Karlie Kloss on the Victoria’s Secret fashion show runway.
The Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show costs $12 million. Preparations for it begin a year in advance. The creative team starts working on costumes and show themes in January or February, even though the show doesn’t tape until November. This is a huge, expensive, news-making fashion show — probably the most viewed in the world — that is planned over many, many hours, spanning many months. Even with all that planning and thinking and discussing of things before the show, young supermodel Karlie Kloss made it down the runway blowing kisses in a gigantic, floor-grazing Native American headdress. That costume, within a few days after the photos coming out, became controversial enough for Victoria’s Secret to apologize for its inclusion and to announce the look would be edited out of the the show when it airs on CBS on December 4.
Many compared the gaffe to No Doubt’s Native American–inspired video, which also had to quickly be pulled down and apologized for after similar backlash. But the Victoria’s Secret incident felt symptomatic of the racial insensitivity on many runways and in many fashion photo shoots, whose long planning periods don’t seem to prevent serious missteps. Let’s review.
3. For its spring 2013 show, Dolce & Gabbana included imagery of black women that was widely viewed as “colonialist” and offensive.
4. These earrings drew particular ire.
5. The collection prompted Azealia Banks to proclaim her intent to “definitely boycott” the label.
So far, no one as famous as her has said the same about Victoria’s Secret. But Indian Country columnist Ruth Hopkins is advocating a boycott of the brand. “As a Victoria’s Secret customer, I am livid,” she wrote. “After years of patronage and loyalty to the Victoria’s Secret brand, I am repaid with the mean-spirited, disrespectful trivialization of my blood ancestry and the proud Native identity I work hard to instill in my children. Well, I’ve got news for you, Victoria’s Secret. Consider yourself boycotted.”
Moving on to other gaffes:
This image of Ford — who is best known for making James Bond’s suits, Julianne Moore’s red-carpet dresses, and wildly expensive apparel generally (see: $990 jeans) — was not the most controversial in this particular issue. That honor went to the portraits of disturbingly sexualized 6-year-olds.
These images are the six different covers Karl shot for German photography magazine Stern Fotografie’s 60th anniversary issue. When they came out in 2010, Fashionista called the covers “everything from crazy and sexy to mildly racist and altogether strange.” Complex wrote, “At least he didn’t style her as a geisha or a slave.” But the two tags on the Complex post say it all: “fashion, racism.”
Contance Jablonski poses with a black baby in a prairie! Why couldn’t Numéro hire a black model, especially when they’re woefully underrepresented on the runways and in fashion magazines? Good luck figuring that one out.
Bloggers were disgusted by this alleged outfit. The Frisky wrote, “‘Sexy Little Geisha’ is part of a ‘Go East’ line, which, again, is not in-and-of-itself racist. This particular execution just makes me, well, want to execute myself.”
And these are just a few examples of the fashion industry’s puzzling insensitivity to race issues. I could spend all day pulling more, but you only have to Google “fashion racism” to come up with a slew of other roundups.
Victoria’s Secret may be a suburban-mall lingerie brand, but its fashion show exists on a rare high-fashion plane as well as a commercial one. Well-heeled fashion editors like Carine Roitfeld and painfully cool designers like Alexander Wang attend and adore the show (they don’t do the same for, say, Bebe). Costume designer Todd Thomas did not return request for comment about how the headdress made it all the way through the show’s creation process to the main stage. And I don’t buy Indian Country’s notion that Karlie Kloss did this to get back at an ex with Native American blood (models don’t get to choose their outfits for fashion shows). But it feels safe to assume it was just another moment that’s symptomatic of an industry that has a very hard time separating sensitive racial issues from artistry.
- Top legal scholars will be filing the 1st major lawsuit against President Donald Trump's alleged business conflicts on Monday.
- "Welcome to the movement": Women's March on Washington organizers are working tirelessly to make sure first-time marchers stick around ✊
- A mass grave in Mexico contained the remains of 56 people, many of whom went missing in 2010, authorities said Sunday.
- The New England Patriots are heading to the Super Bowl yet again. They'll play the Atlanta Falcons on Feb. 5 🏈