Skip To Content
Paid Post

We Asked Floridians Who Has The Best Key Lime Pie In The Florida Keys

If you're from Florida, you give people the best hookups for key lime pie. It's what you do. And if you want to save 15% or more on car insurance, you switch to GEICO. It’s what you do.

We asked Florida locals for the tastiest key lime pies in the Florida keys, and now we are very hungry.

1. Green Turtle Inn — Chip from Fort Lauderdale

2. Blue Heaven — Devon from Sanibel Island

3. Two Friends Patio — Jess from Orlando

4. Key Lime Pie Co., recommended by Kellie from Coral Springs

5. Mrs. Mac's Kitchen, recommended by Terner from Destin

6. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe — Analise from Tampa

7. Hobo's Cafe — Amanda from Fort Lauderdale

8. Key Lime Pie Bakery — Joe from St. Augustine

9. Pepe's Café and Steakhouse — Sarah from Tampa

10. The Fish House — Kerry from Lake City

If you're in Florida, make sure to save room for dessert. ;)

View this video on YouTube