We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.

    22 Shoes That Reviewers Say Hold Up So You Don’t Have To Replace Them Again Next Year

    These lovely pairs will last you so long, you might just start to believe they're your *solemates*.

    Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women’s.

    1. A pair of chunky Fila platform sneakers to give you that extra height boost without sacrificing the comfort you desperately need to carry you through hours of walking. So, no pain in your feet (just in your wallet, as you decide how many different colors you can afford).

    close-up of reviewer wearing the white platform sneaker
    overhead view of reviewer's feet wearing the white platform sneakers

    Promising review: "I adore these shoes! They look and feel so classy. I wear a 9.5–10, and I ordered a 9.5 knowing they would stretch. They fit perfectly right out of the box with little effort to break them in. I wear them for strength training and they hold up very nicely while keeping me stylish. I have them in white, so I keep them looking new with a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. It works like a charm." —Jennifer

    Get them from Amazon for $54.92+ (available in sizes 5–14 and 63 colors/styles — not all styles available in all sizes). 

    2. Lug-sole Dr. Martens Rometty boots — even if you're the sundress-wearing friend in the group, these babies are sure to give you some edge. With a classic look and a comfy platform, these give you the freedom to pair them with whatever you so please.

    close up of reviewer's foot wearing the black boot
    overhead shot of reviewer wearing the black boots

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Here's what BuzzFeed Shopping contributor Brittany Ross says about them: "I bought these boots last year and they quickly became the ones I reach for whenever I'm not wearing sneakers. They're SO comfortable (I've worn them walking around both NYC and Europe for hours on end), and that bit of extra height makes 5' tall me feel like I can take on the world. They're also ridiculously cute and worth every cent of what they cost, thanks to their durability and versatility. I've worn them in the rain and never once worried about slipping! Best of all, they look great with a casual jeans look or gussied up with a slip skirt, which I've paired them with on many occasions. I know they'll last me a long time, but I'm already certain I won't hesitate to buy a replacement pair when they finally give out. 10/10, buy them! Oh, and FYI, they run a little big, so consider sizing down!"

    Promising review: "They look adorable on with any outfit, dress them up with pants or down with jeans. Overall they fit true to size. They are durable with a thick sole and hold up to rain. I have always loved Dr. Martens and these live up to their good quality and staple pieces." —christa kraftician

    Get them from Amazon for $106.92+ (available in sizes 5–11). 

    3. Or some more affordable lug sole low heel booties with the same trendy platform and wide, stretchy elastic side panels so that you can easily slip them on and off.

    reviewer wearing the brown boots
    reviewer wearing the black boots with black stockings, a black skirt, and a white sweater

    Promising review: "HIGHLY RECOMMEND. I’m personally very in a lot of different shoe brands, but normally I’m an 8. I went with my gut and ordered an 8. Very glad I did bc I can wear them with normal socks and fuzzy, and it doesn’t squeeze anything either! I bought the tan pair last month and are still holding up fantastic. Fantastic boots for good price!" —Hannah

    Get them from Amazon for $22.40+ (available in sizes 5.5—11, including wide sizes, and in 19 colors).

    4. Super supportive Dr. Scholl's kicks — aka the new cushy pair of shoes you'll be reaching for when it's time to go to the airport. Since they're super easy to take on and off, TSA might just stop yelling at you as you try to make your way through security as quickly as possible.

    FYI: These are made from recycled bottles!

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising reviews: "I bought these shoes to wear on vacation to the Grand Canyon. I did a lot of walking on that trip, and my feet never hurt and I still looked cute. Then a few months later, we went to Durango, Colorado and did a ton of walking and again, my feet never hurt. I washed them and let them air dry several times over the next year and they came out great every time. They soon became my daily shoes to wear around the house. I have already bought a second pair to replace them so I can still look cute and be comfortable and wear the first pair when I water the garden. I would definitely recommend these shoes!" —J. Perkins

    "I've gotten two pairs of these; the only reason I purchased a second is because I got pregnant and my feet swelled/foot expanded. I LOVE these shoes because they are stylish and super comfy. They also do well in the rain and clean easily. I wear these shoes DAILY and they really hold up." —JF

    Get them from Amazon for $48+ (available in sizes 5–13, including wide sizes, and in 24 styles — not all styles available in all sizes). 

    5. Beachy slip-ons that'll let you avoid having to awkwardly stop in the middle of a walkway to crouch down and tie your shoe *again*. With these you can keep the cute sneaker look, sans the laces! Plus, many reviewers say they're super comfy — even if your feet are on the wider side!

    reviewer wearing the green slip ons
    reviewer wearing the white slip ons

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising review: "Found my favorite comfortable shoes and they don’t even cost that much! I love these! I have had them for about a month and I wear them everyday and they are still holding up pretty well. They are lightweight and thin-ish material so they have air flow lol which I love in hot weather, especially when I can’t wear sandals. Definitely buying another pair once these have served their purpose! Thank you so much for this product!" —Ambree

    Get them from Amazon for $23.02+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 82 colors/prints). 

