World

Many Outlets Are Censoring Charlie Hebdo's Satirical Cartoons After Attack

News outlets shy away from publishing the controversial images of the paper's satirical cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.

Originally posted on
Updated on

WASHINGTON — Major newspapers, television channels and websites have chosen not to run cartoons of Muhammad by the satirical French newspaper Charlie Hebdo after a deadly attack on its offices Wednesday.

In the United Kingdom, The Telegraph blurred out one of the depictions of Muhammad, which appeared on the cover of Charlie Hebdo:

How the terrorists win: @Telegraph is now blurring the cover Mohammed cartoon of #CharlieHebdo in its reporting

Yair Rosenberg@Yair_RosenbergFollow

How the terrorists win: @Telegraph is now blurring the cover Mohammed cartoon of #CharlieHebdo in its reporting

8:09 AM - 07 Jan 15ReplyRetweetFavorite

The Telegraph also used a tightly cropped image of Stéphane Charbonnier, the director of Charlie Hebdo known as Charb, who was killed when masked gunmen attacked the paper's offices, killing 12 people, including employees and police.

.@telegraph: You mistakenly cropped this picture a little tight.

Michael C Moynihan@mcmoynihanFollow

.@telegraph: You mistakenly cropped this picture a little tight.

8:50 AM - 07 Jan 15ReplyRetweetFavorite

However, The Telegraph reported that the BBC actually lifted its ban on depicting Muhammad, though the television station claims it did so before the shooting.

The Telegraph reported Monday that there was some confusion at the BBC because official policy stated Muhammad must not be depicted.

However, the television station seemed to counter that policy by showing Charlie Hebdo images as part of its coverage.

A spokesman for the BBC told The Telegraph that the Muhammad policy is under review. The television station said that it was already reviewing its policy before the attack.

"This guidance is old, out of date and does not reflect the BBC's long-standing position that programme makers have freedom to exercise their editorial judgment with the editorial policy team available to provide advice around sensitive issues on a case-by-case basis," the spokesman told The Telegraph.

The New York Daily News also used blurred images of the Muhammad cartoons. This shows a pixelated photo of the 2011 "Charia Hebdo" issue that depicted Muhammad on the cover, and for which Charlie Hebdo's office was firebombed.

In the second example posted here, the cover shown is the "Intouchables 2" cover from 2012, which did not even depict Muhammad on the cover — the cover shows cartoons of an imam and a rabbi. There were Muhammad cartoons inside the issue.

The editors of The Telegraph and the Daily News did not immediately respond to requests for comment about the decision to censor the images.

But the New York Times explained their decision not to show the images in an email from a spokesperson: "Under Times standards, we do not normally publish images or other material deliberately intended to offend religious sensibilities. After careful consideration, Times editors decided that describing the cartoons in question would give readers sufficient information to understand today's story."

Other outlets made more subtle choices to censor the images, with some using cropped photos that do not include the actual image of Muhammad. Three images of Charb were released on the Associated Press wire after the shooting, and none of them included a photo of the cover itself.

AP spokesman Paul Colford told BuzzFeed News, "You're correct: None of the images distributed by AP showed cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad. It's been our policy for years that we refrain from moving deliberately provocative images."

Many news organizations chose to use the above AP photo, despite the fact that the AP did have more than one photo of Charb holding the cartoon at the time in its system, and most of them show it.

AP took >4 photos of Charb with the famous cover. UK papers are, AFAIK, only using bottom right one. #CharlieHebdo

Jon Worth@jonworthFollow

AP took >4 photos of Charb with the famous cover. UK papers are, AFAIK, only using bottom right one. #CharlieHebdo

9:51 AM - 07 Jan 15ReplyRetweetFavorite

Shown the four images in the tweet linked above, which has now been deleted but included three photos that showed the cover, Colford said that those three photos were taken by non-AP staff photographers and were removed from the AP's commercial photo system later Wednesday. "The top right image in that tweet you sent – very much cropped by us to exclude the illustration – is the only AP staff-taken photo among the four. The other three are SIPA photos, automatically fed to AP's commercial photo division and now being removed from our system," he said.

The choices news organizations face in publishing the cartoons recall the controversy over a Danish newspaper's publishing of Muhammad cartoons in 2005 and 2006. The cartoons inspired protests and boycotts around the world, as well as death threats against the newspaper and cartoonists. Some outlets published the cartoons in solidarity with the newspaper, while others decided to censor them: CNN pixelated the images that it showed of the cartoon.

On Wednesday morning, CNN again reportedly showed pixelated images of the Danish cartoon and did not display images of the Charlie Hebdo cartoons. "As this distressing story continues to evolve we are actively discussing the best way of addressing the key issues and images across all of our platforms," a CNN spokesperson told BuzzFeed News. "Those conversations will continue throughout the day and beyond as the story develops."

A CNN memo obtained by Politico showed the network would not show images of the cartoons.

"Although we are not at this time showing the Charlie Hebdo cartoons of the Prophet considered offensive by many Muslims, platforms are encouraged to verbally describe the cartoons in detail," the memo says. It states that photos of the cartoons held by demonstrators during protesters are "OK, if shot wide."

CNN is not the only network not showing the cartoons — in fact, all the major networks and cable channels are declining to show them. Asked whether NBC News would show images of the Muhammad cartoons in the course of its reporting on the story, a NBC News spokesperson said, "Our NBC News Group Standards team has sent guidance to NBC News, MSNBC, and CNBC not to show headlines or cartoons that could be viewed as insensitive or offensive."

Spokespeople for both ABC News and CBS News confirmed to BuzzFeed News on Wednesday that they would not show the Charlie Hebdo cartoons of Muhammad, though a CBS News spokesperson said later that "CBS News will make an editorial decision based on the relevancy to the story." And Fox News, though it did show a shot of one of the cartoons earlier, told the Washington Post that it has "no plans" to air it again.

Stephen Pollard, the editor of the Jewish Chronicle in the U.K., tweeted on Wednesday that news organizations like his face a special risk if they choose to publish the cartoons:

Get real, folks. A Jewish newspaper like mine that published such cartoons would be at the front of the queue for Islamists to murder.

Stephen Pollard@stephenpollardFollow

Get real, folks. A Jewish newspaper like mine that published such cartoons would be at the front of the queue for Islamists to murder.

8:26 AM - 07 Jan 15ReplyRetweetFavorite

Easy to attack papers for not showing cartoons. But here's my editor's dilemma. Every principle I hold tells me to print them. But 1/2

Stephen Pollard@stephenpollardFollow

Easy to attack papers for not showing cartoons. But here's my editor's dilemma. Every principle I hold tells me to print them. But 1/2

8:15 AM - 07 Jan 15ReplyRetweetFavorite

what right do I have to risk the lives of my staff to make a point? 2/2

Stephen Pollard@stephenpollardFollow

what right do I have to risk the lives of my staff to make a point? 2/2

8:15 AM - 07 Jan 15ReplyRetweetFavorite

BuzzFeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith declined to comment on why BuzzFeed News is publishing the images in the course of its reporting on the story.

Rosie Gray is a reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in Washington, D.C. Gray reports on politics and foreign policy.

Contact Rosie Gray at rosie@buzzfeed.com.

Ellie Hall is a reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in Washington, DC. Her secure PGP fingerprint is 6055 A264 DADD AADC 347E 5986 547C C11C DD7D 176A.

Contact Ellie Hall at ellie.hall@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.