go to content
TVAndMovies

26 Times "One Tree Hill" Kept You Up At Night

There's only one Tree Hill. And it's the scariest town on earth.

Posted on

1. The night Peyton and Brooke went to a college party as high school sophomores and Peyton got roofied.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

Subsequently, any time your eyes glanced away from your drink for one second at a party, you put it down and got a new one.

2. When Keith turned on a red arrow and got into a terrible car accident.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

And suddenly, Dan is the good guy and Keith is in trouble and nothing really makes sense.

3. Or that time Nathan crashed his race car on the track because he was distraught over losing Haley.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

Any part of you that ever thought trying track racing would be fun disappeared forever.

4. When Dan got burned in the dealership fire.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

The flames were scary enough, but the uncertainty for SEASONS of who started the fire left you terrified.

6. When Dan USED THE SCHOOL SHOOTING to kill Keith, his own brother, in cold blood.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

And to this day, you cannot accept that this actually happened.

8. When Peyton's fake brother Derek, aka Ian, covered her room with pictures of her.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

And you found a new worst nightmare that you couldn't even have imagined.

9. And then Ian was shoved out of the window, but was gone by the time the police arrived a few minutes later.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

WHERE DID HE GO?? WASN'T HE DEAD AFTER THAT FALL???

11. Or when Ian returned (because he wasn't in jail after all) and attacked Peyton and Brooke.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

After this episode, it took a long, long time for you to be able to stay home alone again.

17. When psycho nanny Carrie chased Haley and Jamie in the woods.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

If you were hiding during this scene, it turns out OK. Deb appears and smacks Carrie in the face with a glass bottle.

25. Dan's elaborate rescue of Nathan.

The CW / Via Emily Orley / BuzzFeed

You really had no idea who was dead and who was alive and who was good and who was bad. By the end, you were just gasping for air.

Every. Tasty. Video. EVER. The new Tasty app is here!

Dismiss