1. This first option replaces the Scottish blue and white with the black and gold of the St David’s flag.
It’s bold, there’s definitely nothing Scottish about it, but it does have a rather German feel. We’re not convinced.
2. Here the white of the St Andrews flag has been removed, and a Royal Standard covers the majority of the flag.
Here’s where it gets confusing. An independent Scotland would still have the Queen as their head of state, so the Royal Standard would still Scotland’s red lion. But despite this confusion, this flag would be really hard to draw. So it’s a no from us.
3. Again, the gold cross of Wales’ St David’s flag is incorporated.
Nice. But the St Andrews Flag is still clearly visible, which kind of defeats the whole point, right?
4. Scotland’s blue has been removed, while a border containing national plants has been added.
Daffodil? Nice. Shamrock? Sure. Rose? Makes sense. Thistle?! No. Just no.
5. All references to Scotland have been removed, and a Welsh flag incorporated.
This one makes sense. And adding a dragon to any flag instantly makes it 500% more badass. Though it does feel a little uninspiring. We’ll pass.
6. Scottish elements have been removed, while a Royal Coat of Arms takes centre stage.
The garland around the coat of arms is make up of objects from around the Commonwealth. A nice idea, but unnecessarily intricate.
7. The individual flags of the three remaining countries each get their own quarter.
But hang on, this one includes England twice? Apparently this is because it is larger than the other two nations. Yeah, good luck telling them that!
8. Same goes for this one.
9. This one, designed by John Yates, is a more modern take.
Though it certainly has a cracked iPhone look to it, we’re big fans of the originality on display here. This one keeps the Scotland blue to represent the fact it will continue to share the monarchy. But in that case, why change it at all?
10. Here the St Andrews flag has been removed, while the green and white from the Welsh flag make up the background.
Now we’re talking. The flags of all three nations are clearly visible, and it’s as simple a design as the one we have today. This is how you keep everyone happy.
11. This one… well, it’s pretty obvious what this one’s done.
Must try harder.
12. And finally, the blue here has been replaced with the black background from Wales’ St David’s flag.
We like it. We like it a lot. Yes, there is a still a white diagonal cross, but if that wasn’t there we’d be fundamentally changing a design that has been recognised around the world for centuries. Keep the design. Change the colours. Our sports teams will look pretty damn cool in red, white and black.