We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
1. A pack of butterfly hair clips that'll jazz up all your twists, buns, and ponytails. They're just like you remember: Packed with teensy teeth for gripping hair and brightly coloured so you can show off your personality.
2. An original Tamagotchi if the idea of taking care of a real pet is way too daunting, TBH. Reviewers say it's exactly the way they remember (right down to the original programming).
3. A pair of baggy jeans so you can finally ditch those suffocating skinnies. They even have an accent pleat if you're really jonesing for some '90s fashion flashbacks.
4. A classic 35mm camera for capturing all your favourite things. It produces a soft vignette with random light leaks so your photos will look just like they did in the '90s (with zero editing, too).
5. A set of classic Goosebumps novels if you're craving a lil' spine-tingling action (psst– Halloween is around the corner!). It comes in a anniversary-edition tin that'll keep them in perfect condition, too.
6. A pack of juicy Lip Smacker glosses that'll give your smoocher that enviable shine. Reviewers love the smooth, glossy formula and say it never feels goopy.
7. A device holder in the shape of your fave speedy hedgehog. It's perfectly profiled for your gaming controllers, but can just as easily keep your phone safe and sound, too.
8. A slouchy flannel shirt that'll pair perfectly with your grunge style revival. The material's been updated for this millennium with butter-soft rayon and a hint of stretch — hello, comfort!
9. A set of woven bracelets so you can finally cement your friendships (just like you did in homeroom). Reviewers love that they're adjustable, which means they're basically guaranteed to fit the wrists of all your pals.
10. A pair of flashy roller skates that'll help you perfect your fakie. According to reviewers, the fit is surprisingly comfortable and the wheels glide smooth as butter (so you won't take a painful tumble).
11. A bottle of nostalgia-inducing ck one perfume that'll transport both you and your nose back to the '90s. It's light and bright with notes of bergamot, cardamom, jasmine, and musk that reviewers swear smells fantastic on all genders.
12. An anthology of hip-hop's most iconic songs spanning the last four decades. It includes a ton of prolific artists (including Grandmaster Flash, Run DMC, and Queen Latifah) that'll take you on an auditory tour of your childhood.
13. A set of tattoo choker necklaces that'll show off your coolness to the world. They're just like you remember: stretchy, comfy, and cute as hell.
14. A pair of classic Doc Martens if you're on the hunt for the perfect fall shoe. Not only are they incredibly comfortable (reviewers love the sturdy, springy soles), they're also tough enough to withstand all kinds of wear and tear.
15. A pair of mini Super Soakers if you're craving a little aquatic assassination. These pint-sized water guns work just like the ones from your youth, with the added benefit of not taking up every inch of your apartment.
16. An upcycled tie-dyed sweatshirt that's as unique as you are. Reviewers love that it's perfectly oversized, making it a great combo with your fave vintage denim (or just a pair of leggings).
17. A pack of bike spoke beads so you can dress up your wheels. They're easy to clip on and reviewers say they don't make noise while you're riding (they're light enough to tinkle, instead of rattle).
18. And a pair of handlebar grips to complete the ensemble. Reviewers say they're comfy on hands and easy to install — they even come with streamers to boot!
19. A huge set of gel pens that come in just about every colour and finish imaginable. Each one has a comfy grip tip so your fingers won't chafe while you're doodling and reviewers love that they never dry out (even if you forget to put the cap back on).
20. A Clueless graphic tee because if you didn't love Cher's hilarious misadventures as a teen, then you're totally buggin'. Even though reviewers say it's soft enough to wear to bed, I can't imagine not rocking this at my next hang sesh.
21. A portable record player that'll transport you right back to your teenage bedroom (angst not included). It's updated for this century, too, with built-in stereo speakers and Bluetooth tech for easy streaming.
22. A pair of vintage Reebok Club Cs that'll make your feet go, "They just don't make 'em like they used to." Reviewers love that they're comfy straight outta the box so you can skip the dreaded breaking-in period.
23. A pack of shimmery scrunchies that'll look just cute in your hair as they will on your wrist. They're super gentle on brittle hair but reviewers say they're strong enough to hold even the thickest mane in place.
24. An oversized fanny pack if you want to live your best hands-free life. It's big enough to fit all your essentials (seriously — some reviewers even use it as a diaper bag) while being conveniently waterproof.
25. A Friends-inspired keychain you should definitely send to your best pal. It'll help boost their mood when they feel like it hasn't been their day, their week, OR their year.
26. And lastly, a box of magnets inspired by the greatest icons of the decade. We've got Britney, we've got Oprah, and we even have James Van Der Beek's iconic ugly cry from Dawson's Creek — need I say more?
Feeling pretty bad about leaving these gems in the past, TBH.
