• Buy Me That badge

We hope you love our recommendations! Some may have been sent as samples, but all were independently selected by our editors. Just FYI, BuzzFeed and its publishing partners may collect a share of sales and/or other compensation from the links on this page.

32 Online Only Beauty Products You Need In Your Makeup Arsenal

Hello, new makeup obsessions.

We hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a small share of sales from the links on this page.

1. Gerard Cosmetics Eternal Eyeliner, $17

2. Gerard Cosmetics Star Powder, $15

Highlighters really add that extra oomph and shimmer to your complexion, which is why I knew I would love these star powders. That, and because the packaging makes me feel like a 1950s Hollywood star. 💃 ⭐️

Get it on sale for $15 here. Also available on Amazon.

3. Gerard Cosmetics Lipsticks, $19

My lipstick collection has become heavily skewed towards liquid lipsticks, but I'm loving the red-orange payoff of Passion Play that's vibrant but not overly intense, and I find it way easier to put on than most liquid lipsticks because it requires less precision. #lazyornah

Get it here. Also available on Amazon.

4. Wander Beauty Flash Focus Hydrating Foundation, $40

5. Wander Beauty Exquisite Eye Liquid Shadows, $26

6. Wander Beauty On-The-Glow Blush and Illuminator, $42

7. trèStique Matte Color & Lip Balm Lip Crayons, $28

8. trèStique Color & Contour Bronzer Stick, $34

9. trèStique Define, Sculpt & Set Brow Pencil, $25

10. EX1 Cosmetics Invisiwear Liquid Foundation, $18.50

11. EX1 Cosmetics Blushers, $14.50

12. OFRA Cosmetics Long Lasting Liquid Lipsticks, $19.90

I first heard of OFRA from Kathleen Fuentes of KathleenLights, and Havana Nights & Miami Fever are the two liquid lipsticks she's created in collaboration with OFRA. Havana Nights is a slightly vampy brown-red I've been really into and will continue wearing well into spring and summer alongside my *brighter* colors. Santa Ana on me is a very pretty medium raspberry — the perfect pop of pink, not too dark and not too light. Plus, these legit smell like cake. 🍰

Get them here. Miami Fever and Kathleen Lights also available on Amazon.

13. OFRA Cosmetics Dupethat Highlighters, $24.95

14. Velvet59 Contour Is A Girl's Best Friend Palette, $45

15. Velvet59 Matte to the Max Liquid Lipsticks, $20

16. Velvet59 The Exotic Lotus Palette, $39

17. ColourPop Ultra Satin Lips, $6

This line has so many flattering shades to choose from, and all of them have high-quality pigmentation (for only $6!). My four faves are: The Rabbit - a bright fuchsia with a subtle blue sheen; Dopey - a dusty mauve; Lost - a warm-toned brown red; and London Fog - a cool-toned blue red, or as I like to call it, a BOMB-ASS FIRE ENGINE RED. 🚨 🚒

I also highly recommend their line of Ultra Mattes, which have even greater staying power.

Get them here.

18. ColourPop Super Shock Cheeks, $8

These Super Shock face products are some of the most buttery things I've felt in my life. I'm not even usually a blush person because of existing redness on my cheeks, but Flush'd is a gorgeous rusty deepened peach that I'd wear layered on top of a lot of foundation and concealer. Glo Up is a rich gold color that's a little more intense than Wisp, which is the perfect shade of champagne highlighter that I use all the time.

Get their highlighters here, bronzers here and blushes here.

19. ColourPop Super Shock Shadows, $5

9 out of 10 times I wear eyeshadow, I stick to gold/copper/brown tones, so it's obvious I'd like Sunset Blvd, which is a warm golden bronze in a pearlized finish. I also really like Beverly, which is a matte deepened blackberry and makes me feel so badass about my makeup choices. Actually pulling off a deeper color is something else entirely, so I use a ~very light~ hand when it comes to application. Wattles is a dusty beige pink in a satin finish.

Get them here.

20. Glossier Milky Jelly Cleanser, $18

21. Glossier Boy Brow, $16

22. Glossier Priming Moisturizer, $25

23. Makeup Geek Duochrome Eyeshadows, $6

24. Makeup Geek Pencil Liners, $9

25. Makeup Geek Foiled Eyeshadows, $10

26. Winky Lux Smoke & Roses Palette, $30

27. Winky Lux Marzia Lip Kit, $28

28. Winky Lux Lightbox Creamy Illuminators, $16

29. Saucebox Cosmetics Étude Palette, $50

30. Saucebox Cosmetics Single Eyeshadows, $11.50

31. Onomie Bright Concealing Elixir, $30

32. Onomie A.C.E. Illuminating Eye Treatment, $40

Me towards my new makeup: