Skip To Content

    25 Beauty Products From Beauty Pie That Don't Cost A Lot, But Will Be Used All The Time

    Beauty products for those with champagne tastes — but La Croix budgets.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed collects a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    Psst! You can score $10 off your first order after becoming a Beauty Pie member when you use promo code BUZZFEED10.

    1. A smooth matte bronzer infused with thermo-protective red algae so you can get a sun-kissed glow without the sun damage.

    A Beauty Pie Quantum Bronzer Matte compact with logo
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "This is a great, natural, even-toned bronzer. Highly recommend if you’re looking for something subtle and buildable. I really like it and will probably buy again." —Emmagrace

    Price: $34 ($7.78 for members, comes in two shades)

    2. A tinted lip balm crayon designed to hydrate and moisturize lips while providing a pop of sheer color, all with just one swipe.

    Shine Up™ Lip Colour Balm Sticks in different shades with logo
    Beauty Pie

    These lip balm sticks contain no parabens or talc. 

    Promising review: "Love the colors, fantastic lipstick, my go-to from now on! I hope they never change the colors. I use three of them and they also blend well together if you want to mix them, they glide on smoothly over your lips... I'll never wear anything else again!!" — Anne 

    Price: $25 ($5.50+ for members, comes in six shades)

    3. An angled brow pencil with a triangular tip for realistic strokes that mimic actual eyebrows. Top off the look by running the spoolie through the brows to shape, blend, and tame.

    Four Superbrow™ Angled Shaping Pencils with tip and spoolie
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "These are the best pencils I've ever bought and I have tried many. The shaping and quality of the product (which stays put but is easy to get off, too) is brilliant. Highly recommended." —RosieBear

    Price: $30 ($9.59+ for members, comes in three shades)

    4. A high-shine lipstick designed for all-day wear. Formulated with avocado and coconut oil, this creamy lipstick won't dry out your lips (a year-round problem, but an especially big issue in fall/winter).

    Woman applying Futurelipstick Luxe Shine on lips
    Beauty Pie

    This vegan and cruelty-free lipstick is made from pH-active pigments for long lasting shine.

    Promising review: "This lip product has amazing color and moisture, my lips look fabulous! I smile more when I wear this product!" —D. Jordan

    Price: $30 ($8.63+ for members, comes in eight shades)

    5. A colorful sparkly gel liner to add some flare to your next eye look. Both smudge-proof and waterproof, this dermatologically tested liner easily glides on for a smooth, clean line perfect for a wing or cat eye.

    Beauty Pie

    The gel liner is made for all skin types and provides 24-hour wear.

    Promising review: "Just what I needed! Not too sharp and ‘obvious’ around my eyes but gives great definition. So easy to apply and does not smudge. Am sold!" — Flik

    Price: $22 ($4.16+ for members, comes in six shades)

    6. An everyday liquid foundation for those natural and no-makeup makeup looks. This lightweight and light-reflecting foundation offers medium to full coverage with a smooth, matte finish. And yes, it contains no oils or fragrances.

    Woman wearing Everyday Great Skin Foundation close up
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "Goes smoothly on, brilliant coverage but without feeling too heavy, no need to 'top up.' I like a product that requires a minimum of faffing about — and this is it!!" —Pinkfitz

    Price: $40 ($14.79 for members, comes in 14 shades)

    7. A breathable setting spray made with lotus extract to soothe and hydrate skin and keep your makeup flawless. This Korean beauty product features stem cell extract to protect against environmental aging and keep skin in peak condition.

    Fresh Glow Breathable Setting Spray product shot
    Beauty Pie

    Designed for all skin types, this clean setting spray can go right over makeup for a blended look with only a few pumps. 

    Promising review: "I have no idea how on earth this does what it does but my makeup always looks amazing after I spray this, like it melts the makeup into the skin for a more natural, less 'I've just put in two tons of makeup' look." —Charlielou

    Price: $18 ($7.56 for members)

    8. A luminous highlighter to accentuate cheekbones and high points on the face, or mix in with foundation for an overall glow.

