1. Super Soaker 50
The iconic air-powered water blaster that started it all. You can pick up a new one starting around $80.
2. Totally Hair Barbie
The best-selling Barbie of all time. A mint condition doll in the box starts around $40.
3. Talkboy and Talkgirl
Probably the greatest movie tie-in ever. A Talkboy in working condition starts at about $30.
Now good luck finding cassette tapes to go with it.
You can get an original mint-condition Tamagotchi for around $42.
But, even better, there is an app version.
5. Sky Dancers
6. Nintendo 64
8. Spice Girls dolls
I’ll tell you what you want, what you really really want…these dolls! The entire set in mint condition goes for around $62.
So, I have no idea how to play this, or what it’s even about, but the commercial made it sound like this was one epic battle royal. The ’90s edition of the game, with all the pieces, starts at around $75.
10. Polly Pocket
Good News: They still make Polly Pocket.
Bad News: She got a weird kandi kid raver makeover.
You can get an original Polly Pocket starting around $16.
11. Talking Baby Sinclair
You can pick up a used doll for around $40 — which, when you think about it, really is a small price to pay to hear “not the mama” whenever you want.
12. Moon Shoes
They still make them! You can get a pair for $25.
13. Mighty Max: Skull Mountain
The best Mighty Max playset will cost you around $40.
14. Sega Game Gear
You can get an updated brand-new Sega Master System, which comes preloaded with 30 games from both Sega and Sega Game Gear, for $50.
15. Treasure Trolls
The original ’90s editions of these fugly dolls start at $5.
16. Nickelodeon Time-Blaster Radio Alarm Clock
OK, it’s not a toy, but look at this awesome thing! You can get a working one, in good condition, starting around $12.
17. Creepy Crawlers
You can get the ’90s edition of this longtime kids favorite for around $30.
18. American Girl Dolls
19. Fisher-Price Great Adventures Castle
A brand-new, still-in-the-box castle will cost you a king’s ransom! OK, more like $300.
20. Tickle Me Elmo
The ultimate fad toy of the ’90s starts around $9.
21. Nickelodeon Gak
Gak has made a triumphal return after being discontinued for over a decade. You can get it for $7.
22. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
24. Playmobil Victorian House
This amazing playset in used but like-new condition will set you back $420.
26. Batman: Wayne Manor and Batcave Command Center Playset
A playset in good condition starts around $40.
27. Easy-Bake Oven
You can pick up the ’90s edition of this perennial favorite for around $40.
The creepiest toy of the ’90s starts around $25.
They still make these! While it has does have slight update — a light-up feature — the rest of the toy is the essentially the same. You can get one for $6.
And remember, “There’s a counter on this ball, so try to beat your very best score, see if you can jump a whole lot more!”
30. Mighty Morphin Power Rangers
An unopened action figure starts at $23 — so, “Go go, Power Rangers!”