Deleted Facebook Photo Of A Gay Sikh Kissing A Man Sparks Debate On Sikhism And LGBT Rights

Facebook told BuzzFeed the photo was "mistakenly removed" and reinstated it on Kanwar Anit Singh Saini's fan page, but not before his account was suspended for 12 hours.

Posted on

On Sunday, 32-year-old Kanwar Anit Singh Saini posted on his Facebook page, "Sikh Knowledge," this photo of him kissing a man during a Global Day of Rage protest in Toronto against India's ruling criminalizing homosexuality.

By Monday, the photo had received more than 1,000 likes and 80 shares on Saini's fan page. It also sparked a heated debate on LGBT rights and Sikhism. Some posted vitriolic comments about Saini's picture.

At around 10 a.m. ET on Monday, Saini received a message from Facebook saying the photo had been removed because it "violates our terms and policies." His Facebook account had also been suspended for 12 hours.

So #facebook blocked me for the next 12 hours and removed this post of me kissing another man protesting #section377

Sikh Knowledge

@sikhknowledge

So #facebook blocked me for the next 12 hours and removed this post of me kissing another man protesting #section377

/ Via

Saini told BuzzFeed the post was important: "I got fans I want to reach out to 'cause of this whole 377 thing, and not to mention all the 'phobes spewing crap at me."

@facebook u guys suck. Do you see how important my post was? Homophobic morons are being hateful and violent, why not delete their posts?

Sikh Knowledge

@sikhknowledge

@facebook u guys suck. Do you see how important my post was? Homophobic morons are being hateful and violent, why not delete their posts?

/ Via

"The thread under the image was full of love and hate speech. It was SO important to see that banter and to have that visible," said Saini, a speech-language pathologist and a producer-DJ-artist in Toronto.

@MadTatterFilms i had a heated thread, but it was really interesting. So, for unknown violations, they removed it and banned me for 12 hours

Sikh Knowledge

@sikhknowledge

@MadTatterFilms i had a heated thread, but it was really interesting. So, for unknown violations, they removed it and banned me for 12 hours

/ Via

Others started sharing the picture on Twitter, Tumblr, and Instagram.

pic removed by FB on @sikhknowledge's page, getting <3 on #tumblr. http://t.co/hIOxr7TBFX @GayRightsMedia @Queerty @TasneemN. Share it up!

Shazad Hai

@shazadhai

pic removed by FB on @sikhknowledge's page, getting <3 on #tumblr. http://t.co/hIOxr7TBFX @GayRightsMedia @Queerty @TasneemN. Share it up!

/ Via

Others on Twitter criticized Facebook's policies on deleting content.

@sikhknowledge Yet when I try to report #anti-equality movements in Poland, #Facebook does nothing!

Mateusz Bernatek

@MJBernatek

@sikhknowledge Yet when I try to report #anti-equality movements in Poland, #Facebook does nothing!

/ Via

@sikhknowledge @SarbatSikhs Facebook has some weird double standards, bans a kiss, but allows posts of seriously disturbed cruelty etc: ....

Kate Robinson

@rob82840557

@sikhknowledge @SarbatSikhs Facebook has some weird double standards, bans a kiss, but allows posts of seriously disturbed cruelty etc: ....

/ Via

@alpacaaddict I like the way you describe Facebook. They have form for this kind of discrimatory behaviour. Unacceptable. Cc @sikhknowledge

Gisel-lala-la

@GrumpyMoll

@alpacaaddict I like the way you describe Facebook. They have form for this kind of discrimatory behaviour. Unacceptable. Cc @sikhknowledge

/ Via

Matt Steinfeld, a communications manager at Facebook, told BuzzFeed in an email that the photo was "mistakenly removed and has been reinstated."

"The photo was mistakenly removed and has been reinstated. We apologize for the inconvenience."

Saini said that people who don't know him resent how "openly queer" he is with the word "Sikh" in his artist name. "The small community I come from is a challenging one, but on the other hand, normative society is also a toughie for a queer person of color, so I'm screwed and not in the good way," he said.

"I have supporters who see the art and person behind what I do. I get threats to my life and hate speech regularly."

Saini said he was angry about the photo with the thread being deleted because his posts tend to "tease out important questions I want people to ask. So, the thread was people going back and forth with hate/rebuttals/logical rebuttals/dumb rebuttals...so important to our time in history."

Saini said he tries not to interact with trolls who hate on his page. He says he likes to make statements to "neutralize" all the "disdain" he gets from homophobes.

"How often do you see a guy in a turban not flinching to make out with another dude? Uhh never. So... bun down the system," he said.

Tasneem Nashrulla is a reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in New York.

Contact Tasneem Nashrulla at tasneem.nashrulla@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.