back to top

Who Should Replace S.E. Cupp At MSNBC?

MSNBC's midday roundtable show The Cycle lost its lone conservative voice when S.E. Cupp jumped ship for CNN and Newt Gingrich, presenting the network with an opportunity to make a bold move and bring some much needed buzz to 30 Rock.

Posted on

With co-host S.E. Cupp leaving The Cycle, MSNBC will need a replacement — most likely a woman, to preserve the show's gender ratio. Here are some female pundits whom MSNBC might consider for the job.

Michelle Malkin

It's more than a long shot for many reasons, but the pugnacious Malkin taking on three liberals every day would be hard to resist for people watching cable news in the middle of the day.


Abby Huntsman

Young. Conservative. Plays nice with liberals (that's her with The Cycle's Krystal Ball). Plus, her dad, John Huntsman, could come on the show to clash regularly with Touré, à la Morning Joe's Joe Scarborough and Zbigniew Brzezinsk. Sorry, HuffPost Live, but this seems like a match made in heaven for MSNBC.

Michelle Bernard

Bernard, who has has worked for Patton Boggs and Bush-Cheney, is already an MSNBC contributor and is a favorite guest of Chris Matthews, appearing numerous times on Hardball and Matthew's weekend show, The Chris Matthews Show. Picking her might not be the boldest move, but Bernard is a solid commentator who could help the show pick up where Cupp left off fairly painlessly.

Senior Writer

Contact Dorsey Shaw at

Got a confidential tip? Submit it here.