1. Paper Towels
The obvious first choice -- try to get the kind that tear in thirds for minimal clogging issues.
Preferable to newspaper because the print won't rub off on your nether regions. Again, use in moderation.
3. 'Sanitary Napkin'
You'll want to use the really thin pink ones (the heavy-duty overnight kind are NOT recommended). Tearing in half might also be wise.
4. 'Sanitary Napkin' Wrapper
For desperate people and sensitive toilets.
Beware of paper cuts.
6. Toilet Paper Roll
You'll probably want to reserve this for #1 situations, and you'll also need to take the trash out pretty immediately. It works though.