1.
One of those Life Savers "storybooks."
2.
Lip Smackers lip balm — usually a variety pack with a few different flavors.
3.
An Invisible Ink book.
4.
Silly Putty, which you would promptly use to do the ~newspaper trick~.
6.
One of those plastic tubes of mini M&M's.
9.
A holiday-themed Pez dispenser.
10.
A plastic rainbow slinky.
11.
A Beanie Baby. And if you had siblings, you'd compare and be jealous of the one they got.
12.
Random school supplies — like gel pens, markers, even scissors and tape.
13.
Christmas socks, because those things are timeless.
15.
A random little game like Uno, Barrel of Monkeys, or Pass the Pigs.
16.
An ornament that you'd have no idea what to do with, since the tree was already up and decorated.
17.
And finally, one of those gigantic Hershey's Kisses that were impossible to eat, but still so delicious.
