Skip To Content
  • Thanksgiving badge

16 Magical Pie And Ice Cream Combos

You (probably) wouldn't show up to Thanksgiving without pants on, so why should your pie go naked?

1.

bonappetit.com / jeroxie.com

When your pie is plain and simple, you can get a little fussy (and crunchy) on the scoop front.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

2.

marthastewart.com / rachaelwhite.me

Match up super-rich pie with something light and zippy. Also, every pie looks pretty in pink.

PIE RECIPE + SORBET RECIPE

3.

saveur.com / cherryteacakes.com

Wait, what don't you understand about the magic of PB&J?

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

4.

foodandwine.com /davidlebovitz.com

There's a beautiful, secret little language that chocolate and bacon speak to each other. Shhhhh! Listen VERY CAREFULLY and you'll hear it.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

5.

foodandwine.com / davidlebovitz.com

Sweet potato pie may be old-fashioned, but on very special occasions it likes to CRACK UP and get a little NUTTY.

(sorry)

(not that sorry)


PIE RECIPE
+ GELATO RECIPE

6.

foodandwine.com / thetarttart.com

A demure, covered pie requires a little spice in its life.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

7.

bonappetit.com / epicurious.com

Never underestimate the power a fresh fruit pie after an entirely beige Thanksgiving dinner. Lavender adds a little flower power.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

8.

bonappetit.com / davidlebovitz.com

THE PUMPKIN IS COMING FROM INSIDE THE ICE CREAM.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

9.

foodandwine.com / brittanypowell.com

These two quirky individuals will date on the plate and get married in your mouth. True love!

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

10.

bonappetit.com / thekitchn.com

Taking the chocolate pie crust into account, you've got TWO forms of both booze and chocolate, so. That's pretty much all you need to know.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

11.

saveur.com / whiteonricecouple.com

Like an after-dinner cheese plate, except way more exciting.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

12.

smittenkitchen.com / scoopadventures.com

Cranberry sauce: not for everyone. Cranberry ice cream: for everyone.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

13.

foodandwine.com / completelydelicious.com

I mean, who are we kidding? Brown butter cinnamon ice cream can go ahead and pair its sweet self with anything, forever.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

14.

marthastewart.com / davidlebovitz.com

If you're confused about anything here, we should talk.

PIE RECIPE + ICE CREAM RECIPE

15.

marthastewart.com / leaveahappyplate.com

Between the cranberries and the evergreen-y rosemary, this combo gives a subtle little sneak peek at Christmas. PIE RECIPE + GELATO CREAM RECIPE

16.

Want more amazing dessert ideas? Sign up for the BuzzFeed Food newsletter and you'll get great recipes in your inbox twice a week!