    Swatches of Pro-Glow Superstrobing Drops on different skin tones
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "Love this highlighter, lasts all day and isn’t too over powering. I use a few drops in with my foundation for a night out, really gives my foundation a boost. Color is perfect against my skin tone, really easy to apply and builds up really well, depending on the look you’re going for." —Nikki

    Price: $35 ($7.12 for members)

    9. A fragrance-free daily moisturizing lotion made from shea butter and physalis extract that's ideal for those with sensitive skin, promotes microcirculation, and nourishes, all in one.

    Super Healthy Skin Daily Moisture Lotion bottle
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "This is the only moisturiser that makes my skin feel right after using it. It sinks in like a treat and hydrates really well. A magic formula!" —Tallulah

    Price: $40 ($11.93 for members)

    10. A brightening under-eye cream to reduce the appearance of dreaded dark circles and fine lines. Formulated with linoleic acid and vitamin E, this cream provides a smooth, hydrating base for concealer application.

    Four shades of Superluminous Undereye Genius with lids off
    Beauty Pie

    This cruelty-free brightening cream reduces puffiness around eyes when applied over eye cream and under concealer.

    Promising review: "This is so lovely to apply, smooth and hydrating, leaving a subtle glow to brighten the under-eye area. A little goes a long way!" —Sasha P. 

    Price: $25 ($9.37 for members, comes in two shades)

    11. A shimmering lip oil that leaves lips with a nonstick, glossy, lightly tinted finish. Infused with Collagen AC Micro-Vectors and cherry and hibiscus oils, this product hydrates and nourishes lips for a soft, plump look.

    Two containers of Wondergloss Collagen Lip Oil +
    Beauty Pie

    Cruelty free and designed for all skin types.

    Promising review: "Best gloss ever. I have three of these now! So moisturizing and not sticky. Perfect as a quick color that fades nicely and leaves lips soft." —Sarah222

    Price: $30 ($7.51+ for members, comes in five shades)

    12. A three-in-one palette to suit all your makeup needs — it collects bronzer, blush, highlighter, and three shades of eyeshadow, all on one place. Plus, it has a mirror for those quick midday touch-ups.

    One Palette Wonder eyeshadow palette with neutral tones
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "What a great palette with everything you need in one place. Love all the colors. A great product to take with you if you are going away and don’t want to take several different products or you are short on space." —Rachael

    Price: $45 ($8.97+ for members, comes in two shade combinations)

    13. A precision eyebrow pencil designed to sculpt and shape brows in minutes. Its micro-fine tip creates realistic hairlike strokes for natural, even brows, and its reverse end has a spoolie brush to keep hairs in place.

    Five open Superbrow Luxe Precision Eyebrow pencils
    Beauty Pie

    And nope, you don't have to sharpen this eyebrow pencil — its tip is always ready to work.

    Promising review: "Works well. Very fine and soft. Easy to use. Staying power seems good. Nice color for ash-blonde eyebrows." —Anna

    Price: $25 ($8.21+ for members, comes in two shades)

    14. An elasticity-increasing hair repair treatment for damaged, weakened locks. Apply after conditioner biweekly to strengthen hair, visibly reduce color damage, smooth split ends, and strengthen your mane.

    the tubes of conditioner
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "I really like this — I use it as directed on damp hair after conditioning. I have thick, frizzy, and damaged hair and I find it makes a big difference with hair being much smoother, easier to style, and softer after use." —caz

    Price: $40 ($7.43 for members)

    15. A creamy blush made from synthetic waxes and silicone elastomer gel, to seamlessly blend and create a lightweight matte finish.

    Five open creamy blush jars from Beauty Pie
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "Lovely creamy texture that is easy to apply. You only need a little so this is great value for money." —Sallenew

    Price:  $30 ($9.51+ for members, comes in four shades)

    16. A shimmery highlighter palette with a smooth, buildable formula to create a luminous glow.

    Shimmerbar Highlighter swatches on wrist
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "Love the fact I can glow just a little and it looks so beautiful. I toss it on over blush on top of cheekbones." —Carole

    Price: $40 ($11.68+ for members, comes in two shade combinations)

    17. A volume-boosting mascara made from natural waxes, organic shea butter, and vitamin E that creates the appearance of long, luscious lashes.

