Here's Definitive Proof Mariah Carey Lost Her Voice After 1997

    A year-by-year analysis.

    So lately, people have been coming for Mariah, her voice, her legacy, etc. Here's a year-by-year analysis of her voice — after her prime — to silence any hater.

    1998:

    1999:

    2000:

    Mariah Carey - Vision Of Love 2000 Performance Era - Rainbow Era.

    2002:

    You & I (BET 2002 Stevie Wonder Tribute)

    BET

    2003:

    Mariah's whistle register is trained AF. She can run, scale, & emote with her whistles with incredible control.

    2004:

    @MariahCarey slaying Joy To The World in 2004 😭🎄😍 can't no one do it like Mimi. @BigJimWright add this whistle back

    2005:

    Mariah Carey singing "Vision of Love" in 2005. LORD JESUS HAMMERCY

    2006:

    2008:

    One of my personal favorites.. Mariah Carey singing "I Stay In Love" in 2008. Beautiful!

    2009:

    I Want To Know What Love Is (Alan Carr Show)

    2010:

    2012:

    2015:

    This is why I don't argue with people that say Mariah Carey can't sing anymore.. "Joy To the World" Acapella 2015.

    2016:

    TL; didn't watch all the vids: DON'T COME FOR MARIAH.