back to top
Tech

Should You Get A Surface Pro Or An iPad Pro?

New "pro" tablets from Microsoft and Apple want to replace your laptop — here are the pros and cons of each.

Posted on

The “pro” tablet is like a spork, which I've said before and will happily say again. Gadgets in this category have typically been unexceptional at both of their jobs: 1. being a tablet, and 2. serving as a laptop replacement. Tablets offer neither the portability of the other touchscreen device in your pocket — your phone — nor the performance of a desktop computer.

But Microsoft and Apple are trying to convince us otherwise. Both recently released new versions of their respective high-performance tablets: the fifth generation Surface Pro starts shipping today, while the 10.5-inch iPad Pro hits shelves this week. Curious. 🤔

So, if a tablet has “Pro” in its name, does that mean you can get real work done on it? After reviewing this year’s Surface Pro and iPad Pro I’ve discovered that, yes, it’s possible — but that it might not be the most efficient or pleasant way to get that work done, and that it largely depends on the type of work you’re doing. If you’re wondering whether you need a tablet at all, or which one you should buy, here’s a guide to the pros and cons of each.

Who should even consider getting a tablet?

1. People who have $$$$ to burn, bruh! Tablets are amazing luxury devices. They’re giant phones that make Facebook and Hulu and basically any app look uh-mazing. Plus, they’re fun for when you feel like holding a big ol’ slab of glass above your head in bed. FYI: You’ll end up spending close to a grand for a high-end one with a nice screen.

2. If you use digital textbooks or read/annotate lots of PDFs, get a tablet. Big touchscreens make it easy to zoom in and out of text and get up close to the media, in a way that makes doing the same thing on a phone feel cramped. If reading is your primary activity, you can probably get away with a regular tablet (like the cheaper iPad or new Galaxy Tab) with a third-party keyboard case and stylus. But if you *also* need to do some word processing (emailing, essay writing, and the like) and, occasionally, other stuff (playing games or watching HD movies) on the device, consider a pro tablet.

3. The styluses on these tablets are getting insanely good, and are even used by professional illustrators. If you’re interested in drawing or handwriting, these devices can be an alternative to paper sketchbooks/notebooks.

But pro tablets aren’t for everyone.

Touchscreens attract lots of finger grease (gross), and neither of the devices I reviewed for this article are particularly good for typing on laps, if that’s your thing.

Think about whether you really need a touchscreen. There are lots of ultra-lightweight laptop options (including this year’s Macbook and Surface Laptop, which weigh 2 and 2.7 pounds respectively) that might be more suited to your needs.

The new Surface Pro and 10.5-inch iPad Pro: Should I get the latest?

Advertisement

On the outside the devices seem like they haven’t changed much, but thanks to processor upgrades the new versions are as powerful as many laptops on the market.

If you’re a power-user and can afford it, you won’t go wrong with this year's models. But you could save a few hundred bucks by getting last year’s tablets (the 9.7 iPad Pro or Surface Pro 4), and spend the saved money on extra luxuries, like accessories or additional storage. You won’t miss too much.

You can read my full review of the 10.5-inch iPad Pro, but here’s the short version: It has a slightly bigger screen that can accommodate a full-sized keyboard, a faster processor (nearly double the speed compared to last year’s 9.7-inch iPad Pro), and a new feature called ProMotion, which makes all motion — scrolling, zooming, etc. — much more smooth and detailed.

As for the new Surface Pro, the details are below, but the bottom line is this: It has a bigger battery, a faster processor, and a new stylus (the Surface Pen) that’s updated to be more accurate and much more pressure-sensitive (you can tilt to shade, but only in the Sketchpad app for now).

Ok, let’s dive in.

It’s a very productive device.

Advertisement

That’s because the Surface Pro runs a desktop operating system, Windows 10, instead of a limited mobile operating system. You can stack multiple windows on top of each other, instead of just two apps side-by-side. You can also run the full version of Adobe Photoshop (a must for some designers and illustrators), and use browser extensions. There’s a trackpad built into the Surface Pro’s keyboard cover (sold separately), which makes precise actions that aren’t as easy with your finger, like selecting text, less of a pain.

The keyboard is great.

The keys are satisfyingly bouncy. I had no problem using it all day to type (and typing is 95% of my job). It has backlit keys (helpful for dark classrooms!) and shortcuts for sound, brightness, print screen, etc. — all the buttons you’d expect on a full-fledged computer.

It’s a great desktop machine that could absolutely replace your laptop.

