
100. Scott Hall
99. Gail Kim
98. Kanyon
97. Eugene
96. Mr. Perfect
95. Stevie Richards
94. Chris Masters
93. Jimmy Wayne Yang
92. Tazz
91. A-Train
90. Road Dogg
89. Charlie Haas
88. Al Snow
87. Sandman
86. Mark Henry
85. Kevin Nash
84. Raven
83. Sheamus
82. Ivory
81. Chyna
80. Billy Kidman
79. Sabu
78. Diamond Dallas Page
77. Ted DiBiase Jr.
76. Cody Rhodes
75. Dolph Ziggler
74. Val Venis
73. Tommy Dreamer
72. Paul Burchill
71. X-Pac
70. Scott Steiner
69. Hulk Hogan
68. Jamie Noble
67. Rikishi
66. Test
65. Natalya Neidhart
64. Melina
63. Hurricane Helms
62. Muhammad Hassan
61. Evan Bourne
60. Billy Gunn
59. Spike Dudley
58. Sean O'Haire
57. The Miz
56. Paul London
55. Jazz
54. Jack Swagger
53. Cryme Tyme
52. Lance Storm
51. Santino Marella
50. Brian Kendrick
49. Goldust
48. Rhyno
47. John Bradshaw Layfield
46. Chavo Guerrero
45. Goldberg
44. Tajiri
43. Mr. Kennedy
42. Bobby Lashley
41. Finlay
40. Molly Holly
39. D-Von Dudley
38. Bubba Ray Dudley
37. Carlito
36. Big Show
35. Beth Phoenix
34. Mickie James
33. MVP
32. Umaga
31. Victoria
30. Kofi Kingston
29. Ric Flair
28. Batista
27. William Regal
26. Matt Hardy
25. John Morrison
24. Christian
23. Shelton Benjamin
22. Mick Foley
21. CM Punk
20. Lita
19. Trish Stratus
18. Brock Lesnar
17. Booker T
16. Kane
15. Randy Orton
14. Jeff Hardy
13. John Cena
12. The Rock
11. Rob Van Dam
10. Stone Cold Steve Austin
9. Chris Benoit
Though his place on this list is determined by his in-ring career alone, he deserves no other accolades or praise.