Skip To Content

    23 Products For Anyone Who's Obsessed With Peanut Butter

    You're gonna make everyone so JELLY.

    We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. Just so you know, BuzzFeed may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to shop from them. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and items in stock as of time of publication.

    1. A spoon you can personalize with your own name for when you're eating peanut butter in the best possible way — by the spoonful, of course.

    Promising review: "My husband loves peanut butter so I got this for him for Valentine's Day. He loved it! It’s such a unique gift, and it is great quality. I will get more for other people!" —Amber Bryant

    Get it from The Rustic Stamp on Etsy for $13.75.

    2. A 10-pack of organic peanut butter squeeze packs to bring on-the-go so you never have to be without your one true love.

    These are made with all-natural ingredients and are gluten-free, non-GMO, and made with responsibly sourced palm oil and honey, and are also kosher! (Also be sure to try the classic peanut, honey almond, classic almond, maple almond, vanilla almond, and chocolate hazelnut varieties).

    Promising review: "I really like the quality of these squeeze packs! They're perfect for traveling as we took them on our two week road trip. I wasn't sure we would need them, but wanted to have backup protein with us just in case. I'm glad we did! Also, my sweetheart took them with him on his mountain backpacking trip. They're lightweight and were easy to use on the trail. We will definitely be buying more." —QueenBee Debbie of SheMakesTheRules

    Get them from Amazon for $5.81.

    3. A peanut butter mixer that'll make stirring in the separated oils so much easier. Keep buying your fave natural varieties with ease.

    Made of chrome-plated steel that is FDA-approved, BPA-free, and designed to fit on 16 oz. jars with 3 in. lids. To clean, hand wash all parts with warm, soapy water.

    Promising review: "Peanut butter with oil at the top can be annoying, to say the least. I love oily nutritious peanut butter, and Mess Free Nut Stirrer solves that problem. Easy to use, and is sold with different size caps to fit most jars. Put it all together, give it a good stir, then remove the rod, which is self-cleaning, and remove the cover to enjoy your nut butter." —Ed Schwartz

    Get it from Amazon for $9.99+ (available in three sizes).

    4. A sweatshirt for staying cozy and repping your absolute favorite thing in the world, perhaps while eating some at the same time?!

    Get it from Iconic Duo for $42 (available in sizes S–L, also available in jelly).

    5. A pack of 18 Reese's candy products including milk chocolate cups, white chocolate cups, and pieces-stuffed cups so you can satisfy your sweet tooth, while varying which candy you use to do so.

    Comes with 10 classic milk chocolate cups, six cups stuffed with Reese's Pieces, and two white peanut butter cups.

    Get them from Amazon for $16.20.

    6. A recipe book filled with ways to use the best spread in existence. Not like you need ideas, but, ya know, it doesn't hurt in those moments when you decide to do something other than eat it by the spoonful.

    Promising review: "How do you rate a book based on peanut butter? The recipes have all been great, it arrived in perfect shape and the spiral binding allows for more practical in-kitchen use. I got this for my boyfriend, as he randomly tosses peanut butter on everything, I thought this book might help him do so with more aplomb." —The Queene

    Get it from Amazon for $3.82+.

    7. A 13-pack of delicious baked peanut butter cookies that'll make your PB-loving heart and tummy very, very happy.

    For extra, you can opt to add in chips (milk chocolate, semi-sweet, peanut butter, or dark chocolate), or peanuts! Cookies are made within 24 hours of order placement and shipped the same day. Plus, cookies are wrapped and heat sealed to maintain freshness.

    Promising review: "These are the best peanut butter cookies ever!!! Fantastic seller/baker. Order some for your family!" —shiloh1950

    Get them from BakeryByAnn on Etsy for $9+.

    8. An enamel pin so you can make sure you're always repping the good stuff.

    Get it from Hello Treacle on Etsy for $8.05 (also available in jelly).

