An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave The Floor After Getting Screwed
In the match that would decide who would fence for the gold, Germany’s Britta Heidemann landed a match-clinching touch. But was it in time? South Korea’s Shin A Lam didn’t think so. So she refused to leave.
1. The Stakes:
Germany’s Britta Heidemann and South Korea’s Shin A Lam had already fought to a draw in regulation. Whichever fencer got a touch next would move on to the gold medal round of the Women’s Individual Epeé. There was one second left on the clock in the extra frame.
2. The Moment:
3. The Complaint:
The clock never started! So Heidemann had more than one second to land the winning touch. At the very least, whether she landed it in time was highly in doubt. The match should have continued into another round, but instead Shin was declared the loser. So South Korea’s coach went to the judges.
4. The Ruling:
Despite the clock issue, they ruled that the touch was good and that Heidemann was the victor. South Korea’s coach went off to file a formal appeal.
5. The Waiting:
And Shin A Lam, now in tears, refused to live the piste (the platform that they fence on). In fencing, leaving the piste means that you have officially accepted the judges’ ruling. And seeing as the clock didn’t start, and she should still have a shot at gold, she sat down. It’s the filibuster of fencing.
She waited.
And waited.
And waited.
And waited. For 45 minutes, Shin refused to live the piste.
10. The Frustration:
Heidemann didn’t know what to do. She communicated with her coaches, but it was clear she was growing impatient. It’s hard to blame her. She had been named the winner and so had a gold medal match to prepare for, but obviously whether or not she was actually the winner was still in question.
11. The Second Ruling:
After 45 minutes, a judge came out with the ruling that the Korean appeal had been lost and that Shin had to vacate the piste. She didn’t.
12. The Stand:
Shin stood up defiant, resulting in one of the more striking images of these Olympics.
14. The Finale:
Security came out and took Shin away. The crowd gave her a standing ovation.
Shin went on to lose her bronze medal match.
HOT ON
Facebook Conversations
38 Responses So Far
- Contributions
- (Page 1 of 2)
- kirstens5 thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Win
- taylors1616 An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- rendyb An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- werenko thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is LOL, Win & OMG
- Henry Kuurx thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Fail, WTF & Delightful
- Josh Booxor An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s Cute, WTF & Fail
- Goroz Skinny An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s WTF, Geeky & Win
- Arie Tharp An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s Win, OMG & LOL
- Ariet Harpy An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s Cute, WTF & Win
- thatdudek thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is LOL, OMG & Win
- Wewe Garlic An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s Cute, LOL & OMG
- itscharmingjosh An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s OMG, Win & LOL
- dakudaku An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- kunalc thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is WTF & OMG
- Mae Day thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Timeless
- alejandrau2 An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- antoniovaldes An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- Chrischvz thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is WTF, OMG & Fail
- ADoA thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG & Win
- Amber McDaniel thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG
- richardleeis An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s Win
-
scottf16 9 months agoI didn’t see the whole match, so I have a question. How long had the timer been sitting at 1 second? If it had just turned from 2 seconds to 1 second, it would have taken a whole second to count down to 0 seconds. Therefore, the clock could have started, but appeared not to start because it had a full second left before counting down to zero. They need the clocks to be in tenths of a second to eliminate controversies like these.
-
- Meggan McGoldrick thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG
- ketchup An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s WTF & Trashy
- alexjewell thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Win
- nalanathenujam An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s OMG
- theraisingang thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Win
- GBach thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG & Win
- billm12 thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG, WTF & Fail
- stephanierm thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG
- lucil An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- Ziyal thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Win
- joelc8 thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG
-
anthonyw10 9 months agoHey, I analyzed the Buzzfeed video using slow motion and timecode after consulting with an FIE official and the FIE rule book, and it turns out that Heidemann makes her hit more than one second into the match. The FIE is not admitting this, of course, but the tape doesn’t lie. Please make sure to read the video description on YouTube for the full story.
-
- shannelv An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- WorldCitizen An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- sammyw thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Trashy
-
zakk4 9 months agoUnfair? And would it have been fair if the match had ended and Lam went through because of a stupid COIN TOSS before the match? Now that would have been unfair! You people have such double standards. Perhaps you have some other sinister reasons for your complaints, a dislike for the German athlete, perhaps? I can’t blame the German for not relinquishing her win. Having your fate decided by a coin toss - that’s just sick. At least this match got decided by an actual engagement; it could have gone Lam’s way easily, but it didn’t. Better than the other alternative anyway.
-
- daniellelittlefieldr thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is WTF
- pelit.fi readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
- Yann Marcotte An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- “shin a lam” is a hot search term for this page
- news.ycombinator.com readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
- teamliquid.net readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
- marshalls4 An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
-
jonw8 9 months ago“refused to live the piste” Why is it so hard to use the word LEAVE? I have a serb friend who always texts me “I’m living my house now” I is nowhere near EA on a keyboard or autocorrect. If you don’t speak english then don’t be a writer.
-
- Alejandra Villa An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s WTF & OMG
- oprahsweave An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- ninau An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- Joyce Lazarus thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG
- niemanlab.org readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
- Corey B. thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is OMG
- slate.fr readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
- madamecadet An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- youmightfindyourself.com readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
- montrealracing.com readers just made An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... hotter
-
dwightm2 9 months agoThe IOC should be extremely ashamed of how this was handled, and a formal apology should be made to Lam. The match was clearly awarded to the wrong athlete in this situation. There have been far too many controversies in this year’s games, to the point that I fully believe that the IOC has become corrupt and is no longer adhering to the same spirit and ethics that they claim to be holding the competitors to. The games have become a sham, and that is a shame.
-
-
- davido6 An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th...
- LeannL thinks An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... is Fail & OMG
- redleafloans An Olympic Fencer Refuses To Leave Th... and thinks it’s WTF
-
-
-
anthonyw10 9 months agoThis story really caught my attention. So I studied the video using time code and slow motion, and determined that Heidemann’s hit was definitely late by .3 seconds. Lam definitely should have won.
-
-
-
-
-
a90 9 months agoIf you had spent more time on your research than you did on your presentation you might have read that Olympic bylaws require a fencer to remain on the Piste (you know that thing they fence on?) while a ruling is being deliberated. She did not “refuse to leave”. Furthermore, you seem to be under the wrong impression as to the source of the complaint. Again if you had done your research, you might have uncovered that what actually transpired was that the clock had become stuck (you know, not counting down?) and so Heidemann had more time to complete the attack than she should have had.
-
-
-
-
-
-
tonyp18 9 months agoThe Olympics, like life, are sometimes cruel and blatantly unfair. But the Olympics are a part of life, and these things will happen — purposefully put into motion or not. These are tough lessons for someone who has trained for years for that one moment. But a lesson, nonetheless, and well, welcome to the world. It doesn’t compare to homelessness, poverty, etc., etc., etc. Move on.
-
-
-








Special Reactions
Your Reaction?
React with an animated GIF!
READY. SET. REACT!
GET STARTED