Unlike the iPad Pro, it’s much more comfortable to work on at a desk if you’re using it for significant amounts of time. But you’ll need accessories to make it more ergonomic.

The Surface Pro has a port (mini DisplayPort) to connect it to an external monitor, which not only means you can see more things on screen at once, but puts that content at a more comfortable eye level too, so you don’t feel like you’re going to sprain your neck from craning over to look at a little screen. And if the Surface Pro’s tiny trackpad makes your thumb cramp, you can pair it with a wireless mouse.

There’s also a super-stable kickstand built-in that can be upright while typing or recline to 15 degrees, which happens to be a great angle for drawing.

As a Mac user, switching to a Windows device has never felt easier.

It's been a minute since I last used Windows, and I was nervous about having to re-learn the operating system. But, as it turns out, it's super easy to use the device right out of the box. I signed into the Chrome browser, and everything I needed — my saved passwords, bookmarks, extensions — were all synced and ready to go with little setup. It’s helpful that I work mostly with web apps (Google Docs, Gmail, BuzzFeed’s CMS) and software that essentially works the same way across platforms (Slack and Adobe Photoshop/Premiere).

You can easily work with additional devices, without special adapters.

There’s a USB port and a microSD reader built into the Surface Pro. It’s great for connecting a backup drive or dumping images from a camera. If you need to present something, cable adapters that connect the Surface Pro’s display to a projector (with a VGA or HDMI connection) are widely available and can be bought fairly inexpensively from Microsoft (~$40) or Amazon Basics (~$11).

There’s actually a place for the stylus.

Advertisement

There’s a new Surface Pen stylus (now sold separately at $100) for writing and drawing. It has an even stronger magnetic connection, so you can securely snap it to the Surface Pro without worrying it’s going to end up in the bottom of your bag (unlike with the older version). And if you want to be extra cautious, there’s a $5 Pen Loop with an adhesive side that sticks to the side of your keyboard cover.

If you need power, the Surface Pro goes all the way up to 1 terabyte of storage and 16GB of RAM.

You will, of course, need to pay for that top-tier computing power (prices below). If you’d rather poke your eyeball than read about ~specifications~, skip to the next section, Surface Pro Cons.

The following is really for people who need help choosing the right Surface Pro configuration for them.

There are three Intel processors to choose from: Core m3 (for really basic computing like web browsing, writing documents), Core i5 (for photoshopping, multitasking with a lot of tabs), and Core i7 (for video editing, gaming). You also have various storage options.

These are the latest chips from Intel (seventh generation Kaby Lake), and they’re faster and more battery-efficient than the previous version. I tested a maxed-out Surface Pro (with a Core i7, 512 GB of storage, and 16GB of RAM). It was absolute overkill, although editing 1080p video in Adobe Premiere was fun.

The Core i5 model with 4GB of RAM and 128GB of storage will be the sweet spot for most, but those using the Surface as their primary device will want more storage (256GB) because a full desktop operating system takes up a surprising amount of space (approximately 10GB).

It’s better at being a laptop than a tablet.

Even after shedding the keyboard, the tablet part of the Surface Pro, at over a pound and a half, feels much heavier and bulkier than the one-pound iPad. It’s also much bigger (at 12.3 inches vs. 10.5). For the tiny-wristed (hi, it me), it takes some arm strength to hoist the tablet up in the air.

And, for those who opt for the most powerful of the three models ― the Core i7 ― you’ll hear and feel the air running from the fan inside the device. It also runs warm when it’s working hard. The core m3 and core i5 models are fanless (read: quieter), and will run cooler.

The Surface Pro is supposed to get 13.5 hours of battery life, but it got between 7.5 and 9 hours in my testing.

In my first battery test, I put the Pro in overdrive and, as I expected, didn’t get the 13.5 hours Microsoft promised. In my real world high stress test*, I got closer to 7.5 hours of battery life before needing to plug in. A less stressful test — with battery saver turned on and using Microsoft’s Edge browser instead of Chrome — gave me closer to 9 to 10 hours. But you’ll have to use Edge to get that kind of battery life which, ugh.** There’s also some battery drain overnight, even when the device is asleep, and it takes about two hours to fully charge.

A Microsoft spokesperson said the 13.5 hour claim is based on playing videos stored locally (not streamed), and said I received varied results due to factors like an active Wi-Fi connection, background processes, and browsing, which utilizes the CPU.

*I downloaded a software update, plugged the device into an external display, connected a wireless mouse, and had 16 Chrome browser tabs (a serious battery hog on any device), OneNote, and Slack open simultaneously.

