back to top

Couples Prank Each Other With A Fake Secret

What would you do if your girlfriend kept a mason jar full of toenail clippings?

Posted on

We asked three couples to reveal secrets to each other, but then we privately told one member of each pair to prank their partner with a lie. Here's what happened:

View this video on YouTube

youtube.com / Via youtube.com

First, the setups to these fake "secrets" were laid on pretty thick.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Making your girlfriend think you have a secret past she doesn't know about? Shady!

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

She looks nervous!

Sounds like a confession is coming...

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

And he's already jumping to the worst conclusion.

Kevin tells Mallory about a past relationship that he had kept a secret...

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

The anticipation builds as Bryan leads up to his big confession, but Mikey thinks it might be too much to handle!

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Boom.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Zack's girlfriend Morgan told him that during freshman year of college she accepted a very strange dare:

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Zack's face, tho.

She goes on to add that she kept it going for all four years of college, and she still has the jar!

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

WUT.

Perfectly reasonable reaction:

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Meanwhile, Kevin pours his heart out to Mallory about this mystery woman, who was HIS FIRST!

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Mallory's probably wondering what "communicate" means, exactly.

Just in case Zack wasn't grossed out enough, Morgan actually brought out THE JAR.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

That's just wrong (but hilarious).

Zack is rethinking everything right now.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Back to Mikey and Bryan, where sh*t's getting REAL.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

(But, still actually FAKE.)

LOL, Zack.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

After Kevin tells Mallory that he would like to see this former lady friend on their upcoming trip to San Francisco, he drops this little nugget:

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Well played, Kevin.

Now it's time to let their partners off the hook with a big, fat "JK!"

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Mikey is feeling a lot of things right now.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Zack's mostly feeling relieved AF.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Mallory is actually bummed that Kevin didn't come up with something more elaborate.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Is her disappointment worse than his fake secret?

In the end, true love conquered all.

BuzzFeedVideo / Via youtube.com

Could these two be any cuter?

The best things at three price points