Super Comfortable Shoes For Frequent Commuters, According To Reviewers Who Walk A Lot

This selection sneakers, flats, boots, and more will take you work and back comfortably.

Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's.

After a recent trip to New York City, where I trekked on foot to work and back, I finally understood the necessity of having a pair of office-appropriate shoes that are comfortable, supportive, and can withstand outdoor elements.

Cole Haan, Allbirds, Dansko

I had a hunch that frequent commuters everywhere have tried enough footwear to know which shoes fit the bill and which ones aren’t up to snuff. So, with the help of Reddit, online reviewers and recommendations from some of HuffPost’s very own commuters, I curated a list of comfortable options.

Whether it be a pair of machine-washable ballet flats, weather-ready lug-sole boots, or dress shoes that actually feel like sneakers, you’ll find something here that meets your commuting needs.

1. A chic pair of Mary Jane heels

Vivaia

Featuring a sturdy block heel and charming hints of vintage inspiration, these Mary Janes have been designed to be supremely comfortable. There's a padded heel patch, a roomy square toe that won't cinch toes, and a pressure-relieving insole with added arch support.

Promising review: "I love these. I work in NY and consistently on my feet. They are comfy and fashionable. The heel is perfect, especially for those of us who are always on the run." — Zoraida P.

Get them from Vivaia for $139 (available in women's sizes 5–11 and five colors).

2. A pair of water-and-stain-resistant sneakers

Thousand Fell

These city-perfect shoes can withstand everything from stains, to water, to stubborn odor thanks to their breathable construction and weatherproof coating. Sustainably made using all recycled materials, the Thousand Fell Lace-Ups have a cushioned insole for comfort as well. 

Promising review: "Honestly the best white sneaker. These things traveled with me to Disney, to Greece, to the Bahamas. They took at least 20,000 steps a day with me going to work, to dinner, to walking home. I am also not a 'gentle' person so I beat these things up and they still looked great. Also added bonus I can wear them on rainy days. And another added bonus, I returned my old pair to get recycled and recycled clothing so my new pair was discounted!" —Lea

Get them from Thousand Fell for $125 (available in women's sizes 5–10, men's sizes 8–13, and 15 colors).

3. A pair of supportive Cole Haan dress shoes

Amazon

A perfect combination between a classic-looking Oxford and a supportive sneaker, these Cole Haan favorites feature a contoured footbed that's responsive, flexible, and disperses weight evenly. The uppers are leather, and the outer sole is rubber and offers traction to help stop slipping on a variety of terrains. They are available in several variations of this wingtip style, come in tons of colors and leather finishes, two widths, and men's sizes 7–16.

Promising review: "Ordered two pairs (brown/black) and when I wear these out I’ll be back for more. My work requires formal and business casual dress and I am on my feet all day. I walk at least three to five miles on the job per day and other dress shoes leave my feet and back in misery. I ordered a pair a couple years ago and they look great, great arch support, lightweight, and ultimately are as comfortable as a running shoe. I wore the other pair out and back for two more pairs. While they are not a cheap shoe they are well worth the price and you truly pay for what you get." —Todd

Get them from Amazon for $84.89+.

4. A Stuart Weitzman bestseller recommended by a publicist

Stuart Weitzman

In our recent coverage of comfortable dress shoes, publicist Natalie Rao recommended this stylish chunky boot from Stuart Weitzman. “I’ve tried it on and can confirm it is so comfortable and could work for winter events, the office and nights out with friends.” 

We found a number of reviews on the brand’s website that support this claim, with customers praising its supportive design for logging city miles. The luxury hybrid boot pairs Nappa leather with a stretch fabric material for added give in the upper, and has a reasonable 2.4-inch heel that offers both sophistication and practicality. It’s made in Spain.