**Edge also began crashing randomly, for no reason at all. TG for Google Doc autosave.

There’s still no em dash keyboard shortcut. What the hell!

You can’t even rely on the trusty Microsoft Word alt+0151 code to type an em dash on the Surface Pro. You need to lift your arm, tap the touchscreen keyboard icon, switch to the numbers/symbols keyboard, and longpress the the hyphen key to conjure the mythical em dash. Also, the emoji keyboard is limited. I am annoyed.

Windows can be kind of funky.

Advertisement

Windows overcomplicates even simple tasks. For example, there’s a Settings app *and* a Control Panel app, and some settings options are in one and not the other, and vice versa. And even though I tested a top-of-the-line Surface Pro, there’s a weird delay between tapping a taskbar menu icon and the menu appearing, which means there’s a lag...by design?? Details like that make the operating system feel clunky and slow.

The Surface Pro doesn’t have ports that support new technology.

Specifically, it doesn’t have the versatile USB-C port, which can power the device, connect it to an external display, and offer super-fast data transfer speeds with a single cable. Those who have newer Thunderbolt 3 displays and accessories will need to buy adapters.

There are security and privacy concerns with Windows 10.

Microsoft has done a significant amount of work to toughen up its security, and Windows 10 is much more secure than older versions like XP, but it’s still not as secure as iOS, which only allows Apple-signed-and-certified apps to be installed. Bad actors are immediately revoked. Additionally, it’s incredibly difficult for malicious apps to execute code in the background in iOS (like a keylogger that records everything you type), because the system is designed to run one app at a time, and only allows certain functions to run in the background, like music, location, and downloading small amounts of content.

In terms of privacy, the Electronic Frontier Foundation came out strongly against Windows 10 for the amount of telemetry, or the data a computer sends to a company about itself, that Microsoft collects by default. The privacy policy reveals how sweeping this collection can be, especially with Cortana, the digital assistant built into Windows 10. It’s all or nothing with Cortana's location tracking (you can't use the assistant if you don't share it), for example, and Edge sends your browsing history to Microsoft to help Cortana produce better responses. Microsoft responded to the criticism by adding a setting that reduces data collection, but it doesn't eliminate it completely.

It has a killer display.

If you take a look at the specs, the Surface Pro’s screen actually has a higher pixel density (or pixels per inch) than the 10.5-inch iPad Pro’s, but the iPad’s display feels way better. Fonts on the Surface Pro just look kind of...crappy? Janky? Outdated? They're smoother and more attractive in iOS somehow.

Slide to compare fonts between the iPad on the left and Surface on the right:


The new iPad Pro also has that new ProMotion tech, which makes Safari webpages look like they’re attached to your finger when you scroll. Motion lag is virtually imperceptible, and it’s almost disarming when you use it for the first time.

The Apple Pencil is an amazing, pen-like stylus.

Microsoft lowered its pen’s latency (the time between putting your pen on screen and the “ink” appearing) to 21 milliseconds — but the Apple Pencil (sold separately for $100) on the new iPad Pro has a latency of just 20 milliseconds. When you use the two styluses, it’s clear which one feels more natural: the Apple Pencil, especially when sketching or writing in small print. (Here are the video versions of those GIFs.)

That may be because the iPad Pro uses a prediction model, which tries to anticipate where you’re taking the Pencil next, and that technology is now even better with ProMotion. Because of Apple Pencil alone, the iPad Pro is *the* tablet for you if you do a lot of digital drawing or writing.

You can take a look at this side-by-side video of the Apple Pencil vs. the Surface Pen on last year’s devices to see the difference. Note that there’s even less latency on the new iPad Pro (though the Pencil itself has not been changed), and that there's also less latency with this year’s new Surface Pro and all-new Surface Pen.

It plays nice with your iPhone.

You can receive and send text messages on behalf of your iPhone on the iPad. With a feature called Continuity, you can also start reading an article or writing an email on your phone and finish it on the tablet. AirDrop is another feature that allows you to share files wirelessly, over a combination of Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, with any other Apple device.

It’s less bulky and more lightweight.

The 10.5-inch iPad, without a keyboard case, weighs just over a pound. It’s thinner than the Surface Pro too (but doesn’t have a stand built-in).

The camera is legit.

Not that anyone should be taking pictures with their tablet, but the iPad Pro’s camera is as good as the iPhone 7’s now: it’s got a 12-megapixel rear camera with optical image stabilization, Live Photos, and more, and it has a 7-megapixel front-facing camera. The Surface’s rear camera is just 8-megapixel, with a 5-megapixel selfie/Skype cam.

iOS is more secure.

