Can A Veiled Muslim Woman Also Be An American Hipster?

    "Wait, they hate us cuz we're Muslims? I thought they hated us cuz we were hipsters!"

    According to their Facebook page, "Mipsterz" are a cultural group/movement/identity who seek inspiration from both Islam and the "hipster" aesthetic.

    "It is an organic community and culture of individuals who want to chill with creative, critical thinking folks."

    Yesterday, they released a video of women in hijabs as they skateboard, fence, take selfies, and hang out, to the backdrop of Jay Z's "Somewhere in America."

    The women in the video are almost all professional models.

    And it also features Ibtihaj Muhammad, a member of the United States fencing team and a Muslim role model.

    The women are styled to combine the traditional Muslim headscarf with both traditional and Western outfits.

    Since its release, the video has garnered mixed responses on Facebook and Twitter.

    Responses have been polarized, and a wider conversation has been sparked about what it means to be a Muslim woman in America.

    This debate has been furthered by notable Muslim academics, such as Dr. Suad Abdul Khabeer:

    Somewhere in America? Somewhere in America there is Muslim sister whose scarf is slipping slightly as she nods off on her train ride coming off the late shift. Somewhere in America a niqabi is frustrated in a Muslim clothing store because the "L" sizing on the jlbabs they sell is false marketing. Somewhere in America a Muslim mother tries to sooth a screaming baby while she debates whether the scarf on her head is large enough for an impromptu breastfeeding session. Somewhere in America a Muslim woman giggles with glee after finding the perfect shade of plum. Somewhere in America a Muslim woman is grateful that her headscarf style will cover the choke marks on her neck. Everywhere in America, a Muslim woman's headscarf is not only some sex, swag and consumption, it also belief and beauty, defiance and struggle, secrets and shame.

    I know some people are celebrating this video and others criticizing it. I think it's pretty clear I fall in the second camp.

    And writers, such as Sana Saeed, a senior editor at The Islamic Monthly:

    I, like many Muslim men and, more importantly, women, feel really uneasy about a video released yesterday by the group (movement? cultural tour de force?) Mipsterz – Muslim Hipsters. The video, set to Jay Z's Somewhere in America, features well produced shots of stylin' hijab clad women strutting their cool in and around random urban areas. Aesthetically, it's really hip, smooth, fierce and, for all intents and purposes, cool.

    But that's about it...

    The process of creating 'normal' is also stripping us, especially women, away from central parts of our faith. The Mipsterz video is hard to stomach for so many because it throws the increasing Islamofashionista culture into your face. Catwalk ready, catwalk strut and catwalk 'tude seem so antithetical to what we know and expect, sometimes zealously, as Islamic modesty. This isn't about policing what we wear and how or about casting judgment, but about the sort of culture we're creating for Muslim women's dress that is no diferrent than the images and lifestyles sans hijab we criticize. The superficial culture we critique and claim is why we wear hijab is becoming our hijab.

    Within 24 hours of its release, the conversation surrounding the video is already nuanced and likely to continue.

    A common sentiment is that despite its pitfalls, the video deserves credit for starting a much needed conversation about Muslim female identity in the United States.

    Watch the full video below:

    View this video on YouTube

    Noor Tagouri, one of the models in the video, posted this response on her Facebook page the day after the video was posted: