Skip To Content

    The “Ogletree Murder” Is One Of The Creepiest Unsolved Cases In American History

    What happened in room 1046?

    by , , ,

    On Wednesday, January 2, 1935, around 1:20 PM, a man calling himself Roland T. Owens checked into The Hotel President in Kansas City. A few days later his body was found badly beaten and tortured in his hotel room. The events surrounding his death caused a lot of speculation:

    View this video on YouTube

    BuzzFeedBlue / Via youtube.com

    Witnesses said he was aged anywhere between 20 to 35 years old and was nicely dressed.

    BuzzFeed Video

    The bellboy who helped Owens to his room, Randolph Propst, reported that Owens only packed a brush, comb, and toothpaste.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Throughout his stay, the hotel maid Mary Soptic said Owens allowed her to clean while he was in the room.

    BuzzFeed Video

    She recalled Owens keeping the shades tightly drawn and the lights off with the exception of one dim lamp. He also asked that she not lock the door on her way out because he was expecting company.

    BuzzFeed Video

    She told police that she believed that Owens was worried or afraid about something:

    BuzzFeed Video

    At 4 PM, Soptic returned with new towels and found Owens laying on the bed in complete darkness. She also found a note on the nightstand that read:

    BuzzFeed Video

    The next day Soptic came back to clean the room at around 10:30 AM. She noticed that the door had been locked from the outside, assuming that Owens locked it while leaving. However, Owens was sitting on his bed with the lights off, which meant someone else had locked the door from the outside.

    BuzzFeed Video

    While she was still in the room, Owens answered a phone call and said:

    BuzzFeed Video

    When Soptic came back at around 4 PM to deliver fresh towels she heard two male voices from inside the room. When she knocked on the door she heard a rough voice say, "Who is it?" She then explained she had fresh towels and the mystery man responded with, "we don't need any."

    BuzzFeed Video

    During the night a hotel guest staying on the 10th floor reported hearing loud voices.

    BuzzFeed Video

    There was apparently a party going on that night in room 1055.

    The next morning at around 7 AM, the hotel phone operator noticed that Owens' hotel phone had been off the hook for awhile without being in use.

    BuzzFeed Video

    She sent a bellboy to check his room. Despite the door having a “Do Not Disturb” sign, the bellboy knocked a few times and heard a low voice say:

    BuzzFeed Video

    However, the door was locked and no one was opening it. After knocking repeatedly, the bellboy told Owen to "put the phone back on the hook."

    Around 8:30 AM, the phone was still off the hook. Another bellboy, Harold Pike let himself into the room with a passkey.

    BuzzFeed Video

    He only used the light from the hallway and noticed that Owens was naked in bed seemingly drunk. He also noticed that the bedding was darkened around Owen, so he placed the phone back on the hook and left.

    BuzzFeed Video

    At approximately 10:30 to 10:45 AM the phone was once again off the hook. The hotel sent another bellboy to resolve the situation. But when he opened the door, he stumbled upon a truly horrific scene.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Here was his statement to the police:

    BuzzFeed Video

    Owen was discovered with extensive injuries. He had been tied up with a cord around his neck, wrists, and ankles. His skull was fractured, he had been stabbed in the chest several times, and his lung was punctured.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Remarkably Owen was somehow still alive. One of the detectives that arrived at the scene asked Owen if anyone else had been inside the room, his response was:

    BuzzFeed Video

    He claimed that he fell against the bathtub.

    BuzzFeed Video

    After that brief exchange, he lost consciousness and was taken to the hospital. According to a doctor, his injuries had occurred 6-7 hours prior to him being discovered. Owen died the night of January 5, at the hospital.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Detectives found no weapons or any of Owen's belogings in the room and ruled out suicide.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Four fingerprints were found on the hotel telephone potentially from a female.

    BuzzFeed Video

    When Owen initially checked into the hotel, he mentioned he was from Los Angeles. But when Los Angeles authorities searched for a "Ronald T. Owens" they couldn't find any records.

    BuzzFeed Video

    His body was placed for viewing at Melody Mcgilley Funeral Home. As the story spread, more and more people reached out to Kansas City authorities to see if their missing loved one could be Owen, but there were no leads

    BuzzFeed Video

    When police tried to search for the mysterious man that was said to be in Owens' room the night of his death, Don they found no leads.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Owens' upcoming burial was announced by the Kansas City Journal Post on March 3rd to be in a Potter's Field. However, the Melody Mcgilley Funeral Home received an anonymous caller who said they would send money necessary for a proper funeral.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Sure enough, on March 23rd money bundled in a newspaper was delivered to the funeral home.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Anonymous flowers were also arranged along with a card that read:

    BuzzFeed Video

    About a year and a half later, in 1936 a woman named Ruby Ogletree found an article in the American Weekly about Owens' case. Upon looking at the magazine, Ruby correctly identified Owens as her son, 17-year-old Artemus Ogletree.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Ruby had received three letters from her son in the Spring of 1935. However, the letters were delivered after his death and were typed.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Which was suspicious because Artemus didn't know how to type.

    After some time it was revealed that Artemus stayed in another hotel in Kansas with another man, some suspected that man was the mysterious Don.

    BuzzFeed Video

    And in the early 2000s, Dr. John Horner, the author of an account of the murder case published by the Kansas City Public Library, received an out of state call about Artemus. The caller claimed to find a box of newspaper articles about the murder. After that, the case would have no other revelations.

    BuzzFeed Video

    Let's get into the theories now.

    The first theory is that the man referred to as Don beat Artemus to death and acted alone.

    BuzzFeed Video

    The second theory is that the unknown Don didn't act alone. This theory relates back to an observation by Charles Blocher, the elevator operator the night of the murder. The night of murder, Blocher saw a "commercial woman" go to the 10th floor.

    BuzzFeed Video
    BuzzFeed Video

    Blocher claimed the woman was looking for Room 1026 to meet a man she couldn't find. Could it be possible this woman was looking for Artemus? And accidentally mistaken Room 1026 for Room 1046. This woman was also seen with a man and some speculate the man could have been Don.

    If you recall, there were fingerprints on the telephone found in Artemus' room and a woman staying in Room 1048 heard loud female and male voices yelling.

    BuzzFeed Video

    The third theory is that Ogletree was killed for being unfaithful.

    BuzzFeed Video

    According to an article published in The New Castle Sun, "Mystery Murder Room 1046" states that a woman called a local paper to say:

    BuzzFeed Video

    But when asked to identify herself and what happened to Ogletree, she replied with:

    BuzzFeed Video

    And at the same time, a man called the funeral parlor Ogletree was held in and said:

    BuzzFeed Video

    The man also explained that "Owen had jilted a girl he was engaged to." And in Room 1046, Owen, a man, and the jilted girl had a "little meeting." Before hanging up he said, "Cheaters usually get what's coming to them."

    BuzzFeed Video

    Shortly after, the Rock Floral Company received a call requesting:

    BuzzFeed Video

    Still leaving a dead end regarding what happened to Artemus that fateful night.

    Other than that, the mysterious death of Artemus Ogletree has been left to collect dust on the shelves of investigators. To this day there is no possible lead on what truly happened in Room 1046 leaving the case...unsolved.

    BuzzFeed Video