back to top

11 '90s Heartthrobs: Then And Now

Time can be... telling. </3 Wonder what your fave '90s stars are doing now? Wonder no more!

Posted on

1. Devon Sawa

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Wire Image / Jeffrey Mayer

THEN: Making us wish we could make out with a ghost in Casper.

NOW: The lead in the 2015 horror flick The Exorcism of Molly Hartley.

CAREER HIGH: Convincing us we were all gonna die in Final Destination.

ICYMI: He was in that hilarious movie Idle Hands with Seth Green. Remember that one? With the possessed hand? Good sh*t right there.

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Wire Image / Jeffrey Mayer

THEN: Making us wish we could make out with a ghost in Casper.

NOW: The lead in the 2015 horror flick The Exorcism of Molly Hartley.

CAREER HIGH: Convincing us we were all gonna die in Final Destination.

ICYMI: He was in that hilarious movie Idle Hands with Seth Green. Remember that one? With the possessed hand? Good sh*t right there.

← Slide →
Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Wire Image / Jeffrey Mayer

THEN: Making us wish we could make out with a ghost in Casper.

NOW: The lead in the 2015 horror flick The Exorcism of Molly Hartley.

CAREER HIGH: Convincing us we were all gonna die in Final Destination.

ICYMI: He was in that hilarious movie Idle Hands with Seth Green. Remember that one? With the possessed hand? Good sh*t right there.

2. Claire Danes

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Wire Image / Jeff Vespa

THEN: Rolling her eyes as emo teen Angela in My So-Called Life.

NOW: Crying her way through Homeland, and pulling on our heartstrings each and every time.

CAREER HIGH: JULIET. BUT OF COURSE.

ICYMI: Brokedown Palace was one for the record books.

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Wire Image / Jeff Vespa

THEN: Rolling her eyes as emo teen Angela in My So-Called Life.

NOW: Crying her way through Homeland, and pulling on our heartstrings each and every time.

CAREER HIGH: JULIET. BUT OF COURSE.

ICYMI: Brokedown Palace was one for the record books.

← Slide →
Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Wire Image / Jeff Vespa

THEN: Rolling her eyes as emo teen Angela in My So-Called Life.

NOW: Crying her way through Homeland, and pulling on our heartstrings each and every time.

CAREER HIGH: JULIET. BUT OF COURSE.

ICYMI: Brokedown Palace was one for the record books.

3. Rachael Leigh Cook

Getty Images / The LIFE Picture Collection / Wire Image / JB Lacroix

THEN: Putting the SHE in She's All That.

NOW: Lending her voice to video games and Robot Chicken.


CAREER HIGH:
Josie and the Pussycats. <3


ICYMI:
Rachael Leigh Cook and Chad Michael Murray poked fun at overdramatic movie makeouts in the hilarious Funny or Die sketch #FirstKiss.

Getty Images / The LIFE Picture Collection / Wire Image / JB Lacroix

THEN: Putting the SHE in She's All That.

NOW: Lending her voice to video games and Robot Chicken.


CAREER HIGH:
Josie and the Pussycats. <3


ICYMI:
Rachael Leigh Cook and Chad Michael Murray poked fun at overdramatic movie makeouts in the hilarious Funny or Die sketch #FirstKiss.

← Slide →
Getty Images / The LIFE Picture Collection / Wire Image / JB Lacroix

THEN: Putting the SHE in She's All That.

NOW: Lending her voice to video games and Robot Chicken.


CAREER HIGH:
Josie and the Pussycats. <3


ICYMI:
Rachael Leigh Cook and Chad Michael Murray poked fun at overdramatic movie makeouts in the hilarious Funny or Die sketch #FirstKiss.

4. Thomas Ian Nicholas

The LIFE Picture Collection / Getty Images / Via Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images

THEN: Pitching in the pros with his magical arm in Rookie of the Year.

NOW: His plate is pretty full, as he has at least five movies coming out in 2015.

CAREER HIGH: All of the American Pies.

ICYMI: Yeah, he was in a couple episodes of Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman. Let us all never forget that show.

The LIFE Picture Collection / Getty Images / Via Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images

THEN: Pitching in the pros with his magical arm in Rookie of the Year.

NOW: His plate is pretty full, as he has at least five movies coming out in 2015.

CAREER HIGH: All of the American Pies.

ICYMI: Yeah, he was in a couple episodes of Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman. Let us all never forget that show.

← Slide →
The LIFE Picture Collection / Getty Images / Via Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images

THEN: Pitching in the pros with his magical arm in Rookie of the Year.

