back to top

We Lived With Haunted Dolls For A Night And I'm Pretty Sure We're Possessed Now

"I plan on trying to make this doll as haunted as possible."

Posted on

Are some movies so wild they can’t be depicted in real life? Well, on “Reel to Real” we try to figure that out! And on our first episode, we decided to recreate Annabelle: Creation coming out August 11th, by living with haunted dolls and here's what happened:

View this video on YouTube

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

For this challenge, Garrett and I would buy "haunted dolls" from the sketchy-ass part of the internet, live with them for 24 hours, and if we survived, review our experience by giving it a rotten or fresh review.

Garrett and I had completely different goals. He was willing to do any and everything to make sure that this doll haunted him to the point where he was murdered in his sleep by it.

BuzzFeed Video

And I was going to do any and everything to make sure I avoided this doll.

BuzzFeed Video

FOR THE RECORD, I don't believe in haunted dolls. Like, Chucky and Annabelle are obviously not real. But when it comes to the supernatural, I'm definitely cautious.

It was time to pick out our dolls for each other.

My strategy was to be as inclusive as possible. Since I'm a black woman, I thought that if my doll was a woman of color, we could vibe off of that similarity.

BuzzFeed Video

Apparently, haunted dolls aren't extremely diverse, so Garrett bought me, Amelie and she didn't seem too demonic *WIPES SWEAT OFF FOREHEAD.*

BuzzFeed Video

Garrett was open to pretty much whatever, as long as it wasn't sticky. He was aiming for something as demonic and messed up as possible.

BuzzFeed Video

So I picked the most active doll I could find, Anastasia.

BuzzFeed Video

While we waited for our dolls to arrive, I started to feel super uneasy. I decided to talk to BuzzFeed Unsolved's, Ryan Bergara for advice.

The hope was to walk away feeling more positive about the experience. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case. He pretty much told me I was dumb for living with a haunted doll.
BuzzFeed Video

The hope was to walk away feeling more positive about the experience. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case. He pretty much told me I was dumb for living with a haunted doll.

A few days later, we got our dolls. Ten minutes after opening our packages, Garrett was mysteriously stabbed by a random needle poking out of his dolls leg.

BuzzFeed Video

If that's not shady, I don't know what is.

And instead of him thinking that was a warning, it made him more excited to keep taunting it.

BuzzFeed Video

Throughout our work day, Garrett and I had two completely different strategies.

He was doing any and everything in his power to make his doll mad. Like carrying her by the hair...

BuzzFeed Video

...and using a ouija board to try and contact her spirit.

BuzzFeed Video
BuzzFeed Video

Meanwhile, I paid Amelie no mind.

BuzzFeed Video

At the end of the day, Garrett and I went our separate ways. I took the necessary steps and saged my entire apartment, while Garrett just did his normal routine.

And luckily, nothing too crazy happened during the night to report. We surprisingly woke up feeling quite refreshed.

BuzzFeed Video
BuzzFeed Video

So, what was our final review on living with haunted dolls?

Well, Garrett found it to be super dull and unenjoyable, giving it a rotten tomato.

BuzzFeed Video

For me, the experience was unpleasant and something I didn't want to do. So of course, I gave it a rotten tomato as well.

BuzzFeed Video

Comment below with which movie we should do next!