How The Powerful #IfTheyGunnedMeDown Movement Changed The Conversation About Michael Brown's Death

"Don't judge my entire life based off one picture in the media without knowing me as a person or what I do that's positive."

Posted on

On Saturday, Michael Brown, an 18-year-old unarmed black man, was shot and killed by a police officer in Ferguson, Mo., outraging community members, who have taken to the streets in protest.

Mario Anzuoni / Reuters

There have been conflicting accounts of events leading up to the shooting. Police claim that the teen hit the officer who shot him. That account has been disputed by friends and family.

Following Brown's death, some news organizations began using a photo of Michael Brown extending his fingers.

Mike Brown, Facebook

The choice of the photo was criticized. Some worried that the gesture could be interpreted as a gang sign; others noted that it could be a peace sign.

Coverage of Brown's death has prompted a wider discussion about the way the media handles the deaths of black teenagers, like Jordan Davis and Trayvon Martin.

A Twitter movement was born where many black men and women — prompted by the question "If you died, which picture would the media use?" — tweeted side-by-side photos of themselves with the hashtag #IfTheyGunnedMeDown.

If you died, which picture would the media use? #IfTheyGunnedMeDown #MikeBrown http://t.co/lJMM9a0owk

The Root@TheRoot

If you died, which picture would the media use? #IfTheyGunnedMeDown #MikeBrown http://t.co/lJMM9a0owk

9:55 AM - 11 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

Larrell Christian, 21, currently active duty in the U.S. Marine Corps, told BuzzFeed he got involved because "it seems like when the police gun someone down they always use a thuggish picture."

#iftheygunnedmedown which picture would they use?

Name Ring BELLS@Heartbreak_Rell

#iftheygunnedmedown which picture would they use?

5:38 PM - 10 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

His contribution included a photo of him from boot camp.

"People should take notice because this is the society we live in and together we can put an end to it," he said.

Deontre Gray, 19, a student athlete at Ohio State University, says that it was important for him to post photos because "it seems that after a wrongful death, the media tries to twist it."

#IfTheyGunnedMeDown Which pic would they use

Run Tre@UnoDos_TRE

#IfTheyGunnedMeDown Which pic would they use

6:49 PM - 10 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

Gray contrasted a photo of him at a community cookout with how he looked on graduation day.

"Regardless of what that person does or did that may seem wrong to the world, it does not justify their death or give you the right to cast judgment or call them names such as 'thug' or 'gangbanger,'" he told BuzzFeed.

Unlike hashtags that may come and go after making their initial point, many feel #IfTheyGunnedMeDown is continuing to resonate because of how it taps into real concerns about how black Americans are portrayed in the media.

Akil Houston, assistant professor of cultural and media studies in the department of African American studies at Ohio University, said it shows the complexity of the conversation of media representations of black men.

Which picture would you use #IfTheyGunnedMeDown ? #Justice

Lance Tejada II@CantGuardL

Which picture would you use #IfTheyGunnedMeDown ? #Justice

12:25 PM - 13 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

"There is little room in the public discourse for complexity of black males and their identities," Houston said. "Whether someone is wearing a hoodie or sweatpants, they can still be a good father and have a job and take care of responsibility."

Paul Taylor, head of the department of African American Studies at Penn State University, said the media has a long history of questionable depictions of black men, recalling Time magazine's cover that was blasted for darkening O.J Simpson's skin.

Houston told BuzzFeed he talks to his students about black masculinity and how it is perceived in society. He said a largely white audience may see a black male in a hoodie and register him as a potential criminal, while African-Americans would say it's possible "the man is jogging or wearing leisure clothes."

Both Houston and Taylor said the more the black community seems under attack and the more the media disseminates harmful images, the more it will contribute to how African-Americans feel they are viewed by others.

"The more this sort of thing happens, the more people think, My god, black life does not matter in this place," Taylor said.

#IFTHEYGUNNEDUSDOWN #IFTHEYGUNNEDMEDOWN @GQNYU

CBAII@thelaureate_

#IFTHEYGUNNEDUSDOWN
#IFTHEYGUNNEDMEDOWN
@GQNYU

11:28 AM - 13 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

Taylor did say one positive to come from the conversation is the "increasing literacy young folks have with media images."

#IfTheyGunnedMeDown today what picture would you use America? Where is the justice.

Quinton Jones@QDOTjones

#IfTheyGunnedMeDown today what picture would you use America? Where is the justice.

12:33 PM - 11 Aug 14ReplyRetweetFavorite

"This sort of conversation used to be the purview of visual arts people," he said. "Young people grew up with this stuff and they're used to interpreting these images that are very sophisticated. They're thinking through the language of pictures in a way that's really quite striking."

For now, the case surrounding Michael Brown's death is ongoing, with Trayvon Martin family lawyer Benjamin Crump taking the case on behalf of Brown's family. The St. Louis County Police Department will continue to handle the shooting while the FBI investigates whether there were any civil rights violations. The police department won't release the name of the officer who killed Brown, and the St. Louis suburb of Ferguson has become a place where racial tension and mistrust between the black community and law enforcement continues to be high.

Senior Editor

Contact Logan Rhoades at logan.rhoades@buzzfeed.com.

Adrian Carrasquillo is the White House correspondent for BuzzFeed News and is based in Washington, DC.

Contact Adrian Carrasquillo at adrian.carrasquillo@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.