Conservatives this week finally found their response to liberals’ favorite Mitt Romney story, his tale of strapping the family dog Seamus to his roof. The answer came in a passage in Obama’s “Dreams of My Father” in which the President admits that, as a young boy in Indonesia, he once ate a dog for dinner.
With Lolo, I learned how to eat small green chill peppers raw with dinner (plenty of rice), and, away from the dinner table, I was introduced to dog meat (tough), snake meat (tougher), and roasted grasshopper (crunchy).
Obama is unlikely to be rejected in November for eating the local food as a 7-year-old, though the juxtaposition of these two stories does underscore the extreme discomfort that exists in this country around the idea that some dogs are pets and some dogs are dinner.
And dogs are not, in fact, widely eaten in Indonesia either. Due to its predominantly Muslim population, which considers dog meat haram, the country has a considerably smaller dog-meat trade than some other Southeast Asian countries. Amongst non-Muslims, dog is often eaten as a festive dish at weddings or on holidays.
The shadow of a worker using a stick to club a dog before slaughter is seen, at Bambanglipuro village in Bantul, near the Indonesian city of Yogyakarta. The dogs are bought at about 150,000 rupiah ($17.50) apiece, and a meal of dog meat and plain rice costs about 8,000 rupiah ($0.90).
Rintek Wuuk (or RW), which means “fine hair,” is served in Manado, the capital of the North Sulawesi province of Indonesia.
A dog is slaughtered for meat at a makeshift slaughterhouse in Yogyakarta, Indonesia.
These images (and the vastly more horrifying ones that emerged from a recent investigation into the dog-meat trade in China) are certainly jarring, but the fact of the matter is that the squeamishness and outrage that this subject seems to generate is somewhat misplaced. When I raised this issue with Matt Prescott, who is the Food Policy Director at the Humane Society of the United States, he brushed it off:
Abusing dogs for their meat is certainly horrible. Though it’s important to note that the way chickens and pigs are abused on U.S. factory farms is also horrific, with animals crammed into tiny cages and crates, suffering immensely for much of their lives.
If that’s the case, we should probably drop this whole obscure Indonesian dog meat issue and ask both the candidates about these pictures. I won’t hold my breath.
- stefanieb2 thinks All About Indonesian Dog Meat is OMG
- All About Indonesian Dog Meat is starting to get hot on Facebook Share It
- toughlove2 thinks All About Indonesian Dog Meat is LOL & Fail
- a short haired girl All About Indonesian Dog Meat
- politico.com readers just made All About Indonesian Dog Meat hotter
- norisha thinks All About Indonesian Dog Meat is OMG
The broken heart was for obvious reasons
The heart was a thank you for actually acknowledging that we are no better for abusing and consuming different species of animals here on North america.
- ambercosmo + All About Indonesian Dog Meat
- fanaca All About Indonesian Dog Meat and thinks it’s Trashy, WTF & OMG
- MsSkeet thinks All About Indonesian Dog Meat is Fail
- foxnews.com readers just made All About Indonesian Dog Meat hotter
The Romney campaign has a point that we need to move on from this silly issue about dogs. I do, however, think there is a big difference between a 7 year old eating what his stepdad presented to him at the dinner table and a 30-something-year-old grown man strapping the family dog to the roof of the car; stopping the car to hose the dog down after said dog got sick and pooped all over himself; and then putting the dog back on the roof of the car.
- ace.mu.nu readers just made All About Indonesian Dog Meat hotter
- danimooseya thinks All About Indonesian Dog Meat is OMG & Ew
- All About Indonesian Dog Meat was rebuzzed by Donna D.
- All About Indonesian Dog Meat is starting to get hot on Twitter Tweet It
- danh16 thinks All About Indonesian Dog Meat is Fail