Skip To Content

    20 Things For Anyone Who Can Never Get Enough Peanut Butter

    Choosy moms choose JIF, but you can choose whatever you want from these PB picks.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. An eight-pack of creamy natural Skippy peanut butter so you'll be well-stocked — for a few days, at least.

    The peanut butter

    Each pack comes with eight jars of peanut butter. 

    Promising review: "With my kids home all the time, we have been going through peanut butter like it's our job. We love getting this large palette of peanut butter. It cuts down on grocery store trips." —Jennelle

    Get it from Amazon for $17.96 (available in three flavors). 

    2. A protein bar that'll give you a peanut butter boost even when you're on the go. These dairy-free bars are individually wrapped, so they're easy to toss into your bag for the next time hunger strikes.

    The bar

    Each pack comes with 12 bars. 

    Promising review: "These are so great as a post workout snack or a meal while on the go. They are fresh, have wholesome ingredients, and taste great. I love the chunky peanut butter bars. They fill you up, and aren’t loaded with preservatives. They don’t give you gas or upset stomach like some bars I have had. Highly recommend." —joan

    Get it from Amazon for $27.84 (available in fifteen flavors).

    3. A jar of Eliot's peanut butter with espresso nibs for days when you need a caffeine boost with your PB.

    The peanut butter

    Promising review: "This peanut butter is like a joyous choir of angels singing in my mouth. I LOVE peanut butter but due to dietary restrictions am unable to enjoy it as often as I would like. I purchased this jar as a delicacy to have as an occasional snack. First I should say that I'm a sucker for anything remotely coffee-flavored so of course espresso nib is the first flavor I've tried (also bought the honey chipotle that I haven't opened yet). I know they say you can do fancy things with this PB like cooking and using it for sauce, etc. but I stuck with the simple carrot and apple dip and it was a heavenly experience. The different textures are amazing: the smoothness of the peanut butter, the peanut chunks and espresso bean chips. They all combine in perfect harmony. This is a beautiful thing and I don't even care how much it costs." —Sunnyseas

    Get it from Amazon for $9.99+ (available in seven flavors).

    4. A peanut butter knife that'll help you scrape your jar clean so that no PB goes uneaten. You can also use it to stir up your jar if needed.

    The peanut butter knife

    Promising review: "After getting tired of ending up with peanut butter on my knuckles as the jars grew more empty (and trying to get the peanut butter stuck to the bottom and sides of the jar), I decided to try this 'knife' out. First off, it's not really a knife — no sharp edges, which makes it great for kids. It is a great kitchen gadget for folks who like peanut butter. It's long enough to keep your knuckles and fingers clean when the jar is nearly empty. The shape also helps to get every last chunk of my chunky peanut butter off the bottom and sides, and less waste means the knife will pay for itself. It is sturdy enough to make spreading the peanut butter a breeze. Wish I had bought one long ago!" —MJS81

    Get it from Amazon for $12.99.

    5. A jug of chocolate peanut butter protein powder so you can make your daily shake delicious and filling.

    The protein powder and shake ingredients

    Promising review: "I am strong now. This whey protein gives me the strength to move mountains. Build walls. Break them back down. Build another wall. Call my mom and tell her I love her. Have profound conversations with myself about the falsehoods that is ego and realize that hyper masculinity is an illusion to mask years of fearing things I don’t understand and limited thinking. Thanks whey for giving me the brute strength to overcome my fears of becoming a ballerina." —amin

    Get it from Amazon for $29.99.

    6. A personalized peanut butter spoon for anybody who needs a special vehicle for their beloved snack. This isn't a regular spoon, it's a cool spoon.

    The Spoon
    Ashijewelers / Etsy

    Ashijewelers is based in Dallas, Texas, and sells personalized silverware, jewelry, and more. 

    Promising review: "The seller was super responsive and helpful! She customized and shipped the same day I ordered when I told her I was in a bind (since another seller fell through last minute) and I got the package in the nick of time! Would definitely shop here again." —Carla

    Get it from Ashijewelers on Etsy for $9.99+ (available in six styles and endless personalization options).

    7. A Quest cookie that'll satisfy your peanut butter-loving sweet tooth and give you some protein, too.

    The cookies

    Each pack comes with 12 cookies. 

    Promising review: "I order the peanut butter cookies in bulk to save a few bucks because I know that I'm going to buy unhealthy snacks if I don't. These are a great option for those trying to decrease carbs and increase proteins. Not to mention, only 1g of sugar is nice, too! If you're used to extremely sugary snacks, these will be a disappointment. If you're used to just enough sweet to count it as a dessert, these are great. There are a ton of protein treats on the market, but these are one of the very few that also minimize carbs. I highly recommend them." —Biz

    Get it from Amazon for $20.92 (available in six flavors).

    8. A 5-pound jar of Adams natural peanut butter for anybody who *REALLY* prefers crunchy over creamy.

    The peanut butter

    Promising review: "I love everything about this peanut butter. Literally everything. All I can do is pray that they NEVER stop making it. I might die if they do." —Marla 

    Get it from Amazon for $23.90.

    9. A 24-pack of Reese's Peanut Butter Lovers cups because they're peanut butter coated in a peanut butter creme and taste so good they might make your peanut-butter-loving heart burst with joy.

    The peanut butter cup

    Each pack comes with 24 packs. 

