Skip To Content

    28 "Low-key" Matching Couple Gifts You Won't Be Embarrassed About

    Let them know that they're the straw to your berry!

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. Super adorable magnetic keychains to let them know that you whale love them forever and ever!


    Promising review: "This was perfect! The whales have a magnet to kiss! I put one on my boyfriend's key chain and the other one on mine. We are a long-distance couple and this was a cute gift. Whenever we are together the whales kiss." —Amazon Customer

    Get it from Amazon for $11.99 (available in two colors).

    2. Matching phone cases that, my friend, unlocks a new level in your relationship.

    RealDesignRocks / Etsy

    Get the pink and blue case set and the marble design case set from RealDesignRocks on Etsy for $32.35 (available from multiple iPhone and Samsung models).

    3. A set of fondue mugs for some quality dessert time to show them how fond you are of their company.


    Promising review: "What a great and fun idea! Very sturdy and cute, perfect for a little fondue party for two. Loved it so much I purchased another one as a gift." —Lisa Gogolinski

    Get a set of two from Amazon for $14.95.

    4. Minimalistic his and hers toothbrush holders to add a little more fun into your morning brushing routine with your boo.


    Get His, Hers, Theirs holder and personalized names holder from UncommonGoods for $17/each.

    5. Cosmo and Wanda pocket tees, because it would be fairly reasonable to say they're the most magical couple out there.


    Cosmo socks and Wanda socks are available as well!

    Get the Cosmo tee and Wanda tee for $20.23 each from BoxLunch (available in sizes XS–XXL).

    6. And! Onesies for every member of the family — even the four-legged child!


    Promising review: "These plaid PJs were a huge hit with my son and his family! The family jammie is a new thing that seems to be pretty popular everywhere. They love wearing these jammies together on weekends." —Jewels

    Get it from Amazon for $16.99+ (available in adult, children, infant, and dog sizes).

    7. Braided "lucky" bracelets that are subtle enough to wear on a daily basis, if floundering your lovey-dovey relationship isn't their style.


    Promising review: "Got these for my boyfriend and I. I love them, we have had them on for months!" —Jay Jay Tu

    Get it from Amazon for $8.90 each.

    8. Fun-patterened matching undies because obviously, you two are the perfect pair!,

    Get an one time order for $36 or start a subscription for $28/month (available in multiple sizes, cuts, and designs) from MeUndies.

    9. Plush bath rugs for bathrooms that can also be used on each side of the bed. The only thing that is better than morning sex is waking up to step on one of these super soft rugs.

    The Apollo Box

    Get it from The Apollo Box for $37.99 (available in two colors) each.

    10. Treat your ~Only-Wan~ to a cozy Valentine's Day at home with these bathrobes for a Star Wars marathon until they cross to the dark side.


    Promising review: "I got this for my husband for Valentine’s Day! He has an older Boba Fett robe that he loves, but I think he’ll be really surprised to get this. The material is soft and the appliqués are great! It features the chest plate, shoulder plate, and lightsaber of Vader. The hood is just a bonus. I can’t wait for him to see this beautiful robe. The Saga Continues!" —Karen L.

    Get both the Jedi Master bathrobe for $39.95 and the Chewbacca bathrobe for $29.99+ (available in eight styles) from Amazon.

    11. A spoon set, because nothing says "honey, I love being your little spoon" better than giving them these vintage-style utensils.


    Get it from Amazon for $27.

    12. Superhero bookends for your favorite little bookworm and their last stack of books that spark joy.


    Get the hero bookend and the heroine bookshelf from UncommonGoods for $25/each.

    13. Precious pillowcases that perfectly depict the fuzzy feeling you guys felt on your first date. Just try not to drool all over these, OK?

    Promising review: "I bought this set as a Christmas gift to split up between my boyfriend and myself. I was nervous that he would think it was corny but I couldn't resist purchasing this set. He LOVED it and used the pillowcase that same night." —Brittany

    Get them from Amazon for $29.99+ (available in three sizes).

    14. Crew neck sweatshirts featuring the classic love story of two best buds — peanut butter and jelly.

    Iconic Duo

    Get the peanut butter sweatshirt and the jelly sweatshirt from Iconic Duo for $42.

    15. Glow-in-the-dark Kindred The Eternal Hunters necklaces your gaming partner will truly appreciate and LOL for sure.

    Gadget4Entertainment / Etsy

    Get it from Gadget4Entertainment on Etsy for $29.44 (available in four types of chains).

    16. Or! This necklace set for you and your favorite person.


    Get it from Amazon for $9.99 (available in 11 styles).

    17. A low-maintenance marimo, aka moss ball, for your favorite angel. They last pretty much...forever — what a perfect symbol of your relationship!

    Apollo Box

    Get a set of two from Apollo Box for $29.99.

    18. Customizable passport covers for your next getaway with your S.O. since it's you two against the world!


    Promising review: "We are going on a vacation with some friends this summer and purchased several of these as gifts. We had them personalized with our friends' names. It was a big hit!" —H. Griffin

    Get it from Amazon for $17.95 for one and $31.95 for two (available in eight colors).

    19. And sloth luggage tags that'll inspire them to chill out, enjoy life, and go on a vacation with you.

    MadeOnTerra / Etsy

    Get a set of two from MadeOnTerra on Etsy for $9.99.

    20. Matching aprons to prove that cooking may not be their forte, but when you guys tackle it together — anything is possible!


    Promising review: "Very nice material and my husband loves it!" —Penny Morin

    Get two from Amazon for $27.99.

    21. Kitty mugs that will have them feline really, really loved. Look at this preciousness!

    Apollo Box

    It even comes with a cat spoon!

    Get it from Apollo Box for $21.98 (available in four styles) each.

    22. A cute reminder of the best game or movie you two enjoyed together with Funko Pop! figures.

    Hot Topic, BoxLunch

    Get the Rocket and Lylla set from Hot Topic for $18.32 and the Shuri & T'Challa set from BoxLunch for $18.90.

    23. A pair of customizable Converse sneakers to let them know you want to ~step into the future~ with them.

    Get them from Converse for $90 (available in sizes 3–16 for men, sizes 5–18 for women, and in six colors).

    24. A fancy decanter set all for yourself because what's theirs is yours, am I right?!


    Get it from UncommonGoods for $65.

    25. Laptop stickers that are totally for the pair whose idea of a Sunday fun day = staying home to play video games! Or, for the biggest player you know.

    JumperCat / Society6

    Get Player 1 sticker and Player 2 sticker from JumperCat on Society6 for $2.99/each.

    26. Femme pins to deck out their favorite oversized denim jacket or canvas backpack loud and proud.

    LittleWomanGoods / Etsy

    Get three pins from LittleWomanGoods on Etsy for $26.75 (available in eight styles).

    27. Dreamy Van Gogh-inspired rings that are clearly statement pieces.

    Apollo Box

    Get a set of two from Apollo Box for $26.99 (available in two sizes).

    28. And couple lubricants so you can have a great finish to your Valentine's Day with enhanced sensations.


    Get a pack of two from Target for $14.99.

    When you guys are darn proud to matchy matchy:


    The reviews in this post have been edited for length and clarity.

    Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides!

    Allison Krausman / BuzzFeed

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form