Skip To Content

    "AHS: 1984" Gave Matthew Morrison An Elephant Penis And Viewers Couldn't Handle It

    Wow.

    So Matthew Morrison made his, um, ~big~ debut on American Horror Story: 1984 last night.

    FX

    ICYMI: The creepy anthology series was created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk, the same people who brought us Glee, which Matthew also starred in as Mr. Schue.

    Fox

    Good times.

    Fans of the high school drama were surprised to see Matthew, everyone's favorite glee club director, portraying such a different role on 1984, to say the least.

    They really gave Mr. Schue a big dick... #AHS1984

    Yup.

    That wasn't the only wild reaction to Matthew's character, Trevor, who has been hired as the activities instructor at Camp Redwood, which, of course, is being taunted by a serial killer on the loose.

    y’all better believe mr. schue is the killer i don’t make the rules #AHS1984

    Keep reading to see how other Glee fans reacted to seeing a new side of Matthew aka Mr. Schue, who I now have an attraction for. 🙈

    1.

    I bet mr schue’s penis is gonna get cut off #AHS1984

    2.

    thanks so much american horror story but i didn't need to see mr. schue’s naked butt

    3.

    My childhood has been ruined seeing Mr.Schue like this #AHS1984

    4.

    5.

    I haven’t seen Matthew Morrison in anything since Glee. I’m a lil disturbed at seeing Mr. Schue like this I- #AHS1984

    6.

    7.

    the plot twist this season is that it’s actually a prequel to Glee and this is how Mr. Schue ended up in Lima, running from his troubled past #AHS1984 #AHS

    8.

    Can’t believe mr schue packing

    9.

    10.

    11.

    y’all imagine they sitting around the campfire and then mr schue is saying okay kids the lesson of the week is serial killer then they break out too song 😂 #AHS1984

    12.

    my friend watching ahs just texted me that mr. schue's dick is big, ask me how sick i am.

    13.

    what’s mr. schue gonna do? stab jingles with his giant boner????? calm down, boy. #AHS1984

    14.

    i like how all the #AHS1984 viewers aren’t calling matthew morrison by his name, but they’re calling him mr.schue instead

    15.

    recap of #AHS1984: saw mr. schue’s ass. did i want to? no. did i hate it? no. do i wanna see it again. perhaps.

    16.

    mr schue has NO BUSINESS hanging mad dong like this in American horror story 😭

    17.

    why is mr schue kinda sexy on ahs

    18.

    how did mr schue's bulge not get an opening credit mention? #AHS1984

    19.

    20.

    did i just see mr schue’s ass......

    21.

    I'm sorry, but the idea of Mr. Schue having a dick so big it flops around like a baby elephant's trunk is just too much for me. Add the awful mustache on top of that and this might truly be the most horrifying season yet. #AHS1984

    22.

    watching ahs and just saw mr schue’s ass i can’t do it

    23.

    Mr Schue??? Spit in my mouth?????

    24.

    .@Matt_Morrison brought a different kind of monster to the cabin. #AHS1984

    TV and Movies

    Get all the best moments in pop culture & entertainment delivered to your inbox.

    Newsletter signup form