    9. A peanut butter knife made specifically to help you stir your PB and scrape the jar clean — because we all know how annoying it is when there are those little bits left that you just can't seem to get, but know belong in your digestive tract and not clinging to the jar for dear life.

    Long blade size can reach the bottom of jars including 80 oz. Costco-sized jars, 36 oz. Adams, and 48 oz. Skippy. Made out of strength-treated stainless steel and durable, heavy-duty plastic. Plus, it's dishwasher-safe!

    Promising review: "One of the best inventions ever! Either for PB, Nutella, or even jelly, this knife makes it easy to get to and spread. Now I never have to get my knuckles smeared as I reach into the jar anymore. I love this product." —James N. McLimore

    Get it from Amazon for $12.99.

    10. A throw pillow case that'll help you decorate your living space in a way that truly speaks volumes about the wonderful, peanut butter-loving person you are.

    Get it from olcore on redBubble for $20.81 (available in five sizes, and two styles).

    11. A peanut butter sampler filled with six small-batch blends for gifting the fellow PB lover in your life, or you know, just treating yourself.

    Comes with the following varieties: Happy Trails Mix (peanuts, flaxseed, chocolate chips, raisins, and split peanuts), White Chocolate Pretzel (peanuts, pretzel pieces, and white chocolate chips), Snickerdoodle (peanuts and snickerdoodle popcorn), Chocolate Toffee (milk chocolate, bits of toffee, and rice crispies), Keep Smunchy (honey roasted peanuts), and Chocolate Coconut (peanuts, dark chocolate, shredded coconut, and almonds).

    Promising review: "One of my friends is crazy about peanut butter and I gave this to her for her birthday. She will not stop raving about it! She finished some jars almost immediately and tells all her friends and family to buy it for her next birthday. Definitely a great gift idea!" —Cristina

    Get them from UncommonGoods for $40.

    12. A tee to share a simple fact about yourself with others in the most efficient way possible. Anyone who dares to tell you that peanut butter isn't a food group may no longer exist in your life, sorry, I don't make the rules.

    Get it from Boredwalk Los Angeles on Etsy for $25+ (available in five colors, and men's sizes S–3XL and women's sizes S–2XL V-neck or crew).

    13. A lip gloss that'll be a must-add to your cosmetics collection. Sadly it doesn't *taste* like peanut butter, so please don't try eating it.

    Promising review: "I bought this gloss in the shade Peanut Brittle and I absolutely love it! It looks great with my olive skin tone." —Bekah

    Get it from Amazon for $6.50 (available in 24 shades).

    14. A two-pack of PB2 powdered peanut butter you can use in a variety of recipes: from baked goods to smoothies, or as a dip with fruit, or on some bread with jelly, or just plain — simply mix it with water first if you're eating as-is.

    PB2 is all-natural and free of artificial flavors, sweeteners, and preservatives.

    Promising review: "This is the first time ever trying powdered peanut butter and I stepped out on a limb buying a double pack. I am not disappointed!! I am in love with it and went to the store and bought bananas and crackers, (already had it on celery)! I am going to try to not eat it daily, but it's that good, soooo, I might have to! You won't be disappointed!!" —Lisa C

    Get them from Amazon for $16.99.

    15. A shower curtain for those whose obsession is so big, they experience PB separation anxiety while bathing. Also, is bringing a jar of peanut butter into the shower acceptable? Asking for a friend.

    Get it from Paisley Hansen on Society6 for $68.99.

    16. A box of peanut butter patties (left) and peanut butter chocolate fudge bars (right) to satisfy your sweet tooth with the only thing better than straight-up peanut butter — the beautiful marriage of flavors known as peanut butter and chocolate.,

    Get them from See's Candies: the peanut butter patties (left) for $25.50 and the chocolate peanut butter fudge (right) for $10.25

    17. A package of 30 peanut butter pill pockets that'll make giving your PB-loving pupparino their medication a lot easier and tastier.

