It all started with Joe Carroll.
(This is not a serial killer.)
And since he's so goddamn attractive, it makes sense that he'd lure fellow hotties.
How else to explain Emma?
This is not a serial killer.
And how about those gay neighbors?
I'm supposed to fear these dudes?
This is a hunk, not a psychopath.
Sorry, you're just TOO pretty.
Nice try, but not a serial killer.
Also not a serial killer!
Oh, and then this new dreamboat showed up.
Or hey, maybe this is an alternate universe where everyone is hot.
That would explain the detectives.
And maybe there are just a lot of pretty homicidal maniacs out there!