At this year’s Academy Awards, Alfonso Cuarón could be the first Latino man to win the Oscar for Best Director (for the sci-fi film Gravity) — and given that he’s won the Directors Guild of America award, he is by far the odds-on favorite to win. If he doesn’t, however, the man who has a strong chance of scoring an upset is 12 Years a Slave’s director Steve McQueen — who would be the first black man to win in this category.
And this would be a very big deal: More than perhaps any other people in the world, film directors have had the greatest first-hand influence on how we see ourselves for over a century, as they’ve steered tens of thousands of film productions big and small, driving and defining one of (if not the) most influential representation of our culture for just about 100 years.
But when one looks at the nominees and winners for the Academy Award for Best Director — the best barometer we have for whom the film industry regards as the finest film directors of their respective years — an overwhelming majority of them have been white men.
Of course, there is nothing inherently wrong with white male directors — so many white male filmmakers have deeply enriched audiences with their films, on topics that stretch far beyond their own personal experiences. Still, such a dominant art form would obviously benefit enormously from as wide a range of voices and backgrounds as possible.
While the Oscars hold no direct influence over which directors Hollywood studios and independent financiers choose to support, as our most high profile celebration of cinema, they can point the industry to who to regard as our best and brightest filmmaking voices.
3. Of the 425 nominees for Best Director, however, 96% of them have been white men from America, Europe, or Australia.
(Note: The first Academy Awards covered the years 1927 and 1928, and broke up Best Director into separate categories for drama and comedy. Both were included in this study.)
The directors who aren’t white men who received those 17 nominations are: Cuarón, McQueen, Ang Lee (for Life of Pi in 2012, Brokeback Mountain in 2005, and Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon in 2000), Kathryn Bigelow (for The Hurt Locker in 2009), Lee Daniels (for Precious: Based on the Novel “Push” by Sapphire in 2009), Alejandro González Iñárritu (for Babel in 2006), Sofia Coppola (for Lost in Translation in 2003), Fernando Meirelles (for City of God in 2003), M. Night Shyamalan (for The Sixth Sense in 1999), Jane Campion (for The Piano in 1993), John Singleton (for Boyz n the Hood in 1991), Héctor Babenco (for Kiss of the Spider Woman in 1985), Akira Kurosawa (for Ran in 1985), Lina Wertmüller (for Seven Beauties in 1976), and Hiroshi Teshigahara (for The Woman in the Dunes in 1965).
A quick note on Meirelles (who is Brazilian) and Babenco (who is Argentinian, and lives in Brazil): There is an ongoing debate over whether native-born South Americans with European ancestry are white or Latino. But for the purposes of this study about the racial and ethnic outlook of the Hollywood community — which has well established its lack of sophistication on race and ethnicity — it seemed most appropriate to classify these directors as Latino.
4. Those 17 nominations have resulted in only three wins, for two people.
Lee won for 2012’s Life of Pi and 2005’s Brokeback Mountain, and Bigelow won for 2009’s The Hurt Locker. And that’s it!
5. However, the Academy has made significant strides recently towards recognizing a wider range of filmmakers — most of those diverse Best Director nominations have been since 1998.
Though it’s still just under 14% of nominees, Lee is the only Asian man who has been nominated, and no women of color have ever been nominated, it is definite progress.
6. If you similarly look at just the last 15 years of Best Director winners, then Bigelow’s Oscar, and Lee’s two Oscars, make up nearly 19% of the Best Director statues.
Let’s be clear: While the chance to make history is certainly appealing to many members of the Academy, the reason Cuarón or McQueen could win Best Director this year is because of their painstaking and deeply affecting work on their respective films. Latino and black filmmakers, however, have been making painstaking, deeply affecting films for decades; what’s remarkable is that the Academy has only recently started to recognize them.
8. UPDATE: Curarón won Best Picture for Gravity, so the pie chart has changed!
- Justice Antonin Scalia, who served almost 30 years on the Supreme Court as one of its most prominent and influential conservative voices, died Saturday. He was 79.
- The four members of British indie band Viola Beach and their manager are believed to have died in a car crash in Sweden.
- And U.S. Republican presidential candidates had their nastiest debate yet in South Carolina last night 🇺🇸