Skip To Content
    Updated on Jul 12, 2018. Posted on Oct 21, 2014

    16 Homemade Cookie Butter Recipes To Get Your Fix

    Because sometimes buying delicious things in jars can get expensive!

    1. Homemade Cookie Butter Peanut Butter

    averiecooks.com

    Just when you thought peanut butter couldn't get any better... Recipe here.

    2. Spiced Cookie Butter

    chow.com

    LOOK AT DAT DUNK. This one spices up graham crackers with cinnamon and nutmeg. Recipe here.

    3. Southwestern Caramel Cookie Butter

    scarlettabakes.com

    There's an amazing caramel sauce used in this cookie butter, plus a cookie recipe to use it in. Recipe(s) here.

    4. Homemade Gingersnap Cookie Butter

    wineandglue.com

    This recipe uses gingersnaps, so it's got a little texture to it — perfect for this biscoff butterscotch apple pie.

    5. Insanely Delicious Almond Cookie Butter

    jessicainthekitchen.com

    Insanely delicious and insanely easy. This recipe also includes almonds, so it's basically a nut butter when you think about it/ignore all the cookies.

    6. Shortbread Cookie Butter Spread

    amyshealthybaking.com

    Bonus for this recipe: it only uses four ingredients.

    7. Insanely Easy Homemade Gingersnap Cookie Butter

    brunchtimebaker.com

    You can easily control the texture of this recipe by using more or less milk. Mmmm, milk and cookies <3.

    8. Gluten-Free Speculoos Spread

    glutenfreeonashoestring.com

    FINALLY, a recipe for tummies who aren't all about that gluten.

    9. Graham Cracker Butter

    crazyforcrust.com

    This recipe also includes a recipe for s'mores granola that uses this graham cracker butter, essentially making the happiest breakfast of all time.

    10. Low-Calorie Instant Homemade Cookie Butter

    foodiefiasco.com

    This is, essentially, an almond-y paste, but the flavors and consistency still totally get you to cookie butter. (Also, the only instruction is to "stir," so everyone can probably handle this recipe.)

    11. Paleo Cookie Butter

    wickedgoodkitchen.com

    This recipe is both gluten-free and vegan, because someone out there truly cares about you.

    12. Homemade Speculoos Nutty Cookie Butter

    youvegottotastethis.myrecipes.com

    There are two kinds of nuts (peanuts and cashews) and cookies, so you know what that means... it's healthy! Recipe here.

    13. Cookie Butter with Molasses

    pinkcakeplate.com

    Put the ~sass~ in "molasses." (You get the idea...) Recipe here.

    14. Brown Sugar-y Cookie Butter

    bettycrocker.com

    With nutmeg and vanilla, this cookie butter is simply going places. Really delicious places. Recipe here.

    15. Oatmeal Cookie Nut Butter

    thehealthyfoodie.com

    It's the beeeeeest of both woooorlds. This recipe has literally everything delicious in it.

    16. Speculoos and Cinnamon Spread

    seriouseats.com

    Two words: BROWN. SUGAR. Recipe here.