As I’ve already discussed, the apps that you can install through the iOS’s App Store are rigorously vetted. And while Apple also collects data to share with app developers or itself, you can easily turn this off in the Settings app's privacy tab. iOS also gives you the option to limit ad tracking, and lets you see exactly what information is being shared with advertisers for in-app ads.

When you talk to Apple’s digital assistant, Siri, your queries are processed locally on the device when possible, and anonymized if they are sent to the cloud. The Siri data is then purged every six months.

Where am I supposed to put this Apple Pencil?!

There’s no good Apple Pencil solution. It doesn’t magnetically attach to the device, so you need to buy an accessory. Apple offers one case, a leather sleeve for $129, with a Pencil holder. But that doesn’t even include the Smart Keyboard cover, which costs $159. Why, Apple, could you not just put a little pen loop on the Smart Keyboard cover? Why?? *shakes fist at iPhone*

Additionally, that precarious charging cap has got to go. It's tiny. It will be lost. Please don't make us buy new ones.

You’re going to have to wait until the fall to get Apple’s newest iPad features.

The newest version of iOS, iOS 11, doesn’t ship for around another three months, and it’s chock-full of iPad-centric updates. You’ll be able to drag and drop things, quickly open Notes from the lockscreen (similar to swiping to open the camera on your iPhone currently), and manage files in an actual Files app. That good-as-heck camera will also come in handy for the built-in document scanner in the remodeled Notes app. The text in handwritten notes will be searchable as well. But you won’t be able to try it until around September time, when Apple typically rolls out the latest version of its mobile operating system to the public.

Wow. I was able drag four *different* stacks of objects with four fingers (!) on my left hand. Very, very impressiv… https://t.co/6LCBNMBgRc

You might sprain your neck working on the iPad all day.

The new full-sized keyboard feels nice, but iPads are not meant for all-day work. You could put the tablet on a more ergonomic stand, but you’ll have to lift your arm to interact with the screen, because it doesn’t allow for wireless mouse input. You could use one of Apple’s $50 adapters and connect it to an external display, but neither are designed to extend the iPad’s display (it’ll only mirror them). Additionally, some content, like Netflix and iTunes movies, can only be streamed through Apple TV, and not through the adapter.

iOS is not built for serious, multi-tasking power-users.

It’s great for the road because it’s lightweight and has decent battery life (10 hours, which is consistent with my testing). But it’s not built for multi-tasking. You can’t open two windows of the same app side-by-side unless it’s in the Safari web browser, which is problematic for people who live in Google Docs. You can’t even work around the restriction by opening Google Docs in Safari — the browser will force the app to open.

If you want a touchscreen device that feels more like a laptop than a tablet, get the Surface Pro. There's a cellular LTE version of the Surface Pro coming out later this year. Those who work on the road may want to wait for that. If you can’t bear to switch to Windows, try the Chromebook Pro (which has a touchscreen) or the ultra-slim Macbook laptop (which doesn’t).

If you want a device that’s better for drawing or writing, get an iPad Pro and an Apple Pencil. Whatever you do: don’t engrave the dang thing! (Better resale value.)

There's also an updated giant 12.9-inch iPad Pro. IMO it's too big and unwieldy for a tablet not running a desktop operating system, but 3D animators and other creative folks may want to consider it.

Here are all of the Surface Pro models available:

- 128GB / m3 / 4GB RAM: $799
- 128GB / i5 / 4GB RAM: $999
- 256GB / i5 / 8GB RAM: $1,299
- 256GB / i7 / 8GB RAM: $1,599
- 512GB / i7 / 8GB RAM: $2,199
- 1TB / i7 / 16GB RAM: $2,699

And accessories:
- Surface Pen: $100
- Surface Type Cover: $159

All of the iPad Pro 10.5-inch models available:
- 64 GB/WiFi: $649
- 256 GB/WiFi: $749
- 512 GB/WiFi: $949
- 64 GB/WiFi + Cellular: $779
- 256 GB/WiFi + Cellular: $879
- 512 GB/WiFi + Cellular: $1079

And accessories:
- Apple Pencil: $99
- Leather Sleeve with Apple Pencil holder: $129
- Smart Keyboard: $159

*If you’re a student, both Apple and Microsoft have special education discounts.

Nicole Nguyen covers products and personal technology for BuzzFeed News and is based in San Francisco.

Contact Nicole Nguyen at nicole.nguyen@buzzfeed.com.

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.

Promoted