Josh = Hot Mark Cuban
ABC / abc.go.com
Rob Kim / Getty Images
Dylan = Farquaad from Shrek
ABC / abc.go.com
Chris = Matthew McConaughey
Jason Merritt / Getty Images
Nick = Jason Segel
ABC / abc.go.com
Christian Augustin / Getty Images
Brian = Crabbe and Goyle combined
Warner Bros. / imdb.com
Mike = Present Day Bruce Jenner
ABC / static.east.abc.go.com
E!
JJ = Bill Nye The Science Guy
Frederick M. Brown / Getty Images
Steven = Louie Vito With Facial Hair
ABC / abc.go.com
Jason Merritt / Getty Images
Cody = A Toy Rubber Duck
ABC / abc.go.com
iStockPhoto
Brett = Maksim Chmerkovskiy
ABC / abc.go.com
Cindy Ord / Getty Images