NOW: His plate is pretty full, as he has at least five movies coming out in 2015.

CAREER HIGH: All of the American Pies.

ICYMI: Yeah, he was in a couple episodes of Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman. Let us all never forget that show.

5. Nick Carter

Annamaria DiSanto / WireImage / Getty Images / Via Bill McCay / Getty Images

THEN: Globetrotting with the Backstreet Boys.

NOW: The star of his own reality show, I Heart Nick Carter.

CAREER HIGH: Sharing a bed with Paris Hilton.

ICYMI: Nick had a cameo role in the Seth Rogen romp, This Is the End.

Annamaria DiSanto / WireImage / Getty Images / Via Bill McCay / Getty Images

THEN: Globetrotting with the Backstreet Boys.

NOW: The star of his own reality show, I Heart Nick Carter.

CAREER HIGH: Sharing a bed with Paris Hilton.

ICYMI: Nick had a cameo role in the Seth Rogen romp, This Is the End.

← Slide →
Annamaria DiSanto / WireImage / Getty Images / Via Bill McCay / Getty Images

THEN: Globetrotting with the Backstreet Boys.

NOW: The star of his own reality show, I Heart Nick Carter.

CAREER HIGH: Sharing a bed with Paris Hilton.

ICYMI: Nick had a cameo role in the Seth Rogen romp, This Is the End.

6. Tatyana Ali

Ron Galella, Ltd. / WireImage / Getty Images / Via Jason LaVeris / FilmMagic / Getty Images

THEN: Playing the ever-so-adorable Ashley Banks in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.


NOW:
She's returning to the music scene and just dropped a new EP called Hello.

CAREER HIGH: Her chart-toppin' jam from 1998, "Daydreamin'."

ICYMI: She just wrapped four seasons of the TV One show Love That Girl!

Ron Galella, Ltd. / WireImage / Getty Images / Via Jason LaVeris / FilmMagic / Getty Images

THEN: Playing the ever-so-adorable Ashley Banks in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.


NOW:
She's returning to the music scene and just dropped a new EP called Hello.

CAREER HIGH: Her chart-toppin' jam from 1998, "Daydreamin'."

ICYMI: She just wrapped four seasons of the TV One show Love That Girl!

← Slide →
Ron Galella, Ltd. / WireImage / Getty Images / Via Jason LaVeris / FilmMagic / Getty Images

THEN: Playing the ever-so-adorable Ashley Banks in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.


NOW:
She's returning to the music scene and just dropped a new EP called Hello.

CAREER HIGH: Her chart-toppin' jam from 1998, "Daydreamin'."

ICYMI: She just wrapped four seasons of the TV One show Love That Girl!

7. Andrew Keegan

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / WireImage / Tommaso Boddi

THEN: Winning everyone's hearts as Joey Donner in 10 Things I Hate About You.

NOW: Well, he started his own religion, obviously. Worshippers can join hands and sing at Full Circle in Venice, CA.

CAREER HIGH: Starring alongside Julia Stiles and Josh Hartnett in O, the Shakespeare adaptation whose tagline, funnily enough, is "Everything Comes Full Circle."

ICYMI: Before Party of Five, Andrew was Magic Joel in the greatest '90s TV show ever created on Earth, Sabrina, the Teenage Witch.

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / WireImage / Tommaso Boddi

THEN: Winning everyone's hearts as Joey Donner in 10 Things I Hate About You.

NOW: Well, he started his own religion, obviously. Worshippers can join hands and sing at Full Circle in Venice, CA.

CAREER HIGH: Starring alongside Julia Stiles and Josh Hartnett in O, the Shakespeare adaptation whose tagline, funnily enough, is "Everything Comes Full Circle."

ICYMI: Before Party of Five, Andrew was Magic Joel in the greatest '90s TV show ever created on Earth, Sabrina, the Teenage Witch.

← Slide →
Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / WireImage / Tommaso Boddi

THEN: Winning everyone's hearts as Joey Donner in 10 Things I Hate About You.

NOW: Well, he started his own religion, obviously. Worshippers can join hands and sing at Full Circle in Venice, CA.

CAREER HIGH: Starring alongside Julia Stiles and Josh Hartnett in O, the Shakespeare adaptation whose tagline, funnily enough, is "Everything Comes Full Circle."

ICYMI: Before Party of Five, Andrew was Magic Joel in the greatest '90s TV show ever created on Earth, Sabrina, the Teenage Witch.