    6. Or some lightweight (each shoe weighs less than five ounces!) slip-ons with a rounded toe design that gives you some extra space for movement. This pair is sure to be an instant fave to go with your modern-casual wardrobe.

    reviewer wearing the beige slip ons
    reviewer wearing the navy blue slip ons

    Promising review: "This is my third pair of Hey Dude's and I am never disappointed! So comfortable and highly recommend!! For anyone thinking that they may be a little high priced, they hold up for a long time! I wear anywhere from a size nine to nine and a half, depending on the shoe and brand and I purchased a size nine and they fit perfectly, even with wearing with a thicker sock! If they seem a little tight at first, they do stretch and give way after wearing them a few times." —Co4242

    Get them from Amazon for $27.48+ (available in sizes 4—12 and in 30 styles).

    7. A pair of classic ballet flats, which come in too many wonderful colors and prints for you *not* to stock up on several pairs. Reviewers rave about how comfy these suitcase-friendly shoes are!

    reviewer wearing the flats with a black and white pattern
    the same reviewer wearing the beige flats

    Promising review: "These shoes are so comfy! I ordered my regular size and they fit great so I would say they are true to size. The gold color is so versatile. They also hold up very well. I have worn these probably 100 times and there is no wear or cracking, and I do a lot of walking. I am definitely going to be buying more of these in different colors!" —Amazon Customer

    Get them from Amazon for $10.50+ (available in sizes 5—15, including wide sizes, and in 21 colors).

    8. A timeless (and comfy) pair of Dr. Martens combat boots that'll probably spend very little time in your closet because of how perfectly they go with your fall/winter season fits.

    Model wearing the black boots with denim jeans
    Reviewer wearing the black boots with black pants

    Promising reviews: "I'm in love. Never buying another brand of combat boots again. I'd been hesitant to buy Docs because of the price, but these were absolutely worth it. Excellent support (comfortable enough to wear for EIGHT hour shifts on my feet) and they're grippy enough to handle snow / sleet / New England winters. I tend to wear my shoes to death, but I've been wearing these pretty much daily for four months and they're holding up well. The Cherry Red is a beautiful color." —R

    Get them from Amazon for $151.71+ (available in sizes 5–11 and seven colors).

    9. And some absurdly cheap yet cute waterproof Chelsea boots because I think we both know you're way past letting a rainy destination ruin your trip (or your outfit!). These will let you splash around in slushy puddles all you want without any worry of getting a dreadful wet sock.

    reviewer wearing the maroon boots, which have some water droplets on them
    reviewer wearing the black boots with jeans and a pink sweater next to a blue door

    Promising review: "These are great boots. They are stylish, comfy, and are holding up nearly three years later in the Pacific Northwest rains! I truly wear these almost daily during our long, wet winters and the sole is barely starting to go. LOVE this boot. I had similar-looking ones before that only lasted one season as the sole wore quickly and the rubber and elastic parts detached from each other. But THESE are legit. I will never buy another brand of waterproof boots again!" —Shannon Hunter

    Get them from Amazon for $27.98+ (available in sizes 4–13 and 15 colors).

    10. Or some rain boots with a unique quilted mid-calf design that sets them apart from your regular rain boots. Reviewers rave about how roomy and lightweight they are!

    the boots
    a reviewer wearing the boots

    Promising review: "I would totally buy these boots again. Use them to tend to my chickens — easy to slip on and off, easy to clean, comfy for what I use them for. Great price and they are holding up very well. Solid piece construction keeps them waterproof and low maintenance. I just hose them off. If you need, warmth, size up so you can wear thick socks. I needed boots for both the hot summer weather and winter cold fronts. So bought a bit bigger size to accommodate socks when needed. Sometimes I slip my bare feet into them when I'm in a hurry and they are just as comfortable." —Teresa Edmondson

    Get them from Amazon for $29.99+ (available in sizes 5–9.5 and eight colors).

    11. A trendy, lightweight pair of New Balance 608 V5 Cross Trainers that amazed one reviewer with how well they carried them through a full day at Disneyland — and we all know that's the true test of comfort for any pair of shoes. They're made with minimal interior seaming and are lined with supportive foam inserts so that your feet can kiss those painful blisters and midday discomfort goodbye.

    reviewer photo of the white and blue sneakers on a patch of grass
    reviewer wearing the white and blue sneakers with a blue outfit

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising reviews: "New Balance is my go-to brand. They fit well, and are comfortable to walk in. They're the one brand I can wear that truly fits my wide feet; they're study, and hold up to constant wear. This particular pair is a double-winner - the expected high quality product, and I got a huge discount for buying a 'used, like new' pair from Amazon. They're in mint condition, and were packaged well. Glad I went for the sale!" —Knitting Granma

    Get them from Amazon for $45.44+ (available in sizes 5–12, including narrow and wide sizes, and three styles). 

