Alleged Photos From A Pre-Sam Levinson Version Of "The Idol" Are Going Viral, And Some Fans Are Saying It Actually Looks Good

    "The original version of The Idol could’ve been grown up Hannah Montana-type girly-girl show had they left it alone!"

    Even if you have never seen an episode of The Idol, you've likely encountered its general vibe. Like, ooh, so dark! So tortured! From the "twisted minds" of Sam Levinson and Abel "The Weeknd" Tesfaye! Someone alert the church elders!

    lilly rose depp standing in the middle of two other people wearing a stage bodysuit with cutouts

    The backstory surrounding the production of The Idol is undeniably entwined with the show itself. The HBO series was originally directed by Amy Seimetz, known for The Girlfriend Experience and She Dies Tomorrow, but she suddenly left production with around 80% of the show shot. Reports suggested that the ensuing creative overhaul was because Abel, the show's co-creator and male lead, said it had too much of a "female perspective."

    closeup of him on the show wearing a headband

    Enter Sam, who scrapped reportedly $54–75 million worth of the nearly-finished project. His rewrites and reshoots, according to one person involved with production who spoke to Rolling Stone, took the show "from satire to the thing it was satirizing." The publication described the original show as being about a "troubled starlet falling victim to a predatory industry figure and fighting to reclaim her own agency."

    closeup of lily and abel on the show sitting next to each other

    As such, you may be wondering what Amy's version of The Idol looked like. Lo and behold: some images allegedly from the set of the show started going viral on Twitter.

    bts of the original direction of “The Idol” pic.twitter.com/tJmK3njRMf

    — M!RI (@whitney_jewston) July 4, 2023
    Twitter: @whitney_jewston
    It's unclear where these photos originated from.

    Some pointed out that the images are likely a flashback or an expansion on Jocelyn’s past as a child star.

    Twitter: @autumnasasadboy

    Furthermore, Juliebeth Gonzalez, one of the original cast members, appeared to have images from Amy's shoot on her Instagram:

    It's safe to say, the vibes are different:

    As such, many said that they would have wanted to see the original version:

    the original version of the idol could’ve been grown up hannah montana type girly girl show had they left it alone! pic.twitter.com/duwEK1WdZZ

    — khalia. | FLO’S 3 of us EP 🧸🌺 (@VERONASFILMS) July 5, 2023
    Twitter: @VERONASFILMS

    this makes me so upset cause you can tell the original plot of the idol had a genuine vision pic.twitter.com/NPPk1WX5dT

    — kamani ☆ (@TEXASTITTIE) July 5, 2023
    Twitter: @TEXASTITTIE

    Twitter: @kenwhitmore16

    Twitter: @ifavred

    What do you make of the original photos? LMK in the comments!