We Asked Floridians Who Has The Best Key Lime Pie In The Florida Keys

If you're from Florida, you give people the best hookups for key lime pie. It's what you do. And if you want to save 15% or more on car insurance, you switch to GEICO. It’s what you do.

We asked Florida locals for the tastiest key lime pies in the Florida keys, and now we are very hungry.

zoopicture.ru

1. Green Turtle Inn — Chip from Fort Lauderdale

Courtesy of Green Turtle Inn / greenturtleinn.com

This key lime pie goes the extra mile with a macadamia nut–crispy rice crust that is to die for. Combined with the perfect tartness of the filling, you're in for some key lime pie perfection!

2. Blue Heaven — Devon from Sanibel Island

Courtesy of Blue Heaven / blueheavenkw.com

This photo speaks for itself. A graham cracker crust pie topped with a fluffy cloud of meringue along with a squeeze of fresh lime juice to tie it all together, it's a thing of beauty.

3. Two Friends Patio — Jess from Orlando

Courtesy of Precious J. / Via yelp.com

Two Friends Patio's homemade key lime pie will fill that pie-shaped hole in your heart. It's everything a key lime pie should be. It is the Goldilocks of the Florida Keys because it is juuust right. ;)

4. Key Lime Pie Co., recommended by Kellie from Coral Springs

Courtesy of Jorge M. / yelp.com

Did you know that you could have key lime pie on a stick? Did you know it would be chocolate-covered and exceed all your wildest key lime pie expectations? Now you know. You're welcome.

5. Mrs. Mac's Kitchen, recommended by Terner from Destin

Courtesy of Mrs. Mac's Kitchen / Via mrsmacskitchen.com

Creamy filling, crumbly crust, and the perfect balance of ingredients make up this amazing key lime pie. Bonus points: It freezes perfectly so you can stock up in your freezer for a rainy day!

6. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe — Analise from Tampa

Courtesy of Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe / / Via keylimeshop.com

As if their classic key lime pie wasn't mind-blowing enough, Kermit's also makes a strawberry key lime pie and a dark chocolate–covered pie bar. So you have the perfect excuse to get three servings of dessert, all in the name of research. ;)

7. Hobo's Cafe — Amanda from Fort Lauderdale

Courtesy of Hobo's Cafe / hoboscafe.net

This pie is mouthwatering perfection and can be summed up in one word: CREAMY. From the lush filling to the smooth whipped cream topping, you cannot go wrong! Pro tip: Order Hobo’s Jar Key Lime Pie. Part of the proceeds go to a local charity, and there's just something about eating pie out of a mason jar!

8. Key Lime Pie Bakery — Joe from St. Augustine

Courtesy of Key Lime Pie Bakery / Via keylimepiebakery.com

This bakery has been around for decades and specializes in the art of the key lime pie. To say that they've nailed it would be an understatement.

9. Pepe's Café and Steakhouse — Sarah from Tampa

Courtesy of Pepe's Café and Steakhouse / pepeskeywest.com

Pepe's has been around since 1909. That's over 100 years of perfecting their key lime pie recipe, and perfect it they have. You won't want to miss this staple of the Florida Keys!

10. The Fish House — Kerry from Lake City

Courtesy of The Fish House / fishhouse.com / Via Emi Gomez / EGoz Photography

The Fish House is known for its signature browned meringue curlicue on top and also for the fact that it is absolutely delicious.

If you're in Florida, make sure to save room for dessert. ;)

youtube.com