    Promising review: "These are great — just as good as the regular Reese's cups. If you like peanut butter, you'll like these. I don't even miss the chocolate tbh." —Woundsarebleeding

    Get it from Amazon for $41.74.

    10. A PB T-shirt that'll be on regular rotation and let everyone you see know exactly what's on your mind.


    Promising review: "My best friend and I bought these PB and jelly shirts. They are both super high quality, didn't shrink in the wash, and are very comfy." —Shelby

    Get it from Amazon for $9.99+ (available in sizes S-2XL and four colors).

    11. A jar of Big Spoon Roasters chai spice peanut and almond butter because it's my absolute favorite and turns my morning toast into a morning treasure.

    The peanut butter

    Promising review: "Wow. I anticipated that it would be good, but I underestimated how delicious it would be! What a fabulous mingling of flavors, not to mention the satisfying crunch in the texture. Big Spoon Roasters absolutely nailed it, and I’m so glad I came across this product on Amazon. I watch my sugars and carbs, so I use this as my breakfast — a spoonful straight from the jar (okay, maybe two spoonsful because I have no willpower) and a low carb Greek yogurt is all I need. Get you some!" —B-burg Bulldog

    Get it from Amazon for $10.99 (available in nine flavors and two sizes).

    12. A self-cleaning peanut butter mixer that'll take care of any separation. Just put it together, put it on your jar of PB, and do a quick stir before you chow down. No more oil sloshing everywhere!

    a reviewer photo of the peanut butter mixer on a jar of peanut butter

    Promising review: "This is exactly what I was looking for and is perfect! I ordered the 16-oz, 70-mm size and it fits perfectly on the Aldi brand peanut butter I like. The crank turns easily and whips the peanut butter back together into a smooth consistency with no chunky bits settled on the bottom. This lid fits on my mason jars as well so if it doesn't fit you could just dump your peanut butter into a mason jar to make this work for you." —S

    Get it from Amazon for $10.80.

    13. An array of peanut butters for anybody who likes a little variety in their PB pantry.

    Peanut butter assortment

    Each set comes with 10 jars.

    Promising review: "Love this peanut butter. It is fresh and fun to eat. The 2-oz jars are perfect for sharing and gifting. Love the varieties — something for everyone. I don't mind stirring it at all, it tells me it is fresh and not full of a lot of emulsifiers. My favorite way to eat it is on celery." —Teri S.H.

    Get it on Amazon for $24.99 (available in three varieties).

    14. A pair of PB-inspired socks because they'll make you smile every time you slip them on.


    Promising review: "Was a gag gift from my daughter to my brother since he loves PB, and he absolutely loved them." —Krissy Noel

    Get it from Amazon for $13.95.

    15. A bag of peanut butter-flavored popcorn that'll outrank movie theater popcorn any day.

    two bags of peanut butter popcorn

    Comes in a pack of two.

    Promising review: "Fresh and amazing. The Thorp fruit stand in Thorp, Washington always carries it and I can't resist stopping when we're in the area. Now I can get it delivered to my door when we are feeling the need. The peanut butter caramel taste is such a great pairing when you need a special treat!" —Jamie Newell

    Get it from Amazon for $19.99.

    16. A huge jar of Reese's peanut butter sauce that'll transform your baking. It's like peanut butter — but with that delicious Reese's twist.

    The sauce

    Promising review: "This is delicious. OMG I remembered having a sundae many years ago at Friendly's restaurant, so I got this. I heated some up in a bowl in the microwave for a short time and poured it over ice cream and put crumbled cookies on top. OMG it was wonderful. You can cook with this and make peanut noodles too. It is so yummy. Huge container too. SO GOOD. If you like Reese's peanut butter, you will love this." —Jewelry designer, artist and gardener

    Get it from Amazon for $27.99.

    17. A bag of peanut butter-flavored coffee because it'll make tumbling out of bed, stumbling to the kitchen, and pouring yourself a cup of ambition something to look forward to every morning.

    The coffee

    Promising review: "This is THE coffee for those who love peanut butter! Great 'peanutty' taste and a rich smooth finish. Have not found another that even compares! That is why it is the first ever subscription product we have ordered from Amazon. Try it and you'll be hooked, too!" —K Murphy

    Get it from Amazon for $11.50 (available as grounds or whole bean).

    18. A 12-pack of Premier Protein shakes because it's got tens of thousands of 5-star reviews and comes in your favorite flavor combo: chocolate *and* peanut butter.

    The shake

    Each pack comes with 12 shakes. 

    Promising review: "I absolutely love this flavor of Premier Protein. It tastes almost identical to a Reese's peanut butter cup. I plan on purchasing this flavor again." — Dallas

    Get it from Amazon for $24.99 (available in 10 flavors).

    19. A mug set for you and your peanut-butter lovin' friend or sweetie. It's like the grownup version of a BFF bracelet...remember those??

    The mugs

    Promising review: "These mugs were better than expected. I couldn't be happier with my purchase and I can honestly say that these are now my favorite coffee mugs!" —Olivia

    Get it from Amazon for $15.99.

    20. A peanut butter-scented candle because it'll make your entire home smell like PB cookies even if you're not a baker.

    the mason jar peanut butter candle
    BuckeyeCandleCompany / Etsy

    BuckeyeCandleCompany is based in Lancaster, Ohio, and specializes in making homemade soy candles with love and care.

    Get it from BuckeyeCandleCompany on Etsy for $18+ (available in two sizes and three styles).

    Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!

    illustrated banner

    The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form