The tight-knit world of American anti-Islam activists in the U.S. discounted the idea that a video depicting the prophet Muhammad in an absurd and negative light played a significant role in inciting violence in Egypt and Libya during conversations with BuzzFeed today.
“I don’t think the movie is what kicked it off,” said David Reaboi, communications director for the Center for Security Policy run by Frank Gaffney. Reaboi said that his organization believes that the attacks were coordinated by Egypt’s Al-Noor party in order to get a plank onto the Egyptian constitution about outlawing blasphemy.
The protests that led to the violence of Tuesday night were over the offensive anti-Muslim movie, but U.S. officials said today that the attacks on the embassies, which took four American lives including that of the U.S. Ambassador to Libya, may have been organized beforehand by extremist groups in the region. The AP has reported that the video is linked to Coptic Christian activists in Los Angeles.
Reaboi said he hadn’t fully seen the film, or the 14-minute trailer available online: “First couple minutes was all that I could take, at least from a production quality standpoint.”
“There’s no shortage of pretext for Islamic rage based on Sharia blasphemy laws,” Reaboi said. “I don’t think the pretext is important as the doctrinal element when it comes to what makes these people become violent and crazy.”
“The fact is it has nothing to do with this movie,” said Robert Spencer, the director of Jihad Watch and ally of Pamela Geller. “This is obviously orchestrated and they’re looking for someone to get mad at about it.”
“They want us to think it’s our responsibility when they fly into murderous rages,” Spencer said. Spencer said he didn’t believe that outside events, like the film or like the Danish cartoons of a few years ago, “incite at all.”
Daniel Pipes, the founder of the Middle East Forum, said that “The anger is there. But it’s more than anger. It is a deliberate effort since 1989 to tell us in the west that we have to play by the rules of Sharia.”
Pipes distanced himself from the kind of rhetoric in the film, saying “People like me don’t touch that stuff. We have no interest in – we don’t say things like Muhammad is a pedophile. We don’t say things like Islam is a cancer. There’s a distinction between people who despise Islam, and people like me who despise Islamism.”
The video in question has been linked to Florida pastor Terry Jones, who promoted it and who gained notoreity two years ago when he announced plans to burn copies of the Quran in his Gainesville church.
Jones’ office would not put BuzzFeed on the phone with him or answer specific questions, but they sent a statement.
“The film is not intended to insult the Muslim community, but it is intended to reveal truths about Muhammad that are possibly not widely known,” Jones says in the statement. “The recent outbreak of violence and deaths is not because of the film, it is not because of the activities that we have done and that we will continue to do. These types of violent activities must be totally rejected. These people must be held accountable. It again shows the true nature of Islam.”
Please validate your account to contribute content.
Preview Your Response
- Maya O. thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is WTF
- benr11 thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is Fail
- Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is starting to get hot on Facebook Share It
If in the USA, xtians became violent every time a TV show or movie was made that bashed Christianity, who would be blamed? The people making the shows/movies or the xtians who’d become violent? The xtians, of course, would be called out for bad behavior and the xtianity-bashing shows/movies would be praised for speaking truth to power, etc. Muslims and islamists have to learn to behave like something other than thugs every time someone mentions mohammed or islam. It’s not about finding blame with the film-maker or even Terry Jones. What they are doing is USING THIS FILM AS AN EXCUSE to be violent, to commit murder, to harm innocent people. Period. They are thugs. Period.
- oddee.com readers just made Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us hotter
- jerrychia Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us and thinks it’s Trashy, Fail & WTF
- SAbukhater thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is Fail & WTF
The rightwing extremists and the islamic extremists are feeding each other. The rightwingers make a deliberately insulting movie, and the islamic extremists use it as an excuse to go and kill Americans, which the rightwing extremists use as an excuse to make more insulting movies about the muslims, which radicalises them still further. It is a deliberate escalation which will lead to more bloodshed. And how many will give up islam because of this? Nobody. The best way to get rid of religion is a dose of reality. Get them exposed to science, and they will slowly let go of their religion, but try to wrench it out of their hands, and they will hold tight and radicalise.
- amy swiney thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is Trashy & WTF
- baseballgirl thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is Ew
- Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is starting to get hot on Twitter Tweet It
- insomniacagnostic thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is WTF, Fail & Trashy
- rmadams thinks Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us is Trashy & Fail
- hwh97 Anti-Islam Figures: Don't Blame Us