Sabrina The Teenage Witch Fan Theory: Could Libby Chesler Be A Witch?

I know it sounds a little far-fetched, but there is evidence. and here it is: 3 pieces of evidence for libby chessler being a witch.

1st piece of evidence: inna gadda sabrina

google / Via google.com

in this episode, sabrina creates a time ball that sends westbrook back to the 1960's. here's where the first piece of evidence comes up: earlier in the episode, zelda comments: when a witch uses a time ball, only witches know the time changes. mortals are under the spell. as you see throughout the episode, everybody in westbrook is dressed in 60's clothing, knows 60's songs, and act like they've been in the 60's their whole lives, not showing any knowledge of the 90's or dressing like they normally do. everyone except.... sabrina and libby.

libby is shown dressed in her normal cheerleading outfit, and said this:

"oh, boo all you want....... grooming, shopping and social climbing are grand traditions that will never die."

I'm pretty sure at least half of that quote wouldn't make sense unless she had some knowledge of the 90's. also, if this is the 60's, where did she get her cheerleading uniform? I'm pretty sure it wouldn't pass the "is your skirt long enough?" test, and it's fit with the styles of the 90's, not the 60's, so it can't be a coincidence.

2nd piece of evidence: 5 easy pieces of libby

photostock warehouse / Via original.png

this one is small, but still worth mentioning. earlier in the episode, we see libby easily swing open her locker without pitting in the combonation, even though it was locked. later, when sabrina is looking for puzzle pieces, we see her point at the locker and then achieve the same thing. now, thanks to dreama, we've learned that magic doesen't have to be in your finger. so, even though libby didn't point, it's still possible that libby opened it with magic.

3rd piece of evidence: also in 5 easy pieces of libby

hulu / Via hulu.com

when we visit libby's home, we notice that she has a lot of beautiful, solide gold statues and knicknaks. but, if you look closely, you'll notice the gold lion statue that turns into a real lion, owned by sabrina's aunts. could it be that there's more than one of these statues availible for purchase in the other realm? if so, why would a magical statue be in libby's home? and, if they weren't witches, how would they get the statue?

do you think libby is a witch?