back to top
Food

The Definitive Ranking Of Cakes

And it's not even my birthday.

Posted on

19. Fruitcake

Excuse me, no. This is a serious and reprehensible crime against all baked goods.
Getty Images Thomas Northcut

Excuse me, no. This is a serious and reprehensible crime against all baked goods.

18. Black Forest Cake

Chocolate cake: Delicious.Chocolate cake with cherries: RIP, DELICIOUS CHOCOLATE CAKE.
Getty Images/iStockphoto Robyn Mackenzie

Chocolate cake: Delicious.

Chocolate cake with cherries: RIP, DELICIOUS CHOCOLATE CAKE.

17. Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

Maraschino cherries are basically out to destroy the good name of cake. See all of the above.
bettycrocker.com

Maraschino cherries are basically out to destroy the good name of cake. See all of the above.

16. Angel Food Cake

The first time you have angel food cake: "Ooooh, ANGEL food cake, it must be a heavenly delight!" *Puts cake in mouth* "Why am I eating a dish sponge???"
Getty Images/iStockphoto peanut_roaster

The first time you have angel food cake:

"Ooooh, ANGEL food cake, it must be a heavenly delight!"

*Puts cake in mouth*

"Why am I eating a dish sponge???"

Advertisement

15. Lemon Cake

zzzZZZzzz. Lemon out.
Getty Images/iStockphoto megatronservizi

zzzZZZzzz. Lemon out.

14. Cheesecake

Next time you eat cheesecake, remember you're essentially eating a solid BLOCK of cream cheese. Not worth it. Overrated. THERE, I SAID IT.
Getty Images/iStockphoto vaphotog

Next time you eat cheesecake, remember you're essentially eating a solid BLOCK of cream cheese. Not worth it. Overrated. THERE, I SAID IT.

13. Ice Cream Cake

Ice cream cake is a lie and it's fooled us all for way too long. Here are my qualms: It's impossible to cut, the cake-to-ice cream ratio is way off, the cake that is there is frozen and frosty, and the icing is always that weird whipped stuff.
Getty Images Jupiterimages

Ice cream cake is a lie and it's fooled us all for way too long. Here are my qualms: It's impossible to cut, the cake-to-ice cream ratio is way off, the cake that is there is frozen and frosty, and the icing is always that weird whipped stuff.

12. Red Velvet Cake

Red velvet cake tastes OK, but I can't trust any cake that's a brighter shade of red than Taylor Swift's lips.
Getty Images/iStockphoto Danny Hooks

Red velvet cake tastes OK, but I can't trust any cake that's a brighter shade of red than Taylor Swift's lips.

Advertisement

11. Yellow Cake

Yellow cake is like the friend you make a big deal about seeing when you run into them, even though you never talk, and you're all like, "Oh my god, let's get lunch!!" and you both know you never will.
Getty Images/iStockphoto Diane Diederich

Yellow cake is like the friend you make a big deal about seeing when you run into them, even though you never talk, and you're all like, "Oh my god, let's get lunch!!" and you both know you never will.

10. Marble Cake

White cake? Chocolate cake? You don't have to choose! What a gift!
bbcgoodfood.com

White cake? Chocolate cake? You don't have to choose! What a gift!

9. Pound Cake

Here's my case for pound cake: It's substantial enough that you can eat it like toast for breakfast and get away with it. You can eat it with fresh fruit and feel good about it. YOU CAN MAKE DESSERT PANINIS WITH IT. That's all. Cake by the pound.
Getty Images/iStockphoto adlifemarketing

Here's my case for pound cake: It's substantial enough that you can eat it like toast for breakfast and get away with it. You can eat it with fresh fruit and feel good about it. YOU CAN MAKE DESSERT PANINIS WITH IT. That's all. Cake by the pound.

8. Coffee Cake

This is cake that you're actively encouraged to eat for breakfast. It wins all the points.
gimmesomeoven.com

This is cake that you're actively encouraged to eat for breakfast. It wins all the points.

Advertisement

7. Banana Cake

Banana cake owes everything it has to the godly creation that is cream cheese icing. Without it, banana cake is nothing. With it, banana cake is everything.
makingahouseahome.blogspot.com

Banana cake owes everything it has to the godly creation that is cream cheese icing. Without it, banana cake is nothing. With it, banana cake is everything.

6. Coconut Cake

Like the cake you'd take to a gallery opening as your date because it's so simple and elegant and sweet and everyone loves it.
wetakethecake.com

Like the cake you'd take to a gallery opening as your date because it's so simple and elegant and sweet and everyone loves it.

5. German Chocolate Cake

The black swan to coconut cake's white swan. In my food dreams (aka all my dreams), I see a little winged coconut cake on one shoulder and a German chocolate cake on the other, telling me to do bad things. You can see which ranks higher.
finecooking.com

The black swan to coconut cake's white swan. In my food dreams (aka all my dreams), I see a little winged coconut cake on one shoulder and a German chocolate cake on the other, telling me to do bad things. You can see which ranks higher.

4. Funfetti Cake

This cake doesn't just bring the party. This cake IS the party. At the end of the day, if you don't like Funfetti, I don't like you.
thekitchn.com

This cake doesn't just bring the party. This cake IS the party. At the end of the day, if you don't like Funfetti, I don't like you.

Advertisement

3. Chocolate Cake

This picture is driving your salivary glands wild. There's no stopping it. You want this cake so hard right now. Back away from the screen, please.
Getty Images/Purestock Purestock

This picture is driving your salivary glands wild. There's no stopping it. You want this cake so hard right now. Back away from the screen, please.

2. Molten Lava Cake

There's only one way to improve chocolate cake and that's with a center of ooey-gooey hot fudge. Take me to the dark side.
foodnetwork.com

There's only one way to improve chocolate cake and that's with a center of ooey-gooey hot fudge. Take me to the dark side.

1. Carrot Cake

The undeniable winner. This cake has everything. Cream cheese frosting, spice cake, walnuts, VEGETABLES THAT THINK THEY'RE DESSERT. This cake deserves its place atop any cake stand. It's 24-CARROT gold. So in the wise words of the all-knowing Mindy Kaling:
pastichefinedesserts.com

The undeniable winner. This cake has everything. Cream cheese frosting, spice cake, walnuts, VEGETABLES THAT THINK THEY'RE DESSERT. This cake deserves its place atop any cake stand. It's 24-CARROT gold. So in the wise words of the all-knowing Mindy Kaling:

leave a slice of carrot cake at my door if you love me

Mindy Kaling@mindykalingFollow

leave a slice of carrot cake at my door if you love me

12:15 AM - 22 Sep 14ReplyRetweetFavorite