Promising reviews: “I have big feet and bunions so my options for shoes are limited. I tried these on and they felt like magic. The leather is so high quality and soft at the same time, they fit me well but also the regular foot size person at the store who also had them on. They're versatile and beautiful, fun and edgy. I've worn them a few times and they maintain comfort even through an NYC commute. Highly highly recommend! I went down half a size from my norm.” —Lejla

“I wore (only) these boots for an entire five-day trip in NYC. They were comfortable to wear all day, including during long stretches of walking. They worked with multiple casual and semi-dressy clothing options. They were plenty warm though not stifling.” —Liz

Get them from Stuart Weitzman for $595 (available in women's sizes 7.5–13).

5. A pair of breathable ballet flats

Allbirds

Finally, a pair of ballet flats that won't make your feet smell and are comfortable to wear all day long thanks to the brand's proprietary knit blend that's ultra-soft and breathable, plus a flexible, bouncy sole that conforms to your movements.

Promising review: "I like to wear flats with many of my work outfits, but I am constantly having issues with my feet, including achilles enthesitis, so I need something more comfortable than a typical flat. I've tried many, I've tried adding orthotic insoles, and none of them really worked. I was reluctant to spend this much on flats, but I bit the bullet and loved these so much I now own three pairs in different colors. They are so comfortable and I can wear them all day without blisters or feet pain! I wouldn't probably wear them for super long walks, but I wear them to commute, around the office, and for my lunchtime walks without issues." —Nora B.

Get them from Allbirds for $90+ (available in women's sizes 5–11 and 13 colors).

6. A pair of lug-sole weatherproof boots

Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmonds’ men's dress boots were mentioned a few times in a Reddit thread discussing the best commuting shoes that are nice enough for the office as they are suitable for walking in the city. 

The brand’s popular Higgins Mill boot has a lightweight rubber lug sole for great traction and an insole that molds to the shape of your feet. They're available in three colors, sizes 6.5-15, and four widths, although not all sizes are available. (For a fuller size range, try an updated version of the boot that offers many of the same features along with a convenient side zipper.)

Promising reviews: “I have three pair of these boots and like them very much! They broke in very quickly, and I wear them every other day to do my 1.5 mile city walk to and from the office. Only 4 stars due to the laces that come with a size 11 boot. They need to be 8" longer on this size boot, otherwise they only make the first lug. AE: You need to provide longer laces on the larger size boots.” —Candlewood1

“I’m six months into these boots and I couldn’t be more satisfied. The lug sole has the perfect amount of squish which is a godsend since I stand all day at work. They’ve withstood the PNW rain and slushy snow and still look amazing. They’re roomy in the toe so you can get away with thick socks in the winter. The soft lug tread has held up well and hasn’t disintegrated on the sharp gravel I walk through often. Overall they are the perfect winter boot, definitely worth it.” —Heath

Get them from Allen Edmonds for $495.

7. A pair of rugged Blundstone boots

Amazon

The classic Blundstone brand is known for versatile footwear and a longstanding reputation for reliability. These rugged leather boots, which are available in gender-neutral sizing, have a shock-absorbing insole and the brand's signature lug and durable construction.

Promising review: "I've owned five pairs of these same boots over the years and will buy another pair after this one dies...and another after those. Best boots ever, period. Comfortable, versatile, convenient, supportive, and attractive. I wear them with khaki slacks to my office job and get lots of compliments on them. Then I leave the office and go walk the dogs or hike in them. Then I wear them while I rebuild my privacy fence. Then I wear them out to dinner with my wife." —Hiker

Get them from Amazon for $129.95+ (available in women's sizes 5.5–12, men's sizes 3.5–15, and 32 colors).

8. A pair of professional Dansko clogs

Amazon

HuffPost's very own managing editor of shopping, Emily Ruane, is a big fan of the Dankso clog for her commutes. It's a perennial footwear choice across many professions. These cozy shoes have a generous toe, a padded instep, and a color selection that seem legitimately endless. (HuffPost senior reporter Sara Boboltz also likes these for rainy days, thanks to the leakproof sole.) 

