Peeperoni Peepza Is Surprisingly Edible, Maybe Even Delicious

A Peep-graham cracker crust topped with Nutella, chocolate, more Peeps, coconut flakes, and peanuts. What could go wrong?

1. The producers of Good Morning America sent us 5,000+ Peeps to play with.

Macey J. Foronda

They asked us to make crazy stuff that they could put on TV.

ID: 1024139

2. First we tried to bake them into a ostrich egg cake.

Emily Fleischaker
ID: 1023966

3. That really didn’t work :(

Emily Fleischaker
ID: 1023968

4. Then we tried to melt them into fondue.

Emily Fleischaker
ID: 1023974

5. That looked pretty cool but tasted really gross.

Peeps don’t melt the way marshmallows do because they are covered in a thick layer of sugar, which both insulates the marshmallow part from melting, but burns quickly on the outside if placed directly in a pot. So to make a fondue, we learned that it’s best to combine Peeps with a little butter and cream. (You can also do this easily in the microwave.) The ratio of 10 Peeps to 1 tablespoon butter worked — we also added a tablespoon of cream. That combination was stable (stayed melty and gooey/didn’t break and separate) when sitting over low heat. But when we dipped fruit and crackers into it for a taste, we all had miserable sugar headaches instantly. FAIL.

ID: 1023999

6. Next we made a Peepsicle Punch…

Macey J. Foronda
ID: 1024010

7. …by freezing peeps into ice cubes using a muffin tray.

Macey J. Foronda
ID: 1024210
Macey J. Foronda
ID: 1024856

9. Peepsicle Punch

Serves 12

8-10 mint sprigs
2 liters store-bought lemonade (Our favorite brand is Newman’s Own Virgin Lemonade)
12 chick Peeps
4 liters plain seltzer water

Special equipment
1 12-cup muffin tin (silicone is best)

Fill muffin tin cups 1/2 full with water. Place in freezer for 1-2 hours, until frozen solid. Meanwhile, wash mint springs and put them in the lemonade bottle. Seal and shake, and let sit in fridge for an hour to infuse the flavor.

Remove ice tray from freezer and put peeps on top of ice blocks. Pour cold water into muffin cups to fill them to the top, then put back in freezer for another hour until frozen solid. Strain lemonade into punch bowl, add seller and Peepsicles. Serve immediately.

ID: 1024852

10. That was delightful because the Peeps look like they are floating in the punch.

ID: 1024017

11. It was also pretty popular around the office — once we added gin.

ID: 1024033

12. But the Peeps demanded even more.

ID: 1024228

13. So we made a Peepza. And it was surprisingly delicious!

Macey J. Foronda
ID: 1023927

14. Peeperoni Peepza

Recipe reluctantly yet blissfully created by Emily Fleischaker and Andrew Gauthier

Serves 6

For crust
12 graham crackers crushed (about 2 cups crumbs)
1 teaspoon kosher salt
10 yellow Peeps (3 oz)
1 tablespoon butter

For topping
3/4 cup Nutella
1 3-oz dark chocolate bar broken into small pieces
5 Peeps in whatever color you like
1 tablespoon shredded coconut
1 tablespoon chopped unsalted peanuts
kosher salt to taste

For crust
Preheat broiler. To make crumbs out of the crackers, put crackers in a plastic bag, seal bag, and whack with the back of a spoon. You want mostly small crumbs with some larger chunks mixed in. Add salt and stir to combine.

Microwave butter with 10 Peeps for 25 seconds, stir to combine. Coat your hands or a spoon with baking spray then work the melted marshmallow into the graham cracker crumbs. Press the mixture onto a greased baking sheet in one even layer, forming a 12-diameter circle. Allow crust to sit for 10 minutes — if possible in the fridge.

For topping
Microwave Nutella 30 seconds, then spread it onto the crust. Drop chocolate pieces onto the Nutella. Microwave Peeps for 10 seconds, then transfer to pizza with a spatula and place under the broiler for 1-2 minutes, until Peeps have browned and chocolate is melty. Top with coconut, chopped peanuts, and kosher salt. Serve warm.

ID: 1023903

15. We will be on Good Morning America today at 8 a.m. trying to recreate the Peepza — except six times larger — as quickly as possible.

Macey J. Foronda

Hopefully it will not be a disaster, but it’s definitely going to be a disaster.

ID: 1023857

Check out more articles on!

  Your Reaction?


    Now Buzzing