8. Zac Hanson

THEN: Drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.

NOW: Still drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.


CAREER HIGH:
Also drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.

ICYMI: He's the drummer for Hanson.

THEN: Drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.

NOW: Still drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.


CAREER HIGH:
Also drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.

ICYMI: He's the drummer for Hanson.

← Slide →

THEN: Drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.

NOW: Still drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.


CAREER HIGH:
Also drumming his lil heart out in Hanson.

ICYMI: He's the drummer for Hanson.

9. Larisa Oleynik

Getty Images / Film Magic, Inc. / Jeff Kravitz / CBS / CBS Photo Archive

THEN: The star of The Secret World of Alex Mack.

NOW: Has appeared regularly in shows like Hawaii Five-0 and Pretty Little Liars.

CAREER HIGH: Let's go with The Baby-Sitters Club.

ICYMI: Before Mack AND Baby-Sitters, Larisa appeared in Pete and Pete, kickstarting her TV stardom.

Getty Images / Film Magic, Inc. / Jeff Kravitz / CBS / CBS Photo Archive

THEN: The star of The Secret World of Alex Mack.

NOW: Has appeared regularly in shows like Hawaii Five-0 and Pretty Little Liars.

CAREER HIGH: Let's go with The Baby-Sitters Club.

ICYMI: Before Mack AND Baby-Sitters, Larisa appeared in Pete and Pete, kickstarting her TV stardom.

← Slide →
Getty Images / Film Magic, Inc. / Jeff Kravitz / CBS / CBS Photo Archive

THEN: The star of The Secret World of Alex Mack.

NOW: Has appeared regularly in shows like Hawaii Five-0 and Pretty Little Liars.

CAREER HIGH: Let's go with The Baby-Sitters Club.

ICYMI: Before Mack AND Baby-Sitters, Larisa appeared in Pete and Pete, kickstarting her TV stardom.

10. Jonathan Taylor Thomas

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Michael Ansell

THEN: Starring as the cutest Taylor, Randy Taylor, in Home Improvement.

NOW: Playing John Baker in Last Man Standing.

CAREER HIGH: The voice of Young Simba. Duh.

ICYMI: Don't miss JTT in the #InstaClassic Tom and Huck. Now available to own on VHS.

Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Michael Ansell

THEN: Starring as the cutest Taylor, Randy Taylor, in Home Improvement.

NOW: Playing John Baker in Last Man Standing.

CAREER HIGH: The voice of Young Simba. Duh.

ICYMI: Don't miss JTT in the #InstaClassic Tom and Huck. Now available to own on VHS.

← Slide →
Getty Images / Ron Galella Collection / Ron Galella / Michael Ansell

THEN: Starring as the cutest Taylor, Randy Taylor, in Home Improvement.

NOW: Playing John Baker in Last Man Standing.

CAREER HIGH: The voice of Young Simba. Duh.

ICYMI: Don't miss JTT in the #InstaClassic Tom and Huck. Now available to own on VHS.

11. Alicia Silverstone

Getty Images / Wire Image / Barry King / Alberto E. Rodriguez

THEN: Becoming the most quotable actress of all time in Clueless.

NOW: Regularly updating her vegan blog, The Kind Life.

CAREER HIGH: Locking lips with Brendan Fraser in Blast From the Past.

ICYMI: She was in that butter movie called Butter, alongside Jennifer Garner and Ty Burrell.

Getty Images / Wire Image / Barry King / Alberto E. Rodriguez

THEN: Becoming the most quotable actress of all time in Clueless.

NOW: Regularly updating her vegan blog, The Kind Life.

CAREER HIGH: Locking lips with Brendan Fraser in Blast From the Past.

ICYMI: She was in that butter movie called Butter, alongside Jennifer Garner and Ty Burrell.

← Slide →
Getty Images / Wire Image / Barry King / Alberto E. Rodriguez

THEN: Becoming the most quotable actress of all time in Clueless.

NOW: Regularly updating her vegan blog, The Kind Life.

CAREER HIGH: Locking lips with Brendan Fraser in Blast From the Past.

ICYMI: She was in that butter movie called Butter, alongside Jennifer Garner and Ty Burrell.

What if you woke up and it were the '90s all over again? IMAGINE! Find out exactly what that looks like on Hindsight, WEDNESDAYS + 10/9c on VH1.

Every. Tasty. Video. EVER. The new Tasty app is here!

Dismiss