"I swear by the Dansko Professional clog — but the key to wearing them in a work setting is to choose a stylish color! (It does kind of depend on how formal your office is.) I have hot pink and translucent pairs, but I also have a pair in black patent leather that look surprisingly dressy. They're also very weather resistant — I wouldn't wear them in a blizzard, but in rain or even light snow my feet stay really dry, and they feel secure, not slippery. Did I mention that they are eternally comfortable, supportive and I feel like I could stay in my feet all day?" — Emily Ruane

Get them from Amazon for $144.95, Zappos for $124.95, and Dansko for $135 (available in women's sizes 4.5–13 and multiple colors). 

9. A pair water-resistant slip-on sneakers

Zappos

In another Reddit thread on the best shoes for commuting, one commenter swore by Ecco's slip-on sneakers. Made from traceable leather, these water-resistant shoes feature an inject-cushioned insole for a wear that's bouncy and cloud-like, while the outer sole is dimpled for traction against slick surfaces. 

These are available in three colors and sizing for both men and women, though it's important to note that these run big so it's best to order a size down. 

Promising review (Nordstrom): "These shoes are so incredibly comfortable. I bought the gold tone ones and then bought the black ones because I love them so much. As an Esthetician I spend the majority of my day standing. These shoes have been great for my back and go with practically every kind of outfit." —Steph320

Promising review (Amazon): “I can walk in these Ecco shoes all day my feet do not hurt.” —LA Hipster

Get them from Amazon for $109+ (available in men's sizes 5–16.5 and eight colors), Nordstrom for $84.99 (available in women's sizes 4–11.5 and in grey rose) and Zappos for $110.90+ (available in women's sizes 5–12.5 and three colors).

10. A pair of cushioned Nike Air Maxes

Nike

These adorable and marshmallow-y looking classics from Nike are a commuting favorite of my New York City-based colleague Greta Geiselman. Available in tons of fun color combinations and in sizes for both men and women, the Air Max 90s feature a waffle outer sole for traction and the brand's signature insole cushioning that provides the perfect amount of support.

"I guess it depends on the professional setting but I am now a BIG fan of Nike's Air Max line. I have janky, flat feet and these feel so good!!" —Greta Geiselman

Get them from Nike for $97.97+ (originally $130; available in women's sizes 5–12 and 15 colors).

11. A pair of wool runners from Allbirds

Allbirds

Geiselman also said that she really loves these wool runners from Allbirds and sees a lot of people commuting on the subway with them. One of the brand's best-known options, these are great for walking in many different weather conditions and have cushioned support insoles. These lightweight shoes also feature certified natural rubber treads for a delightful bounce and better traction, and merino wool uppers that are thermoregulating.

Promising reviews: "I had been on the fence about purchasing these for a while now. When the sale hit, I figured why give them a try. I really enjoy them. Very comfy and understated so I don’t feel bad wearing them in the office." —Beth S.

"Got these to use in NYC and wore them walking miles for five days. Never able to do that with shoes just purchased. Very comfortable. Warm on snowy days. Never took them off for the full vacation including walking miles in airports. I have no reservations in recommendint these shoes." —Kathleen K.

Get them from Allbirds for $83+ (available in women's sizes 5–11, men's sizes 8–14, and multiple colors).

12. A hybrid sneaker and dress shoe

Ponto

Referred to by the brand as "part sneaker, part dress shoe," the Pacific shoe from Ponto claims to be "light as a feather" and "shockingly comfortable." They can also keep feet dry through small and light rain thanks to the water-repelling uppers and slip-resistant outer soles. The shoe's interior promises to be so absorbent and resistant to odor that you don't even have to wear socks. Grab these in 10 color combinations and men's 8.5-14. 

Promising review: "Use these to commute to the city each morning on the train. They have great support while also looking presentable as a Gen Z person. Perfect business casual shoe." —Liam F.

Get them from Ponto for $148.

The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.