go to content
Food

The Best Ice Cream Sandwiches In America, According To Yelp

Keep cool and eat ice cream.

Posted on

A warm gooey cookie served fresh from the oven is one of life's biggest pleasures. As is a scoop of homemade, luscious ice cream. So when you put them both together in the form of an ice cream sandwich, you've got the best of both worlds.

Netflix

But where do you find the absolute ~best~ dessert sammies? We asked the crew at Yelp to round up their favorites. They sourced these from their community managers across the country — who love frozen treats (and eating local!) — just as much as you do.

1. Odd Pocket from Oddfellows Ice Cream (Brooklyn, New York)

@kvens / Via yelp.ca, @stuffbeneats / Via instagram.com

Take your pick from Oddfellow's extensive ice cream menu, then have your scoop stuffed into a brioche bun, warmed on a panini press, and garnished with toppings.

2. Ice Cream Cannoli from Honeycomb Creamery (Cambridge, Massachusetts)

@nishatnguyen / Via instagram.com

When in Cambridge, order this frozen take on the canoli. It's lemon ricotta gelato dipped in chocolate, rolled in pistachios and seved in a homemade cannoli shell.

3. Waffle Ice Cream Sandwich from SMOOSH Cookies (Houston, Texas)

@foodstablessed / Via instagram.com

This Houston favorite offers two rotating specials to help hungry customers get through the week: Waffle Ice Cream sandwiches on Wednesdays and Churro ice cream sandwiches on Fridays.

4. Ice Cream Sandwich from Sweet Rose Creamery (Los Angeles, California)

@sweetrosecreamery / Via instagram.com

This artisanal ice cream shop with five locations around Los Angeles turns its small batch flavors into mouthwatering ice cream sandwiches. Think: "Blueberry Muffin" and "Summer Corn" wedged between two chocolate-dipped wafer cookies.

5. Cookie Monster from Roxy's Ice Cream Social (Oklahoma City, Oklahoma)

Fran V. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

There's no better way to satisfy a sweet tooth than with this OKC creation made with cookies 'n cream ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies.

6. Peanut Butter Cookie & Grape Ice Cream Sandwich from Lick Ice Cream (Indianapolis, Indiana)

Brooke K. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

Imagine your favorite childhood PB&J sandwich in the form of a frozen treat. Yeah...It's just as good as you'd expect it to be.

7. The Gooey Cooie from Sweet Cooie's (Denver, Colorado)

Kay A. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

The signature dish at this Denver creamery, the Gooey Cooie, features a brioche doughnut, split open and filled with homemade ice cream. The whole thing creation gets pressed together in a panini machine and topped wth icing glaze.

8. Cookiewich from Insomnia Cookies (College Park, Maryland)

@loloah89, @munchandbrew / Via instagram.com

University of Maryland students know the secret to surviving finals week, and it includes lots of these decadent ice cream sandwiches stuffed between freshly baked cookies. Choose from the Cookiewich (an M&M cookies) and the Bigwich (classic chocolate chip).

9. Creamy Bun from Luigi's Ice Cream (Red Bank, New Jersey)

@brellowgirl / Via instagram.com

There's only one main attraction at this Jersey mainstay: A scoop of your favorite ice cream flavor stuffed between a glazed doughnut bun.

10. Anything from The Coolhaus Shop (Los Angeles, Dallas, and NYC)

Via yelp.com, Gustaf A. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

The king of gourmet ice cream sandwiches, Coolhaus is a fleet of ice cream trucks around L.A, Dallas, and NYC. You can choose from eight artisanal sammies, including double chocolate cookies filled with mint chip ice cream and snickerdoodle cookies stuffed with salted caramel ice cream.

11. Ube Ice Cream Sandwich from Bonifacio (Columbus, Ohio)

@Bonifacio614 / Via instagram.com

If you've never had ube — or purple yam — ice cream before, you're missing out. At Bonifacio, a Filipino restaurant, it comes served on a fried bun with coconut caramel sauce and Fruity Pebbles.

12. Milk and Cream Bun from Milk & Cream (Dallas, Texas)

Sherry V. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

These hot-pressed glazed doughnut buns stuffed with ice cream and garnished with your favorite toppings are the ultimate way to cool off in the Texas heat. Looking for strawberry cheesecake ice cream with Cap'n Crunch cereal? No problem.

14. Macaron Ice Cream Sandwich from Tout de Sweet (Bethesda, Maryland)

Via instagram.com, @melbelle31 / Via instagram.com

This Bethesda pastry shop turned its already popular French macarons into delectable ice cream creations. You'll find these treats in interesting flavors like coconut macaroons with mango sorbet and strawberry macarons with green tea ice cream.