    Wand and bottle of Uber Volume Boost Velvet Formula Mascara
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "Fantastic mascara — seems very similar to another high-profile mascara that I won’t go into TOO much detail about at a fraction of the price. Provides length, definition, and volume — perfect." —Jen

    Price: $30 ($7.07+ for members, comes in two shades)

    18. A matte lip crayon that doesn't dry out your lips. Made with wild mango butter and elastic waxes, this creamy formula hydrates while adding intense color.

    Model wearing Powderstick Matte Lip Crayon close up
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "This is fab. Definitely a ‘your lips but better’ product. I’ve got three of these and I love them." —Eve

    Price: $22 ($6.19+ for members, comes in three shades)

    19. An eyebrow gel to sculpt, shape, and keep those pesky eyebrow hairs in place. This tinted gel, made from carnauba wax and synthetic beeswax, adds subtle color with coated powder pigment and doesn't flake or crust during the day.

    Woman applying Arch-ology Tinted Eyebrow Sculpting Gel on face
    Beauty Pie

    This cruelty-free and vegan product has the seal of approval from dermatologists and ophthalmologists.

    Promising review: "I love this product, the brush is brilliant for shaping and building volume. The color is perfect for me. I have switched from my usual brow makeup to this one." —GemmaB25

    Price: $30 ($8.44+ for members, comes in three shades)

    20. A concentrated lifting elixir that will hydrate, smooth, and soothe damaged skin. Add a few drops into your toner or serum (or massage on by itself) for softer, more supple skin.

    Bottle of Japanfusion Genius Lift Elixir with dropper
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "I absolutely love this product it really plumps and hydrates like no other product l have ever used before, and it lasts all day. Every mature lady needs this." —Rosyposy

    Price: $40 ($8.90 for members)

    21. A chip-resistant nail polish infused with coconut oil for a glossy finish. Enjoy a home manicure that doesn't chip and provides lasting high-quality color.

    Person holding Wondercolour Nail Polish in violetta
    Beauty Pie

    This formula is free from seven toxic ingredients commonly found in regular polish. 

    Promising review: "It goes on thin and silky, lasts well, AND is easy to remove. Truly magical product." —Pyroliflorus 

    Price: $15 ($4.91+ for members, available in 16 shades)

    22. A long-lasting, color-correcting brightening primer that provides a lightweight, luminous base for makeup application.

    Woman applying WonderFilter Brightening Primer on cheek bones
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "I've never really seen a difference with any primers I've used in the past, but this one was amazing! Gave my skin such a great radiant glow without looking too shiny." —CC

    Price: $35 ($9.11 for members)

    23. A 100% vegan angled brush so you can achieve a concealer application that is both cake free and streak free. The soft, dense bristles seamlessly blend product while providing coverage to those hard-to-reach areas.

    Woman holding several Pro Angled Concealer Brushes
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "Super materials, super angle, great length, it blends effortlessly, if you need a concealer brush, get this one!" — H

    Price: $30 ($10.06 for members)

    24. A pore-purifying toner that exfoliates and removes dead skin cells for a smoother complexion. Infused with glycolic acid and multi-fruit AHAs, this toner reduces the appearance of wrinkles and improves hyperpigmentation with weekly use.

    Dr Glycolic Pore Purifying Glow Toner containers
    Beauty Pie

    *If you have sensitive skin, you'll want to stay away from this product.*

    Promising review: "Fantastic toning, exfoliating and brightening results. I’ve already ordered another one because I never want to run out! It tingles a bit on application so I only us it two or three times a week, but boy does it pack a punch. Highly recommended." —CarolA

    Price: $40 ($14.46 for members)

    25. A matte setting powder to help keep makeup in place while also creating a smooth, silky finish. Ideal for all skin types, this powder is made with blotting micro-powders to absorb oil and keep your face shine free.

    Open compact of Velvetizer Mattifying Powder
    Beauty Pie

    Promising review: "I never want to be without this powder. Have been using it for several months and it gives a beautiful satiny, matte finish." —VV

    Price: $25 ($9.11+ for members, available in three colors)

    The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.

    Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!

    illustrated banner