Browse links
US residents can opt out of "sales" of personal data.
We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.
You can thank me later.
Promising review: "I swear by this eyebrow pencil. I have tried other brands, but they don't compare. The pigment is true to the color on the cap and it stays on all day. I would highly recommend this to anyone looking to up their brow game."—Michele
Price: $5.92+ (originally $8.99; available in four shades)
Price: $7.66+ (available in five shades)
Promising review: "This is one of my favorite lipsticks of all time and I've been using it for years. I absolutely love the color, as it is subtle enough to wear with anything. I find that I wear this lipstick on days when I'm wearing full on make up and also on days when I'm not wearing any other make up at all. It always looks great, no matter what! I really like the consistency of this lipstick, as it is very moisturizing and is not at all sticky or tacky like some lipsticks that I've tried. Another positive is that it is long lasting and I don't have to reapply often as I have had to do with so many other lipsticks in the past." —Mike
Price: $1.35+ (originally $11.05, available in 47 shades)
Promising review: "Love the color, love the shine, love the buttery feel!" —simply2much
Price: $4.60+ (available in 30 shades)
Price: $7.98
Price: $7.49+ (available in 12 shades)
Promising review: "Perfect for novices and experts alike. I'm one of those girls who is terrible at makeup, but due to face masks and aging (why must everything sag?!?!) I've recently started wearing eye makeup beyond mascara and concealer. This eyeliner has been my favorite thus far. It's easy to use, and not runny like some other liquid liners. I feel more confident when I wear this liner, and the price was incredible. It doesn't break the bank, and gives the user the ability to experiment with runway and advertisement looks." —Tiffany
Price: $7.22+ (originally $9.99+; also available in brown)
Promising review: "Hard candy is making a comeback even though it never really left the scene. I sweat on my nose before anywhere else which is such a hassle when it comes to makeup. I've tried more than 10 setting sprays and I always come back to Hard Candy Sheer Envy Longwear Setting Spray. It feels lightweight, helps my makeup last my whole eight-hour workday, and doesn't show any appearance." —ashlie
Price: $5.97
Promising review: "Otherwise it's a FANTASTIC eyeliner. It glides on really smoothly. I just love that. And it creates a firm, dark line that stays dark for hours. Another con, it does smudge and travel a little. To avoid this, powder a q-tip and line your eyes with the powder first. This is the best makeup trick I ever learned. It really will stay put all day if you powder up first. To avoid breaking, I hold it over a flame for just a second or two, to let it melt a little bit and then cool a little. It seems to stay strong that way. With a little tiny bit of effort your reward will be a lasting line that looks really great." —TropicAnna
Price: $5.94 (originally $7.49, available in three shades)
The reviews for this post have been edited for length and clarity.