15. The Super Jack from Cool Jack's (Sylvan Lake, Michigan)

Cool Jack's via Yelp / Via yelp.com

This Michigan born gem now has two locations in Michigan as well as a third shop in Boca Raton, Florida. The must-try menu item features superman tye-dye ice cream served between two homemade M&M Sugar Cookies

16. Hot Waffle Ice Cream Sandwich from the Custard Hut (Dearborn Heights, Michigan)

Alexandra K. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

Not to be confused with ice cream, custard is even thicker and denser, made with egg yolks and butterfat. If you find yourself in the Detroit area, make sure to try it sandwiched between two warm waffles.

17. Ice Cream Sandwich from Rose's Meat Market & Sweet Shop (Durham, North Carolina)

@ncmadenet / Via instagram.com

Come for the pastrami sandwiches and stay for the decadent ice cream sandwiches at this butcher and pastry shop. Just don't miss the strawberry and pistachio praline frozen sammie.

18. Ice Cream Sandwich with Pie Filling from Peace Pie (Charleston, South Carolina)

Joni.Stepp, @Agathemuller / Via instagram.com

Introducing: Ice cream sandwiches with a layer of pie filling...because God is god. Peace Pie offers over two dozen flavors like salted caramel ice cream with apple pie and cheesecake ice cream with tart cherry pie.

19. Ice Cream Taco from Pop Fizz (Albuquerque, New Mexico)

@misoo_hungry / Via instagram.com

It's like your favorite store-bought choco taco, but so. much. better. Choose from a bunch of ice cream flavors, which are stuffed in a waffle cone taco shell and topped with chocolate.

20. Concha Ice Cream Sandwich from Treats of Mexico (Houston, Texas)

@foodiewithgilzzz / Via instagram.com

If you've never tried a concha before, it's a Mexican pastry that's basically a sweet roll topped with cookie crust. And it tastes even more delicious topped with a scoop of ice cream.

21. Macwich from Bake Shop (Arlington, Virginia)

@dcdining / Via instagram.com

The macaron flavors change daily at this pastry shop just outside of D.C., so you'll have to go often to get your hands on all the flavors.

23. Babka Ice Cream Sandwich from On Rye (Washington D.C.)

@charpotle / Via instagram.com

Start with the matzo ball soup at this haute Jewish deli, and finish off strong with the chocolate babka sandwich filled with vanilla bean gelato.

25. Ice Cream Sandwich from Miller Union (Atlanta, Georgia)

@millerunionatl / Via instagram.com

This upscale eatery serves farm-to-table southern fare, but locals know the dessert menu is the real star of the show. The ice cream sandwiches are only available during lunch time, and the flavors change daily.

27. Birthday Cake Ice Cream Sandwich from Launderette (Austin, Texas)

Nathan I. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

It doesn't have to be your birthday to treat yourself to this rich and creamy sprinkle-topped sammie.

28. Churro Ice Cream Sandwich from Churro Borough (Los Angeles, California)

Jose G. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

This Instagram sensation is well worth all the hype. It's two freshly basked, cinnamon sugar-dusted churro disks filled with your choice of ice cream (like strawberry buttermilk or Spanish latte).

29. Ice Cream Sandwich from Betty Rae's (Kansas City, Missouri)

http://@cocktails.and.cuisine / Via instagram.com

Customers can choose between eight different ice cream sandwich offerings, like "The Notorious PBC," with double chocolate cookie and peanut butter ice cream or "The Breakfast Sandwich," made with oatmeal cookies and coffee ice cream.

30. The Goodwich at The Good Batch (Brooklyn, New York)

Ron L. via Yelp / Via yelp.com

$7 for an ice cream sandwich may sound like a hefty price tag, but one bite of these homemade, melt-in-your-mouth cookies filled with artisanal ice cream and it'll be worth every penny.

31. Crocream from Churned Creamery (Murrieta, California)

32. Ice Cream Sandwich from Ruby Jewel (Portland, Oregon)

http://@treatyoself.com / Via instagram.com

The handmade ice cream sandwiches at this Portland favorite come in eight flavors like lemon cookies with honey lavender ice cream and brown sugar cookies with Oregon strawberry ice cream.

34. Cuban-Style Ice Cream Sandwich from Tio Colo (Hialeah, Florida)

@tio_colo / Via instagram.com

Head to this cuban shop for a bocadito de helado. The main difference between the ice cream sandwiches you're probably used to is the bread. Tio Colo's version serves theirs between two slices of sweet and dense yellow sponge cake.

35. Salty Chipwhich Ice Cream Sandwich from Bittersweet (Raleigh, North Carolina)

@ktdeck88 via Instagram / Via instagram.com

This sweet-and-salty treat features chocolate Chip Sea Salt cookies and vanilla ice cream all rolled in bourbon caramel corn.

36. Create Your Own Ice Cream Sandwich from ChunknChip Cookies (Santa Ana, California)

@herbneats, @chunknchip / Via instagram.com

This craft ice cream shop with locations in Los Angeles and Orange County is known for its "samiches." You can even mix and match two types of cookies with two flavors of ice cream inside.

Every. Tasty. Video. EVER. The new Tasty app is here!

Dismiss