    Promising review: "Only way I could get my dog to take her pills! No matter what I tried to hide them in prior, she always spit out the pill, or just didn't eat the food if I ground the pill up in it. My dog no longer takes pills, but I still use these as her treats! My dog is a toy breed, so I just break up the treat to make them last longer. THEY DON'T DRY OUT LIKE ALL OTHER SOFT TREATS!! My dog is old and has bad teeth, so these soft treats are perfect!" —Ms. C

    Get them from Amazon for $8.49.

    18. And a Bath Buddy for rewarding your doggo during bathing time. Spread a glob of the good stuff on this toy, stick it to the wall, and make them feel like they're in doggy paradise.

    Promising review: "I just used this for the first time with my dog who isn't a fan of water. I put a thin layer of peanut butter on the entire surface. He licked at it the entire time I bathed him. I struggle keeping him in the tub and he absolutely hates water around his neck, upper shoulder, and head. I gave him the easiest and quickest bath I've ever given him tonight. I'm so pleased with this product. Also, it stuck to my tile wall, (that's around the tub) just fine. Didn't fall off at all while my 80 lb. dog licked away at it. Well worth the money." —Kelly

    Get it from Amazon for $19.99 (available in two colors).

    19. A pack of peanut butter cookie mix so you can whip up your own warm and gooey and peanut buttery baked treats at home.

    Promising review: "It really doesn't get easier than this. It's not the same as made-from-scratch cookies, but I didn't need to mess with scooping out and measuring peanut butter. It just takes a minute to stir the ingredients together and they easily roll into balls. I had a few leftover peanut butter chips and I put them in the mix and they were extra decadent!" —Samie May

    Get it from Amazon for $1.98.

    20. A bag of peanut butter crunch ground coffee that'll seriously step up your morning cup of java. Anyone who tells you you're taking your obsession too far with flavored coffee is just a h8er.

    Promising review: "This is THE coffee for those who love peanut butter! Great peanut taste and a rich, smooth finish. Have not found another that even compares! That is why it is the first ever subscription product we have ordered from Amazon. Try it and you'll be hooked, too!" —K Murphy

    Get it from Amazon for $11.50 (available in 71 flavors, and whole bean or ground).

    21. A peanut butter and jelly eye shadow palette for a makeup option as sweet and lovable as the best sandwich in existence, aka any sandwich containing PEANUT BUTTER.


    Promising review: "I received this in the mail the other day. The packaging was well-done. The colors are pretty. The eyeshadow palette has a nice, sweet smell to it, being that it’s peanut butter and jelly!" —Kristin

    Get it from Amazon for $31.95.

    22. A tote bag with a words to live your life by. Seriously, in this house we don't hate against such nutty goodness. Also, does the photo on this tote make anyone else irrationally hungry? No? Just me? Ok.

    Get it from #PoptART products from on redBubble for $33.34 (available in sizes S–L).

    23. A jar of the WORLD'S BEST PEANUT BUTTER — don't @ me on this one. When all else fails, there is nothing like twisting off the lid, peeling back the seal, and digging your spoon into a big ole' jar of natural creamy Skippy, which is what I'm gonna do right now. ✌️

    Made with just four ingredients (roasted peanuts, pal oil, peanut oil, and salt). Plus, it's gluten- and tree nut-free, and certified kosher! Be sure to also try out the creamy honey variety.

    And of course some honorable mention brands include Jif, Peanut Butter & Co., Justin's, and Peter Pan.

    Promising review: "Peanut butter is one of my most favorite foods and this brand and variety is the best. Not waxy like some types, very little salt, and the perfect amount of creaminess." —Virginia Birkenbach

    Get it from Amazon for $5.58.

    Thank you all for your time, going ✈️ eat a jar of Skippy by the spoonful.


    Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.

    Looking for the perfect gift for any occasion? Check out all of BuzzFeed’s gift guides here!

    Allison Krausman / BuzzFeed

    Need A Shopping Buddy?

    Get great products - from pros in the fine art of buying stuff online - delivered to your inbox!
    Newsletter signup form