    12. Or some New Balance Fresh Foam Roav V1 sneakers for the ultimate casual athletic look. These babies come with a rubber outsole for durability, a heel design that keeps your foot snug and supported, and a midsole that'll make you feel like you're walking on clouds. I mean c'mon — what more could you ask for? 😍

    reviewer wearing the black sneakers
    reviewer wearing the white sneakers with grey laces

    Promising review: "This shoe is hands down the most attractive tennis shoe I've ever owned. I want a bunch more. These look so good on my big clown feet. I wear from 10–11 and the 10.5 fit perfect. Wear these almost daily to the gym and they are holding up well. Will 100% buy more." —Michelle

    Get them from Amazon for $25.69+ (available in sizes 5—12, including wide sizes, and 40 colors).

    13. Flexible water shoes that don't scream "water shoes" — they're actually pretty cute! They're quick-drying, anti-slip, and will save your precious feet if you happen to have a rocky beach vacay in your plans.

    reviewer wearing the pink shoes while tubing
    close up of reviewer showing the underside of the shoe

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising review: "There is literally nothing that I dislike about these shoes. They’re lightweight, dry moderately fast, and protected my feet even from oyster shells. They breathe well, grip is fairly good even on things covered in grass or algae, and they hold up well to pretty regular use." —Shea

    Get them from Amazon for $29.97 (available in sizes 5.5–15, in lace-up and velcro styles, and 45 colors). 

    14. Chunky ankle boots to give you versatility, comfort, and a bit of extra height, all at a great price. I guess the only thing they won't give you are second thoughts. 😉

    overhead shot of reviewer's feet wearing the black boots
    another reviewer wearing the black boot

    Promising reviews: "I love everything about these boots. They are well-made, very fashionable, and comfortable. I was a little concerned about the height of the heel being uncomfortable but I wore them to work all day and didn't have any problems with my feet hurting. Very happy with my purchase!" —momtojsh

    "Save a trip to the mall and just get these boots instead. they’re true to size, comfortable enough, and super cute. I’ve worn them out four or five times now and they seem to be holding up great." —Karlee Dodge

    Get them from Amazon for $22.42+ (available in sizes 5.5–11, including wide fits, and 10 styles).

    15. Soft Clarks wedge loafers with the *chef's kiss* perfect amount of added height to offer some glorious heel support. And bonus! Their OrthoLite footbeds will keep your feet super happy as the rest of your tired group decides where to go next.

    reviewer photo of the burgundy loafers
    reviewer wearing the black loafers

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising reviews: "I broke the cardinal rule and took new shoes to Europe for vacation, but I relied on the past history I've had with many Clarks I've bought in the past and wasn't disappointed. These shoes were troopers through all the cobblestone streets and climbing an ungodly amount of flights of stairs to visit castles." —cheekymonkey

    "Great shoes. Comfortable, stylish. Super lightweight, so I wasn't sure if it would hold up, but I've worn them a number of times, and they still look brand new."MKMac

    Get them from Amazon for $63.18+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide sizes, and in 17 colors/styles). 

    16. Or!! Very affordable pointy-toed loafers that reviewers are loving because they don't require breaking in. And if you're in a part of the country with a cold-and-warm climate, these shoes' closed-toe, open-top design makes them extra ideal. One reviewer even said they preferred these over their Gucci pair

    reviewer wearing the gold loafers
    reviewer wearing the leopard print loafers

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising reviews: "I absolutely LOVE these shoes! They are super comfy and adorable! I have a wide foot so I went up a half-size. They fit great! Despite the pointy look, my toes are not squished. The material of the shoe is a soft, suede-like fabric, so it stretches. No need to break-in the shoes." —CSG

    "I absolutely love these! They are cute and go with all of my work outfits, I went with the suede black pair. They are comfortable and didn't hurt my feet to break in. So far the quality is very nice and they are holding up well. It rained and I had to walk through a small puddle and they still look great!" —Hannah

    Get them from Amazon for $19.10+ (available in sizes 5–15, including wide sizes, and 13 styles). 

    17. Super pretty Toms canvas cutout sandals, because in a world where security and stability are a rare find, you should at least own shoes that give you *both*. This pair's thick straps and chunky heels will keep your feet in place, and will look oh-so-cute on you as you walk from your favorite café to a stroll in the park. 

    reviewer wearing the white sandals
    reviewer wearing the leopard-print sandals

    Promising review: "I ordered these to wear to the office and around campus. They're dressy enough for work and I can wear them all day with no problems! I like the thicker heel too because I'm less likely to biff it. They fit perfectly and hold up really well! I wore them, no kidding, every day for a month and they still look brand-new. Definitely a great purchase!" —Ryane

    Get them from Amazon for $25.35+ (available in sizes 5–12 and seven styles). 

