Skip To Content

    16 Of The Most Divisive Home Decor Trends That Our Readers Are Completely, Totally, And Utterly Split Over

    Say what about open floor plans...

    As someone who's always been super curious about home design — and watches way too many HGTV and random Discovery+ home reno shows in his spare time — hearing what real people think of all the design "trends" out there enthralls me to no end. That's why I've been polling you, our loyal BuzzFeed readers, on your home design opinions for over a year now...and your hot takes never cease to fascinate me.

    There are plenty of design trends that y'all pretty much unanimously dislike, like floating staircases. And there are lots that people can't get enough of, like gallery walls. But there's also a surprising number of trends that our readers are genuinely split over. Based on the numbers of folks who weighed in on the following trends (occasionally 100,000 or more!), these 16 are the most divisive ones out there. What do you think?

    Note: Before you ask me why the screenshotted percentages below don't add up to 100%, that's because there's always a third option on these polls of "I don't have strong feelings," which felt kind of unnecessary for this post. Carry on!

    1. Our first divisive trend actually starts on the exterior — the "modern farmhouse" look. This one's basically an even, only 6,000 votes separate them.

    44% think it'll stay trendy, 44% think it'll look dated quickly

    2. Another trend people are split over? Having lots of houseplants, I guess.

    38% of people like houseplants, and the same percentage of people dislike them

    3. There's only a difference of 3,000 people between those who love subway tile backsplashes and those who don't...

    40% like subway tiles and 37% don't

    4. ...and it may not be a perfectly even split, but I'm kind of shocked that people don't totally align on open floor plans?!

    56% think open floor plans will stay trendy and 33% don't

    5. You either love or hate the mid-century modern chandelier. There is no in-between.

    41% are a fan and 38% are not

    6. My tufted headboard is crying in the corner right now.

    35% of people like tufted headboards and 44% don't

    7. I thought the internet was sick of color-coded bookshelves...but BRB while I color coordinate all of my books immediately.

    35% like color-coded bookshelves and 42% don't

    8. If you dislike minimalism, 51% of people disagree with you.

    35% of people think minimalism will stay trendy and 51% do not

    9. Apparently, the jury's out on whether this Moroccan-inspired tile is cute or not when used as a backsplash. Clock that difference of 2,000 votes... 👀

    even split of 39% on whether or not people like Moroccan-inspired tile

    10. I've heard so many people refer to these house numbers as the "gentrification font," but apparently, not everyone agrees on them, aesthetically.

    38% of people like them and 30% of people don't

    11. Opinions on concrete flooring are pretty darn close!

    36% of people like concrete floors and 44% do not

    12. I'm personally of the mindset that mounting a TV over a fireplace is a neck-ache waiting to happen, but what do I know.

    29% of people like TVs over fireplaces and 38% do not

    13. All-gray interiors have people more or less split, too.

    32% of people like all-gray interiors and 41% do not

    14. Everyone has strong feelings about the waterfall kitchen island, it seems.

    46% of people like waterfall islands and 40% do not

    15. Also in the kitchen, the blue cabinet and gold hardware look could truly go either way.

    41% of people like the look and 47% of people don't

    16. And finally, you know how some people paint over brick to give it a cleaner, more modern look? This one is as close to 50-50 as it gets.

    even 40% split on liking or disliking white painted brick wall

    Do you particularly love (or loathe) any of the divisive trends on this list? Sound off in the comments below.