We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
Choosy moms choose JIF, but you can choose whatever you want from these PB picks.
Promising review: "Wow. I anticipated that it would be good, but I underestimated how delicious it would be! What a fabulous mingling of flavors, not to mention the satisfying crunch in the texture. Big Spoon Roasters absolutely nailed it, and I’m so glad I came across this product on Amazon. I watch my sugars and carbs, so I use this as my breakfast — a spoonful straight from the jar (okay, maybe two spoonsful because I have no willpower) and a low carb Greek yogurt is all I need. Get you some!" —B-burg Bulldog
Get it from Amazon for $10.99 (available in nine flavors and two sizes).
Promising review: "This is exactly what I was looking for and is perfect! I ordered the 16-oz, 70-mm size and it fits perfectly on the Aldi brand peanut butter I like. The crank turns easily and whips the peanut butter back together into a smooth consistency with no chunky bits settled on the bottom. This lid fits on my mason jars as well so if it doesn't fit you could just dump your peanut butter into a mason jar to make this work for you." —S
Get it from Amazon for $10.80.
Each set comes with 10 jars.
Promising review: "Love this peanut butter. It is fresh and fun to eat. The 2-oz jars are perfect for sharing and gifting. Love the varieties — something for everyone. I don't mind stirring it at all, it tells me it is fresh and not full of a lot of emulsifiers. My favorite way to eat it is on celery." —Teri S.H.
Get it on Amazon for $24.99 (available in three varieties).
Comes in a pack of two.
Promising review: "Fresh and amazing. The Thorp fruit stand in Thorp, Washington always carries it and I can't resist stopping when we're in the area. Now I can get it delivered to my door when we are feeling the need. The peanut butter caramel taste is such a great pairing when you need a special treat!" —Jamie Newell
Get it from Amazon for $19.99.
Promising review: "This is delicious. OMG I remembered having a sundae many years ago at Friendly's restaurant, so I got this. I heated some up in a bowl in the microwave for a short time and poured it over ice cream and put crumbled cookies on top. OMG it was wonderful. You can cook with this and make peanut noodles too. It is so yummy. Huge container too. SO GOOD. If you like Reese's peanut butter, you will love this." —Jewelry designer, artist and gardener
Get it from Amazon for $27.99.
Promising review: "This is THE coffee for those who love peanut butter! Great 'peanutty' taste and a rich smooth finish. Have not found another that even compares! That is why it is the first ever subscription product we have ordered from Amazon. Try it and you'll be hooked, too!" —K Murphy
Get it from Amazon for $11.50 (available as grounds or whole bean).