Can't top Paparazzi IMO, but this is still yet another masterpiece from GaGa. This woman is a force to be reckoned with.  Given that she has so many great videos, though, why isn't she including a DVD on The Fame Monster? That's kind of the only thing that's bothering me.

Not so much threatened by her Tim, as sick of her.

I'm not remotely interested in her music, but I appreciate the aesthetic and creativity that she brings to the typically bland and repetitive world of pop music entertainment. It's funny how much loathing she inspires in certain people who are completely unharmed by by her, other than in the sense that being challenged by something different threatens tiny little worlds.

title should be “Lady Gaga’s “Bad Music Video” Romance. so sick of her…

Bullshit Eurotrash club beats aside, it's cool that she got Guillermo del Toro to direct her video.

I love wierd, I seriously do. I am impressed by the Giant (figurative) artistic cajones this chick has. But could we just add a “Do Not watch before bedtime” tag for nightmare/insomnia prevention? Freaking Googly eyes and that “rah rah um ma ma” stuff will keep me up all night.

Some call this catchy, so is the Meow Mix jingle. That doesn't speak to me the anymore than this tripe does.  This is what Andy Warhol would have dreamt of for a porn if he was tripping on X. Forgettable, kitschy, and lacking any real substance.

Seriously, I can't stand anymore comments about how she's just this side of artsy us normal people can't understand. Sometimes a lack of talent and craziness equals a lack of talent and craziness. I won't forget those freaky huge eyes anytime soon.

A little bit of Silent Hill. I approve.

One large clusterfuck in my mind. I really think she's fucked my mind because I cant get that DAMNED hook out of my head. Her music is catchy… but nothing amazing. Her style, while original, verges on COMPLETE INSANITY!!! And she looks really nice without makeup. She needs to try a more natural look. Maybe then people would take her seriously.

i hate that i really really like this.

I adore her, she is so out there. I wonder why people freak out about her weird costumes, trashy lyrics, and seem to forget that once upon a time, Madonna made the same headlines? Lady Gaga is just doing it her way, not following the flock. Bravo.

Lady Gaga is a true innovator. I absolutely love everything about her. Only a very narrow minded and idiotic person could dislike her.

I wonder what she'd look like in jeans and a t-shirt.

I would be quite pleased to have nightmares tonight from this video, the would probably end as wet dreams.

She's absolutely gorgeous with three scoops of crazy! I think this is fab!

aesthetically, I like her style, but her music… meh. I could probably live without it

Thanks for the nightmares I'm gonna have later tonight, Gaga.

Hey, Matt, this is a winner: many things vampire and other neat literary allusions. I wonder, though, if she still likes “gays” (one would hope)? And I'd feel better if she had credited Jane Fonda for the bulk of the listless choreography. I was good when Jane did it, but a lot of time has passed. Thanks! It's a keeper for me.