1. Leonardo DiCaprio
If we were Kate Winslet, there is no way we would let wither young Leo or older Leo drown. THERE WAS PLENTY OF ROOM ON THAT DOOR.
2. Jessica Biel
Did it hurt? When you fell down from (7th) Heaven?
3. Rider Strong
Boy meet World, World meet Shawn.
5. Heather Graham
Rollergirl still has it.
6. James Van Der Beek
Dawson may have left the creek, but he’s always got a place in our hearts.
7. Danielle Fishel
Oh Topanga… Who knew you had all of that hiding under those Amish clothes of yours?
8. Britney Spears
Britney may have her ups and downs, but the Princess of Pop still reigns supreme.
9. Joseph Gordon-Levitt
If we were Batman, we’d be crossing our fingers all those rumors about Robin are true.
11. Alyssa Milano
If you’re not charmed by Alyssa Milano, get your eyes checked.
12. Chris O’Donnell
Help us Batman! We’re in danger! Just kidding, we just wanted your attention.
13. Jared Leto
The 41 year old hasn’t looked bad a day in his life! Except for that time he shaved his eyebrows…
14. Tiffani Amber Thiessen
We would be late for class if it meant getting to canoodle under the bleachers with this high school hottie.
15. Justin Timberlake
Thank God JT brought sexy back. Thank him even more for not bringing that hair back with him.
16. David Charvet
The kind of lifeguard you would drown for just to get CPR. Then you would wake up and realize that he’s touching you and probably faint again.
17. Gwen Stefani
There’s no doubt that like wine, this rocker chick only gets better with age.
Can you hear our hearts beating? It’s going MMMbop, MMMbop.
19. Joshua Jackson
That Joey Potter has everything…
20. Christina Ricci
We would take Wednesday Addams any day of the week. Except for Monday, nobody likes Mondays.
21. Jonathan Jackson
Everlasting good looks and a smile that’ll make you melt.
For more of these 90’s heartthrobs tune in to the third season of Franklin & Bash June 19th on TNT!