    18. A pair of sleek Crocs flip-flops — they're a perfect, modern alternative to the brand's signature clogs if you still want to experience the glorious comfort that Crocs provide. Plus, they're lightweight and have a flexible sole that will make them a staple in your travel pool or beach bag!

    reviewer wearing the black flip-flops
    side view of reviewer's foot wearing the black flip-flop in the sand to show its flexible sole

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising review: "I have an extremely rocky yard which has broken several dozen of the highest rated and sturdiest flops made in the five years I’ve lived in the Caribbean. I tried these bc the ratings and brand are excellent. My first thought when opening them was... they did not look one-quarter as durable as the previous brand. But after four months of strenuous outdoor wear, I’m amazed bc they are 100% holding up longer and stronger and they are very comfortable. I’m optimistic that they will continue to hold up which, will save me money." —Christina Mellon

    Get them from Amazon for $19.25+ (available in sizes 4–11 and 15 colors). 

    19. Cute and casual Sperry sneakers with curly-Q laces to keep you from having to tie your shoes every five minutes. They have a removable footbed for lightweight comfort and glorious arch support. Plus, an elastic back for a secure, slip-on fit!

    reviewer's feet in the white sneakers
    reviewer's feet in the navy sneakers

    FYI — if you plan on wearing them with socks, reviewers recommend no-show socks.

    Prime members: You can try before you buy!

    Promising reviews: "I LOVE these adorable sneakers. I got three different pairs of sneakers to compare before settling on these. I decided on these because they felt sturdy and comfortable. I want to be able to wear these for a while, and I like that the sole of the shoe is substantial and the canvas on top is sturdy. The style is adorable. These go with anything and make even the most casual outfit feel a little more sophisticated. The insole is a dream. After wearing through two VERY walking-heavy trips, the insoles have held up great and have molded to my feet. They are so, so comfortable. I love the convenience of the slip-on styling. I've walked hundreds of miles in these babies, and they still look great. (They are in need of a wash — but have kept their shape and comfort)." —Lolo

    "Bought leather Sperrys years ago when I was on my feet a lot. The support helps relieve my back pain and my feet don't hurt at the end of the day. I know from experience they hold up really well. So glad they have canvas." —Susan

    Get them from Amazon for $34.99+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide sizes, and in dozens of colors — not all colors available in all sizes). 

    20. Sock-like platform slip-ons because they weigh just over one pound and are made of breathable mesh that'll keep your precious feet cool and sweat-free. Basically, if you want to combine the freedom of being barefoot with the support of a cushy sole, these are the shoes for you!

    reviewer wearing the grey sneakers
    reviewer wearing the navy blue sneakers

    Promising review: "I can honestly say I was a bit skeptical about these shoes, but for the price, I thought why no. I have had them for five months now and I absolutely love them. They are very lightweight, provide excellent support and are the most comfortable shoes I own, no joke. I do wear mine everyday, and have washed them several times and these babies are still looking as good as when I first got them. They’re holding up beautifully! Great for any workout. I run, walk, lift, etc. seven days a week." —JC

    Get them from Amazon for $23.99 (available in sizes 5—12 and in 26 colors).

    21. Greek gladiator-inspired sandals to take on *all* of your sunny outings. These have an adjustable ankle strap and a padded insole. Who said strappy sandals can't also be comfy?

    A reviewer photo of the brown sandals
    A reviewer wearing the white sandals while parasailing

    Promising review: "All the reviews were right. Super comfy! I wear size 10 tennis shoes so I got size 10 for these. Perfect fit. Going to need to order a few more pairs. I wore them for 8+ hours the first day I wore them, never got uncomfortable. They are holding up well after a few wears so far." —Levi Allen

    Get them from Amazon for $19.90+ (available in sizes 5—15, including wide sizes, and in eight colors).

    22. A pair of wide-calf Western boots that give major ~main character~ energy. The calf is nice and wide for extra comfort.

    model in white western boots
    a reviewer in white boots at a concert

    Promising review: "I rarely write reviews but felt compelled for these boots. I ordered half a size up because of the point and for extra thick socks and they fit perfectly. Also my calves are like 14–14.25 inches and these fit with a little bit of extra room so I would say they're wide calf friendly. I have been searching for a pair of black boots and these aren't my normal style but I am obsessed. I've worn them almost every day since buying and they are holding up. I didn't even break them in before taking them to NY and walking around the city for a week. No blisters, no pain, nothing. They are sturdy, comfortable, walkable, and a decent price. If you have them in your cart and are debating, get them!!" —Amazon Customer

    Get them from Amazon for $59.99 (available in sizes 5–13 and 13 colors).

    Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.